Falchion vs. Scimitar: Which Curved Blade Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question: Is the falchion better than the scimitar? In the world of weaponry, whether real-world history or the fantastical realms of video games, the answer is rarely straightforward. In Elden Ring, specifically, while the falchion and scimitar share similarities as curved swords, the falchion generally offers a more immediately advantageous package, boasting higher raw damage and innate bleed buildup. However, the “better” weapon ultimately hinges on your playstyle, build, and specific needs. Let’s delve into the details.
Understanding the Blades: Falchion and Scimitar
Both the falchion and scimitar are curved swords, characterized by their slashing attacks and relative speed. They are primarily Dexterity weapons, though they also benefit from some Strength. Their curved nature lends itself to wide sweeping attacks, making them effective against groups of weaker enemies. However, their curved design also tends to be less effective when fighting in confined locations. The important characteristics of both curved blades are below:
-
Falchion: The falchion tends to have a heavier blade than the scimitar, often with a single-edged, cleaver-like design. In Elden Ring, this translates to higher base damage and the crucial addition of bleed buildup, causing enemies to hemorrhage additional damage over time.
-
Scimitar: Typically lighter and more agile, the scimitar is a classic curved sword design. While it lacks the falchion’s immediate punch and bleed, its lower weight can be advantageous for builds focused on maximizing mobility and equip load.
The Case for the Falchion
The falchion’s strengths lie in its offensive capabilities:
-
Higher Damage Output: Even without considering bleed, the falchion boasts a higher base Attack Power (AR) than the scimitar, meaning it deals more damage per hit.
-
Innate Bleed: The bleed effect is a game-changer in Elden Ring. When the bleed meter fills on an enemy, they take a substantial burst of damage. The falchion’s innate bleed allows you to trigger this effect more frequently, significantly boosting your overall damage potential.
-
Similar Scaling: Both weapons scale primarily with Dexterity, so you won’t need to respec your character to effectively wield the falchion.
The Scimitar’s Advantages
While often overshadowed, the scimitar has its own merits:
-
Lighter Weight: The scimitar’s lower weight (1.5 compared to the falchion’s 2.5) can be crucial for optimizing your equip load, allowing you to wear heavier armor or wield other weapons without becoming overburdened.
-
Early Availability: The scimitar is accessible relatively early in the game. You can purchase it from merchants in Limgrave and Weeping Peninsula, making it a reliable starting option.
-
Infusion Flexibility: Like the falchion, the scimitar benefits greatly from infusions. You can tailor it to your build with various Ashes of War, adding elemental damage, status effects, or scaling adjustments.
Making the Choice: Playstyle and Build
Ultimately, the “better” weapon depends on your preferences:
-
Aggressive Playstyle: If you favor a more aggressive approach, constantly pressuring enemies, the falchion’s higher damage and bleed are invaluable.
-
Mobile Playstyle: If you prioritize dodging and maintaining distance, the scimitar’s lighter weight can provide an edge.
-
Build Considerations: If you’re running a build with limited equip load capacity, the scimitar might be the more practical choice. For builds focused on status effects, the falchion’s innate bleed synergizes well with other bleed-enhancing items or spells.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is the falchion a curved sword?
Yes, the falchion is classified as a curved sword in Elden Ring and in real-world historical classifications.
2. Is the falchion good in Elden Ring?
Absolutely! The falchion is a very good weapon in Elden Ring, especially for early to mid-game. Its combination of damage and bleed makes it a formidable option for many builds.
3. What scaling does the falchion have?
The falchion primarily scales with Dexterity (D) and has some scaling with Strength (E). At higher upgrade levels, the Dexterity scaling improves.
4. Can you dual wield falchions or scimitars?
Yes, you can dual wield both falchions and scimitars in Elden Ring. Dual wielding them will alternate your attacks and help you to quickly apply the bleed buildup, or in the case of the scimitar, apply any other status effect.
5. What are some good Ashes of War for the falchion or scimitar?
Popular Ashes of War for both weapons include:
- Bloodflame Blade: Adds fire damage and bleed buildup.
- Seppuku: Increases attack power and bleed buildup at the cost of HP.
- Sacred Blade: Adds holy damage and a ranged attack.
- Poison Mist: Inflicts poison buildup.
6. Where can I find the falchion?
The falchion can be found in a chest in the Fort Haight West Site of Grace in Limgrave area, making it accessible relatively early in the game.
7. Where can I find the scimitar?
The scimitar can be purchased from merchants such as the Nomadic Merchant in Limgrave near the Coastal Cave entrance and the Isolated Merchant in Weeping Peninsula.
8. Is the Uchigatana better than the falchion?
The Uchigatana and falchion are both excellent weapons, but cater to different playstyles. The Uchigatana has longer reach and a slightly different moveset, while the falchion offers faster attacks and innate bleed.
9. Can you parry with a falchion or scimitar?
While you can’t parry with the weapon itself, you can equip a shield with the “Parry” skill and use it while wielding the falchion or scimitar.
10. Is it worth upgrading the falchion or scimitar?
Yes, it is definitely worth upgrading either weapon if you enjoy its moveset and it fits your build. Upgrading increases their damage and scaling, making them more effective as you progress through the game.
11. Are curved swords good against armored enemies?
The in-game description itself says that curved swords are ineffective against armor.
12. What’s the best weapon in Elden Ring?
There is no single “best” weapon in Elden Ring. Many weapons are viable depending on your build and playstyle. Some popular and powerful options include the Rivers of Blood, Moonveil, and Bloodhound’s Fang. However, for early-game play with high DPS, the falchion is a great choice.
13. What are some alternatives to the falchion and scimitar?
If you’re looking for similar weapons, consider:
- Bloodhound’s Fang: A unique curved greatsword with excellent scaling and a powerful weapon skill.
- Scavenger’s Curved Sword: Has innate bleed and can be dual-wielded for rapid bleed buildup.
- Grossmesser: A curved sword with slightly higher Strength scaling.
14. Do status effects like bleed scale with Arcane?
Yes, the Arcane stat influences the speed at which you build up status effects such as bleed, poison, and frostbite. Investing in Arcane can significantly enhance the effectiveness of weapons with innate status effects.
15. Is Elden Ring educational?
While not explicitly designed as an educational tool, Elden Ring promotes problem-solving, critical thinking, and spatial reasoning skills. Moreover, its intricate lore and world-building can spark curiosity and encourage players to explore historical and mythological themes. To learn more about the intersection of games and learning, visit the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ or GamesLearningSociety.org.
The Verdict
In conclusion, while the scimitar offers advantages in weight and early accessibility, the falchion generally provides a more potent combination of damage and bleed for the majority of builds in Elden Ring. However, the true answer lies in your individual playstyle and build. Experiment with both weapons, find the one that resonates with you, and carve your own path through the Lands Between!