Is Dark Souls 2 and 3 Connected? Exploring the Threads of Lore
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3 are definitively connected, albeit in a subtle and often debated manner. The connection is more thematic and lore-based than a direct narrative continuation, focusing on the cyclical nature of the curse, the fading of kingdoms, and the echoes of past events that reverberate throughout the world.
Unraveling the Lore: The Threads That Bind
While Dark Souls games are known for their challenging gameplay, their intricate and often cryptic lore is equally compelling. Unlike direct sequels that follow a clear narrative path, the Dark Souls series embraces a more fragmented approach, leaving players to piece together the story through item descriptions, dialogue, and environmental storytelling. This is particularly true of the relationship between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3.
The Cyclical Nature of Fire and Dark
The central theme connecting all Dark Souls games is the cycle of the First Flame and the subsequent rise of the Dark. Each game explores different facets of this cycle, presenting different characters and kingdoms grappling with the same fundamental problem: how to perpetuate the Age of Fire or usher in the Age of Dark.
Dark Souls 2 focuses on the consequences of hubris and the futility of defying fate. Drangleic, the kingdom in Dark Souls 2, has risen and fallen before, much like the kingdoms in Dark Souls 1 and those yet to come in Dark Souls 3. Nashandra’s manipulation and the player’s eventual decision – to link the Fire or abandon it – directly contribute to the weakening of the Flame and the eventual events of Dark Souls 3. The theme of legacy and the burden of history is prominent in both games.
Dark Souls 3 presents a world on the brink of collapse, where Lords of Cinder have abandoned their duty to link the Fire, hastening the arrival of the Dark. The state of Lothric and the various kingdoms that converge upon it reflects the consequences of choices made in the past, including the events of Dark Souls 2. While the characters and settings differ significantly, the underlying struggle against the encroaching Dark is a direct continuation of the overarching narrative.
Recurring Characters and Items: Echoes of Drangleic
Despite the temporal distance between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3, certain characters, items, and locations hint at a deeper connection. While not always explicitly stated, these elements serve as subtle nods to the events of Dark Souls 2, reminding players of the interconnectedness of the Dark Souls universe.
- The Old Iron King: References to the Old Iron King and his fiery reign appear in Dark Souls 3. The Smouldering Lake, a location in Dark Souls 3, is implied to be the remnants of his kingdom, hinting at the tragic fate of Drangleic and the echoes of his failure.
- Lucatiel of Mirrah: While not appearing physically, Lucatiel’s mask can be found in Dark Souls 3, reminding players of her tragic story and the effects of the curse on individuals and kingdoms. The presence of her mask hints at the far-reaching consequences of the events in Drangleic and the enduring impact of the curse.
- The Ring of the Living: This ring, which reduces the visual effects of hollowing, is present in both games. Its inclusion in Dark Souls 3 suggests the persistence of the curse and its continued effect on the undead.
- Armor and Weapons: Certain armor sets and weapons from Dark Souls 2, such as the Drangleic Set, make appearances in Dark Souls 3, either as obtainable items or as worn by enemies. These reappearances serve as visual reminders of the past and hint at the cyclical nature of the series.
Thematic Connections: Shared Destinies
Beyond specific characters and items, the most significant connection between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3 lies in their shared thematic concerns. Both games explore the themes of:
- The Weight of History: The past shapes the present, and the actions of previous generations have lasting consequences.
- The Futility of Resistance: The cycle of Fire and Dark seems inevitable, and attempts to defy it often lead to ruin.
- The Nature of Hope: Even in the face of overwhelming darkness, hope can persist, albeit fragile and often fleeting.
- The Curse and Hollowing: The curse that afflicts the undead is a constant threat, eroding their sanity and driving them to madness.
These shared themes solidify the connection between the two games, highlighting the cyclical nature of the Dark Souls universe and the interconnectedness of its many kingdoms.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the connection between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3:
1. Is Dark Souls 2 non-canon?
No, Dark Souls 2 is considered canon. While it may have a different director and a slightly different feel compared to the other games, it contributes to the overall lore and themes of the Dark Souls universe. Its events are acknowledged and referenced in Dark Souls 3, solidifying its place in the series’ timeline.
2. Does Dark Souls 3 directly continue the story of Dark Souls 2?
Not directly. Dark Souls 3 does not pick up immediately where Dark Souls 2 left off. Instead, it takes place in a later era, where the consequences of the past have shaped the present. The narrative focuses on new characters and kingdoms, but the events of Dark Souls 2 are not entirely forgotten.
