Is Elden Ring Just Bloodborne? Unraveling the Similarities and Differences
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The simple answer is: no, Elden Ring is not just Bloodborne. While both games hail from the renowned FromSoftware, they are distinct experiences with their own unique identities. They share a lineage, belonging to the subgenre often referred to as “SoulsBorne”, but their core mechanics, lore, and world design diverge significantly. This article will delve into the specific differences, drawing comparisons where they exist, and ultimately help you understand why Elden Ring stands as a new IP, rather than a reskin of Bloodborne.
Contrasting Worlds: Yharnam vs. the Lands Between
The Setting
One of the most immediately noticeable differences between the two games is their setting. Bloodborne takes place in the gothic, Victorian-inspired city of Yharnam. This city, with its narrow streets, towering structures, and a pervasive sense of decay, is a closed, interconnected world that offers a tightly focused and claustrophobic experience. By contrast, Elden Ring unfolds in the Lands Between, an expansive open-world with diverse biomes, sprawling landscapes, and hidden secrets scattered across its map. The contrast in scale alone dictates a fundamentally different gameplay experience.
Aesthetics and Tone
While both games feature a dark and challenging atmosphere, the aesthetics are quite different. Bloodborne leans heavily into Lovecraftian horror and a steampunk-inspired style with grotesque monsters and a pervasive sense of dread. Elden Ring, while certainly dark, operates in a more traditional high-fantasy setting, albeit with the signature FromSoftware twist. The aesthetic is inspired by medieval fantasy, with towering castles, mythical beasts, and more familiar fantasy tropes, albeit rendered in a unique and often unsettling manner.
Gameplay Mechanics: Fast-Paced Frenzy vs. Tactical Open-World
Combat Pacing
The combat systems in both games are a core element of their identities. Bloodborne is known for its aggressive and fast-paced combat. Players are encouraged to be proactive, parrying and dashing through encounters with a “rally” mechanic that rewards counter-aggression. It’s a relentless, often frantic experience. Elden Ring, while still challenging, offers a more measured and tactical combat system. It’s more reminiscent of the Dark Souls series, with an emphasis on managing stamina, timing attacks, and utilizing a variety of weapons and magical options. The open-world nature also allows players to engage with combat on their own terms, choosing their battles and utilizing the environment to their advantage.
Open-World vs. Linear Design
Elden Ring’s expansive open-world design is a significant departure from Bloodborne’s linear, interconnected world. This open design allows players to explore freely, discover hidden areas, and tackle challenges in a non-linear order. In Bloodborne, the world design is more curated. Players progress through specific areas, facing specific challenges, which provides a more focused narrative experience. The ability to simply “walk away” from a difficult boss in Elden Ring is a major point of differentiation, highlighting the freedom afforded by its open-world.
Character Customization and Progression
While both games offer a degree of character customization, Elden Ring allows for a far more diverse range of character builds. Players can choose from a variety of classes and experiment with an enormous assortment of weapons, armor, spells, and incantations. This extensive customization promotes varied playstyles and encourages experimentation. Bloodborne, while offering unique weapon transformations, has a slightly more limited customization system.
Lore and Story: Outer Gods vs. The Great Runes
Narrative Approaches
Both games present their narratives in the classic FromSoftware fashion – through environmental storytelling, item descriptions, and cryptic dialogue. Bloodborne’s story is rooted in the influence of the Great Ones, cosmic entities with unknowable motives, and the corruption they inflict on Yharnam. The narrative is tightly woven, leading players down a specific path of mystery and horror. Elden Ring’s story involves the shattered Elden Ring and the powerful demigods vying for control over the Lands Between. The narrative is more sprawling, allowing players to piece together the lore by exploring the vast world.
Deities and Powers
Both games feature figures of immense power, but the specific themes and how the player interacts with them differ. In Bloodborne, the player’s potential to become a Great One makes the boundaries of power more ambiguous and less fixed. Elden Ring focuses on the concept of Outer Gods and their influence on the world, but the player’s role is less about transcendence and more about shaping the destiny of the Lands Between through the power of the Great Runes.
Difficulty and Accessibility
Relative Difficulty
Many consider Bloodborne to be a notably difficult game due to its fast-paced combat and unforgiving nature. While Elden Ring is also challenging, it offers several mechanics that can make the experience more accessible. These include the ability to summon spirits for aid and the open-world design that allows players to avoid tough encounters until they are better equipped. This flexibility makes Elden Ring arguably more approachable than Bloodborne, especially for newcomers to the Soulsborne genre.
