Table of Contents

Elden Ring vs. Dark Souls vs. Bloodborne: Which is the Hardest?

Quick answer

This page answers Is Elden Ring harder than Dark Souls or Bloodborne? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The age-old question: Is Elden Ring harder than Dark Souls or Bloodborne? The answer, like the Lands Between themselves, is complex and depends heavily on playstyle, experience, and willingness to engage with all the tools the game provides. Objectively, Elden Ring, when played “pure,” meaning solo and without leaning heavily on Spirit Ashes, can be considered more challenging than the original Dark Souls. Its bosses boast intricate movesets, aggressive AI, and devastating damage output, especially in the later stages of the game. However, when compared to Bloodborne, the scales tip slightly in favor of Bloodborne’s grueling difficulty, particularly for new players unfamiliar with the fast-paced, aggressive combat style the game demands.

Elden Ring offers more accessibility through open-world exploration, build variety, and powerful summoning mechanics. Bloodborne, on the other hand, throws you into the deep end of Yharnam and expects you to swim. Both are challenging, but in different ways. This article will delve deeper into the nuances of these three acclaimed games, addressing frequently asked questions and providing a comprehensive analysis of their difficulty.

Comparing the Core Mechanics

Combat Style

Dark Souls: Known for its methodical, deliberate combat focused on poise, armor, and strategic shield use. Patience is key.
Bloodborne: Favors aggressive, fast-paced combat with emphasis on dodging, parrying with firearms, and regaining health through aggressive counter-attacks with the unique Rally system.
Elden Ring: A blend of both. It borrows the deliberate combat of Dark Souls but also introduces elements of Bloodborne’s aggression, particularly with certain weapon types and enemy designs. The addition of jump attacks and mounted combat expands the combat vocabulary considerably.

Open World vs. Linear Design

Dark Souls: Features a largely interconnected world with some branching paths, but the overall progression is relatively linear.
Bloodborne: While not a true open world, Bloodborne’s Yharnam is a tightly interconnected city with multiple branching paths and hidden areas.
Elden Ring: A true open-world game. Players can explore vast landscapes, tackle dungeons in any order, and amass resources to overcome challenges at their own pace. This freedom contributes significantly to its perceived accessibility.

Build Variety

Dark Souls: Offers diverse builds focused on strength, dexterity, faith, and intelligence, each with unique weapon and spell options.
Bloodborne: While fewer stats to level, Bloodborne features trick weapons that transform and offer diverse movesets, allowing for unique combat approaches.
Elden Ring: Boasts the largest build variety in the series. A massive arsenal of weapons, spells, and armor combined with the ability to respec stats allows for unparalleled customization and experimentation. This adaptability is a major factor in its perceived lower difficulty for some players.

Summoning Mechanics

Dark Souls: Limited summoning options that require specific items and online connectivity.
Bloodborne: Similar to Dark Souls, with summoning relying on specific items and online connectivity.
Elden Ring: Introduces Spirit Ashes, summonable AI companions that can significantly ease boss fights and exploration. These summons are readily available and can be upgraded, providing a substantial advantage to players who utilize them.

The Boss Factor

Boss encounters are a defining characteristic of FromSoftware games.

Dark Souls Bosses: Often characterized by straightforward attack patterns and deliberate pacing.
Bloodborne Bosses: Generally faster and more aggressive, demanding quick reflexes and precise dodging. Many have multiple phases and require mastering the Rally system.
Elden Ring Bosses: The most complex and demanding in the series. They feature intricate movesets, delayed attacks, hyper-aggression, and often multiple phases that drastically change the fight’s dynamics. Malenia, Blade of Miquella, for instance, is widely considered one of the most difficult bosses in FromSoftware’s history.

Addressing the Perceived Difficulty

Elden Ring’s open-world design and accessibility features (Spirit Ashes, jump attacks, build variety) can trivialize certain aspects of the game. Players can grind levels, acquire powerful gear, and summon allies to overcome difficult encounters. This contrasts sharply with Bloodborne, where reliance on skill and aggression is paramount. Dark Souls sits in between, demanding patience and strategy but with fewer readily available tools to cheese encounters.

