Is Arthur Permanently Underweight in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is no, Arthur Morgan is not permanently underweight throughout the entirety of Red Dead Redemption 2. However, the narrative heavily influences his weight, particularly after he contracts tuberculosis (TB). While you can maintain a healthy weight, and even make him overweight for a time, TB will significantly hinder his ability to gain and sustain weight in the later chapters of the game. The disease progressively impacts his metabolism, causing him to lose weight despite consistent efforts to feed him. This is a deliberate design choice by Rockstar Games to reflect the debilitating effects of TB and to underscore Arthur’s declining health as the story progresses.
Understanding Arthur’s Weight System
Red Dead Redemption 2 features a surprisingly detailed and dynamic weight system that directly impacts Arthur’s core stats (health, stamina, and Dead Eye) and even his appearance, to a limited degree. Prior to contracting TB, manipulating Arthur’s weight is relatively straightforward:
- Overweight: Eating too much and not expending enough energy will cause Arthur to gain weight. This results in increased health but decreased stamina. Think of him as a tank, able to absorb more damage but slower and less agile.
- Perfect/Healthy Weight: Maintaining a balance of eating and activity keeps Arthur at a healthy weight. This provides a good balance of health and stamina.
- Underweight: Not eating enough or exerting excessive energy without sufficient caloric intake will lead to Arthur losing weight. This increases stamina but decreases health, making him more agile but vulnerable.
The game uses a hidden calorie system. Certain foods are more calorie-dense than others, and the rate at which Arthur burns calories depends on his activities. Rest also plays a crucial role, as it allows Arthur’s body to process the food and gain weight.
The Impact of Tuberculosis
Once Arthur contracts TB, the weight system is fundamentally altered. The disease acts as a constant drain on his resources, making it increasingly difficult to maintain a healthy weight. Here’s how TB impacts Arthur’s weight:
- Metabolic Impairment: TB significantly slows down Arthur’s metabolism. He burns calories at an accelerated rate, even when idle.
- Reduced Nutrient Absorption: Arthur’s body becomes less efficient at absorbing nutrients from food. Meaning he can be eating all the time, with little to no weight gain, and will rapidly lose weight.
- Progressive Weight Loss: No matter how much you feed Arthur, he will gradually lose weight as the disease progresses. This is a key narrative element that underscores the severity of his condition.
While you can temporarily mitigate the effects of TB by constantly eating high-calorie foods and resting, you will eventually reach a point where Arthur’s weight is permanently underweight. This is not a glitch or a bug; it’s a deliberate design choice to reflect the reality of living with a deadly disease in the late 19th century.
Managing Arthur’s Weight Post-TB
Despite the challenges, you can still attempt to manage Arthur’s weight after he contracts TB. Here are some tips:
- High-Calorie Diet: Focus on feeding Arthur high-calorie foods like big game meat (panther, cougar, wolf, alligator), stews, and cooked meats.
- Frequent Meals: Eat several times a day, even if Arthur’s hunger meter is not fully depleted. Think of it as constantly refueling his body.
- Regular Rest: Get Arthur to sleep regularly. Sleeping will help gain weight.
- Prioritize Health: Focus on replenishing Arthur’s health core whenever possible. This will help him withstand the effects of the disease for a bit longer.
However, understand that these efforts will only delay the inevitable. Arthur will still lose weight, but you can potentially slow down the process and maintain a somewhat healthier weight for a longer period.
A Narrative Imperative
Ultimately, Arthur’s weight loss is a crucial part of the narrative arc in Red Dead Redemption 2. It serves as a visual and gameplay representation of his declining health and eventual demise. While it can be frustrating to see Arthur become progressively weaker, it’s important to remember that it’s an integral part of the story’s emotional impact.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions about Arthur’s weight in Red Dead Redemption 2:
1. Can Arthur become obese?
Yes, Arthur can become overweight, though he won’t appear drastically “fat.” Eating consistently and resting without much activity will lead to weight gain.
2. How quickly can Arthur gain weight?
Arthur’s weight changes are limited to one adjustment per in-game hour and per screen fade (loading screens after sleeping, fast traveling, etc.).
3. Does Arthur’s appearance noticeably change with weight?
The visual changes are subtle. His face might become slightly fuller or thinner, and his clothing might fit differently. The changes aren’t always consistent, and some players report variations in how noticeable the weight gain or loss is.
4. What are the benefits of being underweight?
An underweight Arthur has increased stamina but decreased health. He’s more agile but can’t withstand as much damage.
5. What are the benefits of being overweight?
An overweight Arthur has increased health but decreased stamina. He’s more resilient but less agile.
6. How do I lose weight in RDR2?
Simply eat less and engage in more physically demanding activities, such as running, hunting, and fighting.
7. Does Arthur’s weight affect his performance in combat?
Yes. Being underweight or overweight can negatively impact Arthur’s combat performance. A healthy weight provides the best balance.
8. Can I avoid Arthur getting tuberculosis?
No. Arthur contracting tuberculosis is a fixed narrative event and cannot be avoided. It’s part of the game’s core storyline.
9. Is there a cure for Arthur’s tuberculosis?
No. There is no cure for tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2, reflecting the limited medical knowledge of the time period.
10. Does Arthur’s tuberculosis get worse over time?
Yes, the effects of TB become more pronounced as the game progresses, leading to increased weight loss, coughing fits, and a general decline in Arthur’s health.
11. What is the most effective way to keep Arthur at a healthy weight before he gets TB?
Maintain a balanced diet, engage in regular activities, and get sufficient rest. Avoid excessive eating or prolonged periods of inactivity.
12. Does John Marston’s weight work the same way as Arthur’s?
Yes, after the epilogue, John’s weight system functions similarly to Arthur’s before he contracts TB.
13. What happens if Arthur is severely underweight?
Arthur will appear visibly gaunt, cough frequently, and his health core will deplete more quickly.
14. Can I use tonics to counteract the effects of being underweight?
Yes, tonics can temporarily boost Arthur’s health and stamina cores, but they don’t address the underlying issue of being underweight.
15. Does the game provide any visual cues about Arthur’s weight?
Yes, Arthur’s appearance will change subtly based on his weight. Pay attention to his face, clothing fit, and overall physique.
Remember, Arthur’s journey is not just about being an outlaw; it’s about grappling with mortality and finding redemption in a world that’s rapidly changing. The weight system, especially in the context of his illness, is a powerful tool that Rockstar uses to convey this message.
To learn more about the impact of games on learning and player behavior, consider visiting the Games Learning Society website.