Accessibility Options
The open world design of Elden Ring and the various methods of mitigating difficulty, such as utilizing summons and the sheer size of the map, make it a more approachable FromSoftware game than many of its predecessors, including Bloodborne. However, the game still demands focus and endurance to chain moves and manage multiple enemies.
Conclusion: Shared Lineage, Distinct Experiences
While both games are crafted by FromSoftware and share some common elements, the core differences are significant. Elden Ring, while inspired by its predecessors like Bloodborne, is very much its own beast. It builds upon the foundation of the SoulsBorne subgenre, but expands its scope and refines its formula to create a unique and expansive experience. Elden Ring is not just Bloodborne, but a spiritual successor to the entire lineage of FromSoftware’s challenging action RPGs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Elden Ring a sequel to Bloodborne?
No, Elden Ring is not a sequel to Bloodborne. They are set in completely different universes with different lore, characters, and settings. Elden Ring is considered a spiritual successor to the Souls series as a whole, not just to Bloodborne.
2. Is Elden Ring harder than Bloodborne?
It depends on your playstyle and approach. Bloodborne’s aggressive, fast-paced combat is often seen as particularly challenging, but Elden Ring also presents a significant difficulty, especially when attempting it without summons and assistance from other players. Elden Ring offers tools like summons and the open-world for mitigating difficulty that Bloodborne lacks.
3. What are the main influences on Elden Ring’s design?
Hidetaka Miyazaki cited Shadow of the Colossus, The Elder Scrolls, The Witcher 3, and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild as design influences for Elden Ring. The game also draws inspiration from tabletop RPGs, such as RuneQuest, and fantasy novels like The Lord of the Rings.
4. Is Elden Ring a “Souls-like” game?
Yes, Elden Ring is considered a “Souls-like” game, a term used to describe games inspired by the Dark Souls series and other FromSoftware titles. This means it features challenging combat, a dark fantasy setting, and a focus on exploration and discovery. It often uses the term SoulsBorne to include the likes of Demon Souls, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, and Elden Ring.
5. Is there a connection between Bloodborne and the Age of Stars ending in Elden Ring?
There is a fan theory suggesting the Age of Stars ending in Elden Ring could be a prequel to the events of Bloodborne. This theory focuses on the shared thematic elements of cosmic entities and the manipulation of power structures. It is still just a fan theory at this time.
6. Is Elden Ring good for beginners to the Soulsborne genre?
Elden Ring is often considered the most approachable FromSoftware game due to its open-world design and various options for managing difficulty. However, it is still a challenging game, so beginners should be prepared for a demanding experience.
7. Why is Elden Ring so popular?
Elden Ring’s popularity stems from its challenging gameplay, massive open world, compelling story and lore, diverse character-building options, and its beautiful and compelling aesthetic. Its unique blend of action RPG mechanics and exploration makes for an engaging and rewarding experience.
8. What is the easiest class to play as in Elden Ring?
The Vagabond class is often cited as the easiest class for beginners due to its balanced stats and starting equipment. It provides a good foundation for a variety of playstyles. The Samurai and Confessor are also good starting classes.
9. What is the hardest class to play as in Elden Ring?
The Wretch class is widely considered the most challenging class due to its low starting stats, minimal gear, and overall lack of advantages. It is best suited for experienced players looking for an extra challenge.
10. Does Elden Ring have an easy mode?
No, Elden Ring does not have a formal “easy mode.” However, the open-world structure and available summoning options can be utilized to mitigate the overall difficulty, making some parts of the game more manageable.
11. Is Elden Ring too hard for a casual gamer?
While Elden Ring is known for its difficulty, it is not solely about brutal gameplay. It has a rich story and presentation that many casual gamers could find enjoyable. With some patience and the willingness to learn, even casual players can experience the game.
12. Is there a sequel to Elden Ring planned?
Hidetaka Miyazaki has seemingly confirmed that a sequel to Elden Ring is in development.
13. Is Elden Ring losing popularity?
While Elden Ring’s player base has seen a decline since its initial release, it remains a very popular game. This decline is expected for most single-player, story-driven games over time.
14. Can you skip Margit the Fell Omen?
Yes, it’s possible to skip Margit the Fell Omen if the player is so inclined.
15. What are some key things beginners should know before starting Elden Ring?
Some helpful tips for beginners include: utilizing guard counters, exploring the map thoroughly to discover Legacy Dungeons, not fighting the Tree Sentinel early, and experimenting with bleed weapons for increased damage.