Magmasaur vs. Forge: Which Smelting Solution Reigns Supreme in Ark?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether a Magmasaur is “better” than a forge in Ark: Survival Evolved doesn’t have a straightforward yes or no answer. It hinges entirely on your specific needs, playstyle, and stage in the game. While the Industrial Forge undoubtedly offers the fastest and most efficient smelting, the Magmasaur presents a unique, mobile alternative with its own distinct advantages, particularly in resource gathering and early-to-mid game progression. Therefore, a Magmasaur may be the right choice if efficiency is not your goal, while a forge might be better when you simply want the smelting done quickly.
Delving Deeper: The Strengths and Weaknesses
To truly determine which is superior for your Ark adventure, let’s dissect the strengths and weaknesses of each option:
The Mighty Magmasaur: A Living Forge
-
Pros:
- Mobile Smelting: This is the Magmasaur’s defining feature. You can smelt metal directly at the source, eliminating the need for long, tedious trips back to base.
- Resource Gathering Powerhouse: Magmasaurs excel at harvesting metal, stone, and crystal, often with significant weight reduction. They’re formidable gatherers.
- Lava Immunity: Navigating volcanic regions becomes trivial, granting access to otherwise dangerous resources.
- Combat Prowess: Magmasaurs are powerful combatants, capable of defending themselves and your resources while out gathering. They can even destroy Tek structures.
- Stone Fuel: Rather than wood or other burnable resources, magmasaurs are fueled by stone.
-
Cons:
- Slow Smelting Speed: Compared to a Refining Forge, the Magmasaur smelts metal at a significantly slower rate. Compared to an Industrial Forge, the rate is abysmal.
- Voracious Appetite: Magmasaurs consume food incredibly quickly when smelting, requiring constant feeding, especially when using the “searing spit” attack.
- Limited Capacity: The Magmasaur’s inventory space, while decent, is not comparable to the sheer output capacity an Industrial Forge system can achieve with dedicated storage.
- Water Weakness: Magmasaurs are vulnerable to cold temperatures and water, which can hinder their effectiveness.
- Level Limitations: Like any tame, a wild-caught Magmasaur has a level cap that will affect its overall stats and smelting efficiency.
The Industrial Forge: Efficiency Embodied
-
Pros:
- Unrivaled Smelting Speed: The Industrial Forge smelts metal 20 times faster than a Refining Forge. This is its primary advantage.
- High Capacity: Capable of smelting massive amounts of metal simultaneously, ideal for large-scale operations.
- Gasoline Production: Can also efficiently convert Oil and Hide into Gasoline, a crucial resource for many advanced structures and vehicles.
- Scalable Systems: Can be integrated into complex automated systems for continuous resource processing.
-
Cons:
- Stationary: Requires a dedicated base location, limiting its utility for on-the-go smelting.
- Resource Intensive: Requires a significant investment of resources to build and maintain.
- Fuel Dependent: Consumes large amounts of fuel (wood, thatch, etc.) to operate.
- Defenseless: Offers no inherent combat capabilities, making it vulnerable to attack.
- Late-Game: The Industrial Forge requires a high level to obtain, and a lot of Polymer, Organic Polymer, or Corrupted Nodule to craft.
Making the Right Choice
Consider these scenarios:
- Early Game: A Magmasaur can be a game-changer, providing both mobile smelting and resource gathering capabilities before you can access the Industrial Forge.
- Mid Game: If you need to smelt resources on the move and defend yourself while gathering, the Magmasaur remains a valuable asset. If you want to quickly smelt a lot of metal, then you might consider getting the Refining Forge, then the Industrial Forge when you can.
- Late Game: The Industrial Forge becomes essential for large-scale metal production and fueling advanced technologies. The magmasaur, although still useful, becomes less useful here.
Ultimately, the “better” choice depends on your priorities. The Magmasaur offers versatility and mobility, while the Industrial Forge prioritizes speed and efficiency. Many players find both to be valuable assets in their Ark arsenal.
It’s important to know more about the game beyond just forges and creatures. The Games Learning Society is an excellent resource for understanding the educational aspects of games, even those as complex as Ark. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more about the potential of gaming in education and research.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How good is a Magmasaur at smelting?
The Magmasaur smelts metal at the same rate as a regular Refining Forge, but it burns through its food reserves very quickly while doing so. It’s a decent option for mobile smelting, but not the most efficient.
2. Is there anything better than a Refining Forge in Ark?
Yes, the Industrial Forge is significantly better for smelting large quantities of metal quickly.
3. What is a Magmasaur good for in Ark?
Magmasaurs excel at collecting metal, stone, and crystal, are immune to lava, and can be used as mortar/base destroyers in PvP due to their magma ball attack. They are also good in combat situations.
4. Are Magmasaurs good at getting metal?
Yes, Magmasaurs are excellent metal farmers. They have a significant weight reduction for metal and can damage Rock Golems effectively.
5. What smelts metal quicker, a Magmasaur or an Industrial Forge?
The Industrial Forge smelts metal much quicker (20x faster than a Refining Forge and thus, the Magmasaur).
6. Is an Anky or Magmasaur better at metal farming?
The Magmasaur is generally considered better than the Ankylosaurus at metal farming.
7. Do Magmasaurs take lava damage?
No, Magmasaurs are completely immune to lava.
8. Can Magmasaurs destroy Tek structures?
Yes, Magmasaurs can damage all structures, including Tek.
9. What is a Magmasaur’s weakness?
The Magmasaur is weak when exposed to cold temperatures and water, which can hinder its effectiveness.
10. What is the cheat for Refining Forge?
The GFI code for Refining Forge is “Forge”. Use the command “GFI Forge 1 0 0” to give yourself one.
11. What collects the most oil in Ark?
A trained Dunkleosteus or Ankylosaurus using a pickaxe is generally considered the best way to gather oil in Ark.
12. What makes a Magmasaur smelt faster?
Nothing inherently makes a Magmasaur smelt faster. However, force-feeding it stone is the most efficient way to replenish its food while smelting. Stone replenishes the Magmasaur’s food level faster than meat.
13. Can you survive the volcano on a Magmasaur?
Yes, you can survive a volcano eruption while mounted on a Magmasaur as both the player and the Magmasaur are immune to lava damage.
14. What is the best tame to fight Magmasaur?
The Managarmr or Snow Owl are popular choices. The Managarmr can use its ice breath to freeze Magmasaurs from a distance.
15. Does water hurt Magmasaur?
While Magmasaurs can swim in water, prolonged exposure to water and cold temperatures weakens them. Their abilities cannot be used underwater or when it’s raining.
By understanding these nuances, you can make an informed decision about whether a Magmasaur or a forge is the better investment for your Ark: Survival Evolved gameplay. Both offer unique advantages, catering to different needs and playstyles within the game.