Dogmeat vs. Codsworth: Which Fallout 4 Companion Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The wasteland of Fallout 4 is a harsh and unforgiving place. Having a reliable companion by your side can mean the difference between survival and becoming another ghoul’s lunch. Two of the earliest and most beloved companions players encounter are Dogmeat, the loyal German Shepherd, and Codsworth, the pre-war robotic butler. But the question remains: which of these two iconic companions is truly the better choice for the Sole Survivor?
The short answer is, it depends on your playstyle. There’s no definitive “best” companion here. If you are looking for pure combat support and utility, Codsworth often comes out on top. He is a resilient tank, capable of wielding various weapons, carrying significant amounts of gear, and even offering you daily purified water – a crucial resource in the early game. However, for players who want a more narrative-driven experience that doesn’t compromise on exploration or the Lone Wanderer perk, Dogmeat proves to be a fantastic choice. Dogmeat’s ability to locate enemies and items, his unique crowd control with his bite, and his total lack of judgment makes him a unique and fun addition to any playthrough.
Combat Capabilities: Codsworth’s Metal Might vs. Dogmeat’s Canine Tenacity
Codsworth: The Combat-Ready Robot
Codsworth’s greatest strength lies in his durability and combat versatility. As a robot, he boasts high damage resistance against various attacks, making him a reliable tank that can absorb significant damage while drawing enemy fire. He can equip various weapons, including a flamethrower and even be upgraded further with the Automatron DLC, turning him into a true war machine. He also has a high carry weight, meaning he can hold large quantities of loot, alleviating some of your inventory burden. Furthermore, as a robot, he is immune to radiation and diseases, providing yet another edge.
Codsworth’s companion perk, Robot Sympathy, which is unlocked upon reaching max affinity with him, offers you a permanent +10 damage resistance against robot energy weapons providing a fantastic additional defense boost. This is particularly useful as players often encounter robots through the game.
Dogmeat: A Loyal Companion in Combat
While Dogmeat might lack the raw firepower and sheer durability of Codsworth, he brings a unique set of skills to the table. His ability to sniff out enemies and items is invaluable, especially in the early game. He can alert you to hidden dangers and point you in the direction of loot caches that you might otherwise miss.
Dogmeat also has a special attack where he bites and holds enemies, providing a form of crowd control that can allow you to take a more strategic approach to combat, or to simply move in for the kill. This ability also provides increased accuracy and an occasional limb crippling effect which greatly enhances your combat capabilities. While it may seem like Dogmeat is unable to assist in combat, as a companion he is still capable of dealing some damage and distracting enemies.
It’s also worth noting that Dogmeat is immortal, meaning he cannot permanently die. He may be knocked out during combat, but he will always get back on his paws, making him a reliable ally in any situation.
Utility and Perks: Beyond Combat
Codsworth: The Helpful Butler
Codsworth’s utility extends beyond the battlefield. He provides one purified water each day when you speak to him, a welcome source of hydration and recovery in the harsh Commonwealth. While he can be assigned to settlements, he does not perform any tasks. Instead he simply “patrols” the assigned area. Codsworth’s biggest utility function is to provide a useful carry weight for any spare items you may pick up, he also has the potential to be modified further if you own the Automatron DLC where you can unlock even better combat and carry weight potential.
Dogmeat: The Loyal Pathfinder
Dogmeat’s primary utility function is his ability to detect enemies and items. He does this by sniffing them out and barking, which allows you to identify threats early, plan your routes and find rare and useful items. Unlike other companions, Dogmeat does not judge your actions. He’ll remain by your side no matter how evil your choices are, providing a truly loyal companion. Also, despite being a companion, Dogmeat does not disable the Lone Wanderer perk. This means you can enjoy all the benefits of exploring the wasteland with a companion while maintaining the damage resistance and carry weight enhancements that the perk provides. This ability is invaluable for players who prefer to play the game solo but want the security of having a companion.
Dogmeat can also be geared up with special canine armor that can be found while exploring the game. While this armor is purely cosmetic, it still enhances the look of your canine companion making him feel like more than just a normal dog.
The Verdict: A Choice of Preference
Ultimately, the “better” companion between Dogmeat and Codsworth comes down to personal preference and playstyle.
- Choose Codsworth if: You prioritize combat prowess, need a reliable tank, enjoy heavy looting, and want a daily dose of purified water. The ability to upgrade Codsworth with the Automatron DLC also gives him an edge in the later game.
- Choose Dogmeat if: You value exploration, appreciate the Lone Wanderer perk, want a non-judgemental companion, and like the utility of a loyal dog who can detect enemies and items.
Both companions offer unique advantages and drawbacks and will greatly enhance your gameplay experience. Regardless of who you choose to adventure the wasteland with, you can’t go wrong with either Codsworth or Dogmeat.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can you have both Dogmeat and Codsworth as companions at the same time?
No, not without mods. In the base game, you can only have one companion active at a time. However, there are mods available that allow you to have both Dogmeat and another human companion, Codsworth or otherwise, together.
2. Does Dogmeat disable the Lone Wanderer perk?
No, despite the wording of the perk, Dogmeat does not disable Lone Wanderer. You can enjoy the benefits of the perk’s extra carry weight and damage resistance while traveling with Dogmeat.
3. Can Dogmeat die permanently?
No, Dogmeat is immortal. He can be knocked out during combat, but he will always recover.
4. What is Codsworth’s companion perk?
Codsworth’s companion perk is Robot Sympathy. Upon maxing out your affinity with him, you’ll gain +10 Damage resistance against robot energy weapons.
5. Can you upgrade Codsworth?
Yes, if you have the Automatron DLC, you can customize and upgrade Codsworth with new armor, weapons, and abilities.
6. Is Dogmeat affected by the Live & Love magazine perks?
Yes, there is a mod that patches the bug causing the Live & Love magazine perks to not affect Dogmeat (and other companions like Cait, Curie, and Preston Garvey). However, this does not happen in the base game.
7. Can you gear up Dogmeat?
Yes, Dogmeat can be equipped with various dog armor, though they are mostly cosmetic with no actual defensive benefit.
8. Can Codsworth do anything in settlements?
While you can assign him to a settlement, he will not perform any actual work, like farming or scavenging. He essentially will patrol the area.
9. Is Dogmeat a boy or girl?
Dogmeat is a male dog in the game, though the real-life dog who served as the inspiration, River, was female.
10. Does Dogmeat drop synth components?
No, Dogmeat does not drop synth components when defeated in combat.
11. Can you have a human companion and Dogmeat at the same time?
No, in the base game, you can only have one companion at a time. Dogmeat is considered a companion.
12. Does Dogmeat judge you?
No, Dogmeat is extremely loyal and will never judge your actions in the game, no matter how evil they may be.
13. Can you make Dogmeat stronger?
You cannot directly increase his base stats, but giving him armor can help his overall sustainability in combat.
14. What happens if Dogmeat dies?
Dogmeat is essential and can not die permanently. If he is knocked out during combat, he will return shortly after.
15. Does Dogmeat’s armor provide any benefit?
No, Dogmeat’s armor is purely cosmetic and provides no actual protection or bonuses.