Table of Contents

Blood and Wine vs. Hearts of Stone: Which Witcher 3 DLC Reigns Supreme?

Quick answer

This page answers Is Blood and Wine better than Hearts of Stone? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Is Blood and Wine better than Hearts of Stone? It’s a question that has sparked countless debates amongst Witcher fans, and the answer, as with most things in life, is: it depends. While both are exceptional examples of DLC done right, boasting compelling narratives, memorable characters, and significant additions to the Witcher 3 universe, they cater to slightly different tastes. Blood and Wine offers a grand, sweeping adventure in a vibrant new region with a satisfying conclusion to Geralt’s story, while Hearts of Stone delivers a more intimate, character-driven tale with some of the most challenging and innovative boss battles in the entire game. Ultimately, choosing a “better” expansion hinges on what you prioritize in your Witcher experience.

Diving Deeper: Contrasting Key Elements

To truly understand the nuances between these two phenomenal expansions, let’s dissect their key elements:

Story and Narrative

Hearts of Stone boasts a tightly woven narrative centered around Geralt’s entanglement with Gaunter O’Dimm, a mysterious and malevolent entity, and Olgierd von Everec, a cursed nobleman. The story is dark, morally ambiguous, and explores themes of regret, ambition, and the consequences of one’s choices. Many argue that Hearts of Stone has a better storyline due to its focus and intricate character development.

Blood and Wine, on the other hand, presents a more sprawling narrative set in the visually stunning duchy of Toussaint. Geralt is tasked with investigating a series of brutal murders, leading him down a rabbit hole of conspiracies, ancient curses, and fairytale-esque characters. The immersive storyline and its connections to classic tales provide a refreshing change of pace.

Characters

Hearts of Stone features some of the most unique characters in the Witcher universe. Gaunter O’Dimm is a particularly compelling villain, and Olgierd von Everec’s tragic backstory adds depth to the narrative. Shani’s return is also a welcome sight for fans of the original Witcher game, and she provides a worthwhile romance option.

Blood and Wine is filled with more lovable characters, or at least, characters that are more easily sympathized with. Duchess Anna Henrietta is a strong and independent ruler, and Regis, a fan-favorite vampire, returns to play a significant role. The supporting cast is also memorable, filled with eccentric knights and quirky villagers. Blood and Wine has the more lovable characters.

World and Atmosphere

Hearts of Stone takes place primarily in the familiar landscapes of No Man’s Land and Oxenfurt, albeit with some notable additions and alterations. The atmosphere is dark and brooding, reflecting the tone of the story.

Blood and Wine, however, introduces an entirely new region: Toussaint. This sun-drenched land is inspired by the south of France, with rolling vineyards, medieval castles, and a vibrant culture. The stunning new region is a feast for the eyes, and the atmosphere is much lighter and more whimsical than the base game or Hearts of Stone. Blood and Wine introduces lots of new monsters. Blood and Wine features famous fairytale characters. Blood and Wine is much bigger.

Gameplay and Combat

Hearts of Stone is renowned for its incredibly designed boss fights. These encounters are challenging, requiring players to utilize all of Geralt’s skills and knowledge of enemy weaknesses. The boss battles are strategically and unique, demanding more than just brute force. Hearts Of Stone: The Boss Fights Are Amazing.

Blood and Wine expands upon the base game’s gameplay with new mutations, gear, and abilities. The combat is still challenging, but it’s often more about mastering Geralt’s build and utilizing the new tools at his disposal. Gameplay and Mechanics of the Blood and Wine DLC significantly expands all these features! You can expect spectacular boss fights, fairy-tale characters, thirty additional weapons, and many new monsters. But the vital game changer is the more intuitive interface, the ability to dye the armor, and twelve extra mutations.

Ending

Hearts of Stone has two different endings, each with its own set of consequences. The choice Geralt makes at the end of the story has a significant impact on the fate of both Olgierd and Gaunter O’Dimm.

Blood and Wine provides a more definitive fitting ending to Geralt’s story. While there are multiple possible outcomes depending on the player’s choices, the expansion ultimately serves as a farewell to the Witcher world.