3. Are there any returning NPCs from Dark Souls 2 in Dark Souls 3?
There are no directly returning NPCs from Dark Souls 2 in Dark Souls 3 in their original forms. However, references and echoes of past characters, such as Lucatiel, can be found, hinting at their continued presence in the world’s collective memory.
4. What are some specific examples of references to Dark Souls 2 in Dark Souls 3?
Specific examples include:
- The Old Iron King’s presence in Smouldering Lake.
- The Lucatiel Mask.
- The Ring of the Living.
- The Drangleic Set and other returning armor/weapons.
5. How does the Scholar of the First Sin DLC affect the connection between the games?
Scholar of the First Sin doesn’t drastically alter the core connection, but it expands upon the lore and themes of Dark Souls 2, making the game’s role in the overall narrative more pronounced. It adds more depth to the themes of cyclical history and the nature of the curse, further reinforcing its connection to Dark Souls 3.
6. Is the Emerald Herald mentioned in Dark Souls 3?
The Emerald Herald is not directly mentioned in Dark Souls 3. However, her role as a guiding figure and a keeper of knowledge is echoed in other characters, such as the Fire Keeper, suggesting a continuity of purpose across the games.
7. Does the player character from Dark Souls 2 have any bearing on the events of Dark Souls 3?
The player character’s actions in Dark Souls 2 indirectly impact the events of Dark Souls 3 by influencing the state of the First Flame and the overall cycle of Fire and Dark. Their choices contribute to the weakening of the Flame and the eventual arrival of the events in Dark Souls 3.
8. Are there any areas in Dark Souls 3 that are similar to areas in Dark Souls 2?
While there are no direct recreations, some areas in Dark Souls 3 share thematic or architectural similarities with areas in Dark Souls 2. For example, Irithyll of the Boreal Valley has certain aesthetic parallels to areas in Drangleic, but these are more evocative than literal.
9. How does the concept of “souls” connect the two games?
The concept of souls is central to both games. Souls represent life force and power, and the pursuit of souls drives many characters’ actions. The transfer of souls across time and kingdoms, as evidenced by the reappearance of certain souls in different forms, highlights the interconnectedness of the Dark Souls universe.
10. Is there a definitive timeline placing Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3?
A definitive timeline is difficult to establish due to the ambiguous nature of time in the Dark Souls universe. However, it is generally accepted that Dark Souls 3 takes place significantly later in the timeline than Dark Souls 2, with the events of Dark Souls 2 contributing to the world state of Dark Souls 3.
11. Why do some fans dislike Dark Souls 2 compared to the other games?
Reasons for disliking Dark Souls 2 vary, but often include:
- Different level design philosophy.
- A perceived disconnect from the lore of Dark Souls 1.
- Changes to gameplay mechanics, such as Adaptability and Agility.
Despite these criticisms, Dark Souls 2 remains a valuable entry in the series with its own unique strengths and contributions to the overall lore.
12. Should I play Dark Souls 2 before Dark Souls 3?
While not strictly necessary, playing Dark Souls 2 before Dark Souls 3 is recommended. It provides a deeper understanding of the recurring themes and the cyclical nature of the series, enriching the overall experience of Dark Souls 3.
13. Are there any Dark Souls 3 DLC that further connect to Dark Souls 2?
Yes, The Ringed City DLC for Dark Souls 3 contains references to the events and characters of Dark Souls 2, further solidifying the connection between the two games. It explores the themes of the cycle of Fire and Dark in greater detail, drawing parallels to the struggles faced in Drangleic.
14. Is there a consensus in the Dark Souls community about the connection between the games?
The Dark Souls community is divided on the extent of the connection between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3. Some believe that the connection is minimal and largely thematic, while others argue for a more significant and direct link. The ambiguity surrounding the lore allows for diverse interpretations and ongoing debate.
15. What is the best way to understand the connections between Dark Souls 2 and 3?
The best way to understand the connections is to:
- Play both games thoroughly.
- Pay close attention to item descriptions and dialogue.
- Explore the environments and look for subtle clues.
- Engage with the Dark Souls community and discuss theories and interpretations.
By actively engaging with the game world and its lore, players can uncover the subtle but meaningful connections between Dark Souls 2 and Dark Souls 3, gaining a deeper appreciation for the interconnectedness of the Dark Souls universe.