Table of Contents

Decoding Combat: Is Fighting the Same as Attacking in Magic: The Gathering?

Quick answer

This page answers Is fighting the same as attacking in Magic The Gathering? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

No, fighting is not the same as attacking in Magic: The Gathering. While both involve creatures dealing damage to each other, they are distinct game mechanics with different rules and implications. Attacking is a core component of the combat phase, where creatures are declared as attackers and blockers, leading to combat damage. Fighting, on the other hand, is a keyword action, typically triggered by a spell or ability, that causes two specified creatures to deal damage to each other simultaneously, outside the normal attacking and blocking sequence. Crucially, damage dealt through fighting is considered noncombat damage.

Understanding the Key Differences

Attacking: The Dance of Combat

Attacking is a fundamental mechanic within the combat phase. Here’s a breakdown:

Declare Attackers: The active player (the one whose turn it is) chooses which creatures they control will attack. They can attack the defending player, a planeswalker the defending player controls, or a battle the defending player controls.
Declare Blockers: The defending player then declares which of their creatures will block the attacking creatures.
Combat Damage: Finally, creatures deal damage to each other. Attacking creatures that are not blocked deal damage to the player or planeswalker/battle they’re attacking. Blocked attacking creatures deal damage to the creatures blocking them, and vice versa.

Key Characteristics of Attacking:

It occurs during the combat phase.
Damage dealt is combat damage.
Creatures are declared as attackers and blockers.
The active player chooses the targets of their attacks.
Blocking creates interactions involving multiple creatures.

Fighting: A Noncombat Duel

Fighting, defined by the keyword action “Fight,” is a different beast. When a card uses the phrase “[Creature A] fights [Creature B],” both creatures deal damage equal to their power to each other simultaneously.

Key Characteristics of Fighting:

It is a noncombat action.
Damage dealt is noncombat damage.
It bypasses the attack/block sequence.
It is typically initiated by a spell or ability.
It targets specific creatures, and doesn’t interact with player/planeswalker/battle damage.

Why the Distinction Matters

The difference between fighting and attacking isn’t just semantic. It affects how various abilities and spells interact with the game state. For example:

Combat Damage Triggers: Abilities that trigger “when a creature deals combat damage” won’t trigger from damage dealt during a fight.
“Attacking” Creatures: Spells that affect “attacking creatures” will not affect creatures involved in a fight, unless they were already attacking, too.
Defenders: A creature with Defender can be declared as a blocker but cannot be declared as an attacker. This restriction doesn’t apply to fighting; a creature with Defender can still be forced to fight.
Indestructible Creatures: An Indestructible creature will survive combat with a creature that could deal lethal damage, but the Indestructible creature will still deal combat damage to the attacking creature. Similarly, an Indestructible creature will survive a fight even when the damage dealt to it equals or exceeds it’s toughness, however it will still deal damage back.

Understanding these distinctions is crucial for making informed decisions during gameplay.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the difference between fighting and attacking:

Does fight count as combat in Magic The Gathering? No, fight does not count as combat. It’s a noncombat action that deals noncombat damage.
Is a creature still attacking after combat damage? Yes, a creature remains an attacking creature until it’s removed from combat, the combat phase ends, or another effect changes its status.
How does attacking work in magic? Attacking involves declaring creatures as attackers during the combat phase. Unblocked attackers deal combat damage to the defending player or planeswalker/battle they are attacking. Blocked attackers deal combat damage to the creatures blocking them.
Can you skip combat in magic? Yes, you can choose not to declare any attackers, effectively skipping the combat damage step.
What is until end of combat in Magic The Gathering? Effects that last “until end of combat” expire at the end of the combat phase, after the end of combat step concludes.
What are the rules for attacking and blocking in Magic The Gathering? The active player declares attackers. The defending player declares blockers. Creatures then deal combat damage to each other based on their power.
Does destroying a battle flip it? No, destroying a Battle with an effect like a destroy spell does not flip it. Battles are flipped by depleting their defense counters by dealing combat damage to them.
What does Battle Cry mean in Magic The Gathering? Battle Cry is a combat mechanic that gives other attacking creatures +1/+0 until the end of the turn when a creature with Battle Cry attacks.
Can you go to combat without attacking MTG? Yes, you can proceed to the combat phase without declaring any attackers.
Does attacking directly count as battling? Yes, attacking directly counts as battling.
What is the difference between attacking and defending? Attacking is an offensive action, while defending is a protective action. In Magic, attacking means declaring a creature as an attacker, and defending means declaring a creature as a blocker.
Does combat happen every turn in Magic The Gathering? Every turn includes a combat phase, unless an effect specifically skips it. However, combat damage only happens if attackers are declared.
Do you lose mana between combat steps? Yes, any unspent mana is lost at the end of each step and phase, including the combat phase.
What is the rule 506 in Magic The Gathering? Rule 506 governs the attacking player’s steps when creating an attack, and explains when creatures are removed from combat.
Do creatures heal after fight mtg? No, damage marked on creatures does not automatically disappear after a fight. Damage persists until the end of the turn or until it is removed by an effect.

Beyond the Basics

The distinction between fighting and attacking becomes even more important when considering more complex card interactions. Certain creatures might have abilities that trigger specifically when they deal combat damage, making attacking a more advantageous strategy. Conversely, certain creatures might benefit from fighting, particularly if they have abilities that trigger when they take damage or if they are more powerful than the creature they are fighting.

Conclusion

While both fighting and attacking involve creatures dealing damage, they are fundamentally different mechanics in Magic: The Gathering. Attacking is a structured process within the combat phase, while fighting is a noncombat action triggered by spells or abilities. Understanding these differences is key to mastering the game. Dive deeper into the strategic nuances of card games and their role in education by visiting the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.