Is Elden Ring the Highest Rated Game of All Time?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether Elden Ring is the highest-rated game of all time is complex and nuanced. While it achieved near-universal acclaim upon release, boasting a ‘Top Critic Average’ of 97 on OpenCritic, a score matched only by Super Mario Odyssey, the answer isn’t a simple yes. While it briefly held the top spot, nuances in scoring methodologies and differing critical opinions over time mean it’s difficult to definitively crown any single game as the undisputed champion. The truth is more subjective and depends on the criteria used for evaluation.
The Metrics of Greatness: How We Rate Games
Defining a game’s quality and comparing it across generations is a tricky endeavor. Several factors influence the overall perception of a game, including initial hype, critical reception, sales figures, player retention, and long-term impact on the industry.
OpenCritic and Metacritic: A Snapshot of Critical Consensus
Sites like OpenCritic and Metacritic aggregate reviews from various sources to provide a numerical representation of a game’s critical success. Elden Ring’s initial scores on these platforms were exceptionally high, placing it among the elite. The ‘Top Critic Average’ on OpenCritic is a weighted average, giving more importance to established and respected publications. This metric initially favored Elden Ring, highlighting the game’s exceptional quality at launch.
However, averages fluctuate as more reviews come in, and differing opinions emerge. Also, it’s essential to consider the context of these scores. Games released in different eras are judged based on the prevailing standards of their time. A game considered revolutionary in 2005 might not receive the same accolades today, despite its historical significance.
Beyond Scores: Intangible Qualities and Lasting Impact
Ultimately, a game’s greatness extends beyond numerical scores. Its influence on game design, cultural impact, and lasting legacy are equally crucial. Elden Ring, for example, has reinvigorated the open-world genre by demonstrating that vast, explorable landscapes can be combined with challenging gameplay and a cryptic, yet compelling, narrative. Games that push boundaries and inspire developers for years to come deserve consideration as some of the greatest ever made. Games like Super Mario 64, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, and Grand Theft Auto V, which have dramatically shaped the industry, are also important to consider.
Elden Ring’s impact is undeniable. Its sales figures have been astronomical. More than 20.5 million units worldwide as of March 2023. It introduced a new level of accessibility to the FromSoftware formula, attracting players who might have been intimidated by the difficulty of the Dark Souls series. The game’s vast and intricate world, combined with its challenging combat and rewarding exploration, has captivated players worldwide.
Frequently Asked Questions About Elden Ring
Here are some common questions about Elden Ring that provide further insight into its critical reception and overall impact.
1. Is Elden Ring a top 10 game of all time?
The question of being “top 10” is subjective. However, considering its critical acclaim, sales success, and significant influence on the gaming landscape, Elden Ring has earned a place in many lists of the greatest games ever made. Its innovative open-world design and challenging gameplay contribute to its standing among the elite.
2. Where does Elden Ring rank all time compared to other FromSoftware titles?
While subjective, many consider Elden Ring to be FromSoftware’s magnum opus. It builds upon the foundations laid by the Dark Souls series, Bloodborne, and Demon’s Souls, offering a more expansive and accessible experience. While some purists might prefer the tighter level design of previous games, Elden Ring’s ambition and scope are unmatched.
3. Which game is objectively better than Elden Ring?
“Objectively better” is impossible to define. However, some argue that games like The Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim offer a different, equally compelling open-world experience, focusing more on player agency and a richer narrative. Ultimately, preference comes down to individual taste.
4. What made Elden Ring so popular?
Several factors contributed to Elden Ring’s popularity: its challenging but rewarding gameplay, the vast and explorable open world, the cryptic and intriguing lore, and the positive word-of-mouth spread by players who enjoyed the game. The collaboration between FromSoftware and George R.R. Martin also generated significant hype.
5. Is Elden Ring more successful than Dark Souls?
Commercially, Elden Ring is significantly more successful than any of the Dark Souls games. It sold 12 million copies in just over two weeks, surpassing the sales figures of Dark Souls 3 by a considerable margin.
6. What is the hardest game ever compared to Elden Ring?
While Elden Ring is known for its difficulty, it’s not necessarily the “hardest game ever.” Games like Demon’s Souls, Ghosts ‘n Goblins, and Ninja Gaiden II are often cited as being significantly more challenging due to their unforgiving mechanics and precise timing requirements. The game is known to be very unforgiving, so practice and patience is definitely key.
7. How many people have 100% completed Elden Ring?
Around 7.9% of Elden Ring players on PlayStation have earned the Platinum trophy, indicating they have completed all the game’s achievements. This is considered a high percentage for a AAA game, suggesting that many players were dedicated to exploring every aspect of the world and conquering its challenges.
8. Is Elden Ring harder than Skyrim?
The combat in Elden Ring is significantly more complex and demanding than in Skyrim. While Skyrim offers a broader range of character customization and quests, Elden Ring emphasizes precise timing, strategic thinking, and mastery of its combat mechanics.
9. Why is Elden Ring so hard?
Elden Ring is considered difficult because it is “unforgiving.” One mistake can lead to death. FromSoftware designs its games to punish recklessness and reward careful observation, strategic planning, and perseverance. This is why some have been known to play without getting hit and leveling up.
10. How long does it take to 100% complete Elden Ring?
On average, it takes around 133 hours to achieve 100% completion in Elden Ring. This includes exploring all areas, defeating all bosses, and completing all quests. However, time will always vary.
11. Is Elden Ring 2 real?
While not officially confirmed at the time of this writing, rumors and hints suggest that a sequel to Elden Ring may be in development. Given the game’s immense success, it’s likely that FromSoftware will explore opportunities to expand the Elden Ring universe.
12. Can an average person beat Elden Ring?
Yes, an average person can beat Elden Ring, but it requires patience, persistence, and a willingness to learn from mistakes. The game is challenging, but not insurmountable. With practice and determination, most players can overcome its obstacles.
13. What percentage of players finish Elden Ring?
Around 50% of players on Steam have finished Elden Ring at least once. This completion rate is significantly higher than many other AAA games, reflecting the game’s captivating nature and the satisfaction players derive from overcoming its challenges.
14. What is the hardest ending to achieve in Elden Ring?
The Lord of Frenzied Flame ending is often considered the most difficult to achieve in Elden Ring, as it requires a complex and obscure questline that many players might miss during their playthrough.
15. Is Elden Ring or Demon’s Souls easier?
Generally, Elden Ring is considered more accessible than Demon’s Souls. While still challenging, Elden Ring offers more options for character customization, a larger open world to explore, and a greater variety of combat styles, making it slightly easier for newcomers to the FromSoftware formula.
Conclusion: Elden Ring’s Place in Gaming History
Whether or not Elden Ring is the “highest-rated game of all time” is a matter of perspective and depends on the metrics used for evaluation. However, its impact on the gaming industry is undeniable. Its innovative open-world design, challenging gameplay, and critical acclaim have cemented its place among the greats. While it may not definitively hold the top spot in every ranking, its influence and legacy will be felt for years to come.
Ultimately, Elden Ring’s greatness is best measured by the experiences it provides to players. Its world is captivating, its combat is rewarding, and its challenges are satisfying to overcome. These qualities, more than any numerical score, are what make Elden Ring a truly special game.
To learn more about how games can enhance learning and engagement, explore the Games Learning Society website at GamesLearningSociety.org.