Ultimately, the “hardest” game is subjective. A Dark Souls veteran comfortable with slow, methodical combat might struggle with Bloodborne’s relentless pace. A Bloodborne player accustomed to aggressive dodging might find Elden Ring’s delayed attacks frustrating. However, played “pure,” Elden Ring’s late-game bosses push the limits of player skill and endurance, arguably making it the most challenging experience for experienced Souls players seeking a true test.

The Games Learning Society explores how games teach and facilitate learning. For more information, visit GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is Elden Ring easier than Dark Souls if I use summons?

Yes, Spirit Ashes in Elden Ring can significantly reduce the difficulty of boss fights and challenging areas. Dark Souls’ summoning system is less accessible and often less impactful.
Which game has the hardest early game: Elden Ring, Dark Souls, or Bloodborne?

Bloodborne’s early game is arguably the most challenging due to its aggressive combat and limited resources. While Elden Ring can be difficult at the start, the open world allows players to explore easier areas and level up before tackling challenging encounters.
Is Bloodborne’s fast-paced combat harder to learn than Dark Souls’ slower combat?

For many players, yes. Bloodborne requires quick reflexes and aggressive play, which can be difficult to master. Dark Souls’ slower combat is more forgiving and allows for more deliberate decision-making.
Does Elden Ring’s open world make it easier or harder than the linear design of Dark Souls?

Easier. The open world allows players to explore, level up, and find powerful gear before tackling challenging areas. Dark Souls’ linear design forces players to confront challenges head-on with limited resources.
Are Elden Ring bosses more difficult than Dark Souls bosses?

Generally, yes. Elden Ring bosses have more complex movesets, delayed attacks, and higher damage output than most Dark Souls bosses.
Is Elden Ring the easiest Souls game?

No. While Elden Ring has accessibility features that can make it easier, it also contains some of the most challenging bosses in the series. When played “pure,” it can be extremely difficult.
Is Bloodborne harder than Dark Souls 3?

Many players find Bloodborne more challenging due to its aggressive combat and faster pace. Dark Souls 3 is also difficult but offers more build variety and tactical options.
Which game has the hardest final boss: Elden Ring, Dark Souls, or Bloodborne?

This is subjective, but many players consider Elden Ring’s Elden Beast or Bloodborne’s Orphan of Kos to be among the most challenging final bosses in the series.
Does build variety make Elden Ring easier than Dark Souls?

Yes, the massive build variety in Elden Ring allows players to tailor their characters to specific challenges and exploit enemy weaknesses.
Is the lack of a traditional shield in Bloodborne a significant factor in its difficulty?

Yes. Bloodborne replaces shields with firearms, which require precise timing and aggressive counter-attacks. This forces players to adopt a more aggressive playstyle.
Which game is more forgiving for new players: Elden Ring, Dark Souls, or Bloodborne?

Elden Ring is generally considered the most forgiving due to its open world, Spirit Ashes, and build variety.
Is it possible to “cheese” bosses in Elden Ring more easily than in Dark Souls or Bloodborne?

Yes, due to the open world and abundance of powerful weapons and spells, there are more opportunities to exploit enemy weaknesses and “cheese” bosses in Elden Ring.
Does Elden Ring’s jumping mechanic contribute to its perceived lower difficulty?

Yes, jumping allows players to dodge attacks, reach new areas, and perform powerful jump attacks, adding another layer to the combat system.
Which game requires more grinding to overcome challenging areas: Elden Ring, Dark Souls, or Bloodborne?

Elden Ring benefits most from grinding, as the open world allows for efficient leveling and item acquisition.
If I struggled with Bloodborne’s combat, will I struggle with Elden Ring?

Potentially, but Elden Ring’s more deliberate combat and build variety offer more options for players who prefer a less aggressive playstyle. You may still struggle with specific boss encounters.