Is Being Hollow Bad in Dark Souls 1? The Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In Dark Souls 1, the question of whether being Hollow is inherently “bad” is nuanced and depends heavily on your playstyle and goals. Directly, the answer is no, being Hollow is not inherently bad. It doesn’t impose significant direct gameplay penalties. However, it does impact your ability to engage with certain aspects of the game, primarily online interactions and certain NPC questlines. Therefore, whether it’s “bad” depends on how much you value those elements. Let’s dive deeper into the intricacies of Hollowing and its impact.
Understanding Hollowing in Dark Souls 1
Hollowing is the default state of the player character after dying in Dark Souls 1. You begin the game as an Undead, marked by the Darksign, which prevents true death. Instead, you resurrect at the last bonfire you rested at, but in a Hollowed form. This form presents a withered, almost zombie-like appearance.
The Mechanics of Hollowing
The core mechanic linked to Hollowing is Humanity. Humanity serves two primary purposes:
- Reversing Hollowing: Consuming a Humanity and resting at a bonfire allows you to “Reverse Hollowing,” restoring your human form.
- Kindling Bonfires: While human, you can offer another Humanity to “Kindle” a bonfire, permanently increasing the number of Estus Flasks (healing potions) you receive when resting there.
The Advantages of Being Human
While Hollowing doesn’t inflict stat penalties, being human grants several advantages:
- Co-op: You can summon other players to assist you with challenging areas or bosses.
- NPC Summons: Certain NPCs can be summoned as allies for boss fights.
- Invasions: Being human makes you vulnerable to invasions from other players. While this can be frustrating, it also provides opportunities for PvP combat.
- Kindling Bonfires: This greatly increases the number of Estus flasks you can carry.
- Some NPC interactions: Some questlines will be unable to proceed unless you are in human form.
The Perceived “Bad” of Being Hollow
The “bad” of being Hollow mainly stems from the limitations it imposes:
- Inability to Summon: You cannot summon other players or most NPCs while Hollow. This can make certain areas and boss fights significantly more challenging, especially for new players.
- Missed Opportunities: You cannot kindle bonfires in Hollowed form, which makes Estus management more difficult.
- Aesthetic Preference: Some players simply dislike the Hollowed appearance and prefer to play as a human.
Strategy of Hollowing in Dark Souls
Depending on your play style, it could be advantageous or detrimental to the gameplay. Here’s a breakdown of the strategy of using Hollowing:
Hollowing as a Solo Player
If you prefer to play Dark Souls 1 entirely solo, the downsides of Hollowing are minimized. You won’t be summoning anyone anyway, so the inability to do so is irrelevant. However, the inability to kindle bonfires remains a significant drawback. Estus management becomes crucial, and you’ll need to rely more on other healing items and careful play.
Hollowing and Online Play
For players who enjoy co-op and PvP, maintaining human form is essential. The ability to summon allies can significantly ease the difficulty of certain areas, and the thrill of invasions adds a layer of excitement (or frustration, depending on your perspective).
Hollowing and NPC Questlines
Certain NPC questlines are contingent on being human at specific times. Missing these opportunities can lock you out of unique items, spells, and even alternate endings.
Practical Considerations and Choices
- Humanity Management: Humanity is a finite resource, although it can be farmed from certain enemies (like rats in the Depths). Conserving Humanity is crucial, especially early in the game.
- Risk vs. Reward: Reversing Hollowing makes you vulnerable to invasions. Weigh the benefits of co-op against the risk of being invaded by a potentially more skilled player.
- Strategic Hollowing: Some players intentionally remain Hollowed while exploring difficult areas to avoid invasions, then reverse Hollowing before tackling a boss.
Conclusion: Embrace the Hollow, or Embrace Humanity?
Ultimately, the decision of whether to be Hollow or human in Dark Souls 1 is a personal one. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer. Consider your playstyle, your goals, and your tolerance for risk. Embrace the Hollow if you prefer a solitary experience, or embrace humanity if you crave the camaraderie of co-op and the challenge of PvP.
