Is a Zweihander a Polearm? Unraveling the Truth About This Massive Sword
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether a Zweihander is a polearm is a fascinating one, steeped in historical context and often confused by its sheer size. The simple answer is: no, a Zweihander is not a polearm. While it shares some superficial similarities with polearms due to its length and two-handed grip, it fundamentally remains a sword. This distinction lies primarily in its design, function, and intended use on the battlefield.
The Zweihander: A Sword Unlike Any Other
The Zweihander, meaning “two-hander” in German, is a type of greatsword or ultra-greatsword characterized by its exceptionally long blade and handle. Developed primarily in the late 15th and 16th centuries in the context of the Holy Roman Empire and particularly the Landsknecht mercenaries, it was a specialist weapon. Unlike typical swords, the Zweihander was not designed for single combat or personal defense. Instead, it was wielded by a specific class of soldier, the Doppelsöldner, on the front lines of battle formations.
Defining Features of a Zweihander
- Size: Zweihanders were massive, with blades typically reaching 1.4 meters (4 feet 7 inches) or more in length, and entire weapons could reach well over 2 meters (6 feet 6 inches) and up to 8 feet.
- Weight: These swords weighed on average around 2 kg (4.4 lbs), though some could be heavier.
- Two-Handed Grip: As its name suggests, the Zweihander was designed exclusively for two-handed use. The hilt was much longer than a typical sword, around 25 cm (9.8 inches) minimum.
- Ricasso and Parierhaken: Many Zweihanders featured a ricasso, an unsharpened portion of the blade just above the guard, often with Parierhaken (“parrying hooks”) or side rings. These allowed for better grip and control, particularly during thrusting and close-quarters combat.
- Purpose: Its primary function was to disrupt enemy formations, break through pike lines, and provide a powerful offensive weapon. It wasn’t meant for intricate fencing like some swords.
Why the Zweihander is Not a Polearm
While a Zweihander shares the two-handed grip and longer reach of a polearm, it differs significantly in several critical areas:
Blade Design and Function
Polearms, such as halberds and pikes, feature a head mounted on a shaft. This head can take different forms, including a spear point, an axe blade, or a hook, and is specifically designed for thrusting, hooking, or hacking. The primary function of a polearm is to inflict damage from a distance and disrupt enemy formations.
A Zweihander, on the other hand, is still a sword, with a double-edged blade designed for cutting and thrusting actions. Though its size enables powerful blows, its primary design is for delivering cutting attacks and controlled piercing thrusts, not for the long-range reach that is the main strength of a polearm. The ricasso and Parierhaken also indicate its design for controlled sword use closer to the body.
Tactical Role on the Battlefield
Polearms were frequently used by entire ranks of soldiers, often as the primary weapon of infantry. In contrast, Zweihanders were utilized by specialized individuals, the Doppelsöldner, who were often employed to lead the charge or disrupt enemy formations, rather than a general infantry weapon.
Handling and Movement
Polearms are designed for leveraging reach and power. Zweihanders, while requiring a two-handed grip, are still wielded with sword techniques and movements, focusing on controlling the blade. While the size gives them a wide sweep, they don’t have the long-levered reach of a polearm and their movement is more about blade control.
Carrying Methods
Polearms are typically carried vertically or rested on the ground. Due to their size and the difficulty in sheathing them, Zweihanders were carried across the shoulder, like polearms, but that is a matter of practicality, not tactical role.
In essence, while a Zweihander’s size and two-handed grip might suggest it is a form of polearm, its design as a large sword with a specific blade shape and tactical function in combat, firmly places it in the category of swords.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the distinctions between the Zweihander and other weapons:
1. Is a Zweihander a Longsword?
Early Zweihanders were essentially larger versions of longswords, but they developed into their own distinct class of weapon. While they share a similar basic design concept, the extreme size and purpose of the Zweihander separates it from a standard longsword.
2. Is a Zweihander the Same as a Claymore?
No, they are distinct. A Claymore is a greatsword, and a Zweihander is an ultra-greatsword. Zweihanders are typically longer, heavier, and designed for a different tactical role than the Scottish Claymore, which was more a general purpose two handed sword.
3. How Long Was a Zweihander?
Zweihanders ranged from 1.4 meters (4 ft 7 in) to over 2.4 meters (8 feet) in total length.
4. What Was the Purpose of a Zweihander?
These swords were used primarily for fighting in pike-squares where they would hack paths through, knocking aside poles, possibly even lobbing the ends off opposing halberds and pikes and then slashing and stabbing among the ranks.
5. Why is the Zweihander Blade Wavy?
Some Zweihanders had wavy blades called Flammenschwert. These waved blades distributed the force of impact better, making the blade less likely to break. They also had a psychological impact, appearing menacing, and could deter opponents from blade grabs.
6. What is a Ricasso?
A ricasso is an unsharpened portion of the blade just above the guard. It allows a user to grip the blade in this area, giving better control in specific close quarter fighting.
7. What are Parierhaken?
Parierhaken are “parrying hooks” found on the ricasso of some Zweihanders. These hooks could be used to catch and deflect an opponent’s blade.
8. Is the Zweihander a Thrusting Sword?
Yes, while primarily designed for cutting, the Zweihander could also deliver devastating piercing thrusts.
9. What is the heaviest sword in history?
While the article mentioned Rajput king Maharana Pratap’s swords which weighed 25 kilos, this is likely a very exceptional case, not the usual sword. Zweihanders were never that heavy, despite their size.
10. Why is a Bastard Sword Called That?
A bastard sword, also known as a hand-and-a-half sword, is called so because it was not a single-hand sword and not a two-handed great sword, it was therefore seen as having no clear family, a “bastard” of the sword types.
11. How Effective was a Zweihander?
A Zweihander had a clear advantage against smaller swords, being capable of fighting multiple opponents or breaking through pike formations.
12. Why did the Swiss Outlaw Zweihanders?
Some Swiss cantons outlawed longswords because, as side arms they were too large and unpractical, and as primary weapons they were not big enough to compete with polearms.
13. How Thick is a Zweihander Blade?
The blade thickness varied, but generally they were around 1.7 cm thick at their base.
14. Is a Flamberge a Zweihander?
Generally speaking, a flamberge refers to the flame-bladed style of the blade, and was often seen on Zweihanders. But not all Zweihanders were flamberges.
15. Is Excalibur a Longsword or Greatsword?
Excalibur is often depicted as a longsword, and historically would most likely have been a short blade closer to the Roman Gladius for that period.
Conclusion
The Zweihander, with its impressive size and power, is a fascinating weapon from history. Despite its large size and two-handed grip, it is not a polearm, but rather an incredibly large and specialized type of sword. Understanding its design, tactical role, and handling reveals its unique place in the history of warfare.