The Verdict

Both Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine are masterpieces in their own right. If you prefer a darker, more character-driven story with challenging boss battles, Hearts of Stone is the better choice. However, if you desire a grand adventure in a visually stunning new region with a satisfying conclusion to Geralt’s story, Blood and Wine is the clear winner.

Ultimately, the best way to decide which expansion is “better” is to play both and experience them for yourself. You won’t be disappointed.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the recommended play order for the Witcher 3 DLCs? The recommended way is to play them in order of release: Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Hearts of Stone, and then Blood and Wine. This order allows the narrative to flow most naturally. The recommended way to experience The Witcher 3 DLC is by its release order.
Can I play Hearts of Stone or Blood and Wine before finishing the main game? Yes, you can. It is possible for players to jump into Hearts of Stone first, even ahead of the main campaign, without any major story confusion. However, for Blood and Wine, it is generally recommended to finish the main story first to avoid spoilers and ensure a more impactful ending. Blood and Wine is available after beating The Witcher 3’s main story, and should be the absolute last thing players do in the game.
At what level should I start Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine? Hearts of Stone is recommended for players around level 30, while Blood and Wine is best experienced at level 35 or higher. The Blood and Wine DLC officially starts at level 35, although players are able to start playing the expansion pack prior to reaching this level.
How long does it take to complete Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine? Hearts of stone takes from 10 -20 hours to complete. Blood and Wine takes from 30-50 hours to complete. The length depends on your playstyle and whether you focus on the main story or explore side content. How long is The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – Blood and Wine? When focusing on the main objectives, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – Blood and Wine is about 15 Hours in length. If you’re a gamer that strives to see all aspects of the game, you are likely to spend around 40½ Hours to obtain 100% completion.
Is it possible to romance Shani in Hearts of Stone? Yes, Shani is a romance option in the Hearts of Stone DLC.
What are the rewards for completing Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine? Both expansions offer unique rewards, including powerful weapons, armor, mutagens, and abilities. Completing Blood and Wine also grants Geralt his own vineyard in Toussaint, Corvo Bianco.
Does Blood and Wine introduce new game mechanics? Yes, Blood and Wine introduces new mutations that enhance Geralt’s abilities. It also allows you to dye your armor.
Is Aerondight still the best silver sword in Blood and Wine? Many consider Aerondight to be the best silver sword in the game, obtainable in the Blood and Wine DLC. This is the Holy Grail of the silver swords.
Should I play Hearts of Stone before going to the Isle of Mists in the main game? Storywise Hearts of Stone could be done before going to the Island of Mists. The Hearts of Stone DLC is basically a huge side quest to the main story. I would recommend to start it shortly before you find Ciri or after the battle of Kaer Morhen. In any case, before the grand finale on Undvik.
What’s the best armor in Blood and Wine? The Hen Gaidth set is considered one of the best armors in Blood and Wine due to its high damage reduction. If you own the Blood and Wine expansion for The Witcher 3, you can gain access to the Hen Gaidth set.
Are there multiple endings in Blood and Wine? Yes, there are multiple endings in Blood and Wine. The ending you receive will depend on certain choices you make during the expansion’s story.
Does Blood and Wine add new monsters to the game? Yes, Blood and Wine introduces a variety of new monsters, many of which are inspired by folklore and fairy tales.
What happens if I complete Blood and Wine before the main story? Main downside to doing B&W and HoS before you complete the Vanilla Main Quest and other quests is that it’ll render any remaining quests outside Toussant to the low level sub 50xp for completing a quest zone and most aren’t even above 30xp when labeled low level.
Can I play Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine at the same time? While it is possible to do, it will mean you miss out on a number of events, and a final quest that occurs after the end of Blood and Wine’s main story. While doing Hearts of Stone before Blood and Wine is preferable, it isn’t necessary given the disconnected nature of the Hearts of Stone campaign.
Where can I learn more about the educational benefits of gaming? You can explore the research and resources available on the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. The GamesLearningSociety.org explores how games can be used to enhance learning and development.