Regardless of your choice, remember that Dark Souls 1 is a game about overcoming adversity. Whether you’re a Hollowed wanderer or a radiant human, the journey through Lordran will test your skill and your resolve.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Hollowing in Dark Souls 1
1. How do I reverse Hollowing in Dark Souls 1?
To reverse Hollowing, you need to consume a Humanity item and then rest at a bonfire. Select the “Reverse Hollowing” option from the bonfire menu. This will restore your human form.
2. What are the benefits of being human in Dark Souls 1?
The primary benefits are the ability to summon other players and NPCs for co-op, kindle bonfires for more Estus Flasks, and participate in PvP through invasions.
3. What happens when I die in human form?
When you die in human form, you revert back to your Hollowed state. You also lose any Humanity you were carrying as “soft humanity” (the number displayed in the upper left corner of the screen).
4. How do I get more Humanity in Dark Souls 1?
Humanity can be found as items throughout the world, dropped by certain enemies (especially rats in the Depths), or obtained by successfully defeating a boss as a summoned phantom in another player’s world. You can also gain Humanity by killing invaders.
5. Is there a way to prevent Hollowing in Dark Souls 1?
No, there’s no way to permanently prevent Hollowing. Dying will always revert you to Hollowed form.
6. Does being Hollow affect my stats in Dark Souls 1?
No, being Hollow does not directly affect your stats. However, it does prevent you from accessing certain features that can indirectly impact your character’s strength, such as kindling bonfires for more Estus Flasks.
7. Can I still be invaded while Hollow in Dark Souls 1?
No, you cannot be invaded by other players while in Hollow form. Invasions only occur when you are in human form.
8. How does Humanity affect item discovery in Dark Souls 1?
Having “soft humanity” (the number displayed in the upper left corner of the screen) increases your Item Discovery stat, which improves your chances of finding rare items when defeating enemies. The maximum item discovery bonus is reached with 10 soft humanity.
9. What is the “Usurpation of Fire” ending, and how is it related to Hollowing?
The “Usurpation of Fire” ending is a secret ending tied to Yuria of Londor’s questline. This questline requires you to embrace Hollowing and collect Dark Sigils. This ending drastically changes the outcome of the game.
10. Are there any specific items that are only available to Hollow players?
While no items are exclusively available to Hollow players, certain items are more easily obtained or relevant when pursuing specific Hollow-related questlines (such as Yuria’s).
11. How do covenants interact with Hollowing in Dark Souls 1?
Some covenants have different requirements or benefits depending on whether you are human or Hollow. For example, joining the Darkwraiths covenant requires you to be Hollowed and interact with Darkstalker Kaathe.
12. Is it possible to complete Dark Souls 1 entirely in Hollow form?
Yes, it is entirely possible to complete the game while remaining in Hollow form for the majority of your playthrough. This requires careful resource management and a willingness to forgo the benefits of co-op and kindling bonfires.
13. Does my appearance change as I become more Hollow in Dark Souls 1?
No, your character’s appearance does not change based on your Hollow state in Dark Souls 1. This is a feature of later Dark Souls games, but not Dark Souls 1.
14. Can NPCs go Hollow in Dark Souls 1?
Yes, certain NPCs in Dark Souls 1 can go Hollow as their storylines progress. This is often triggered by specific events or choices made by the player. A prime example is Siegmeyer of Catarina.
15. Where can I learn more about the lore and mechanics of Dark Souls games?
There are many excellent resources available online, including wikis, forums, and YouTube channels dedicated to Dark Souls lore and gameplay. You can also engage with the community and learn from experienced players. The Games Learning Society also provides insights into game design and mechanics, which can enhance your understanding and appreciation of the Dark Souls series. Check out GamesLearningSociety.org for more.