Is Grapeshot Banned in MTG?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is yes, Grapeshot is banned in Magic: the Gathering’s Pauper format. However, it is not banned in other formats like Modern, Legacy, or Commander. This discrepancy often leads to confusion, especially for players new to the game or those venturing into different formats. Let’s break down why Grapeshot is banned in Pauper and explore its role in other formats.
Grapeshot: A Stormy History
Grapeshot is a red sorcery card with the Storm mechanic. This mechanic allows you to copy the spell for each other spell that was cast earlier in the turn. Grapeshot itself deals 1 damage to any target, but with a high enough Storm count, it can rapidly deal lethal damage. Its low mana cost, just a single red mana, makes it incredibly efficient within the right deck.
The card’s strength lies in its ability to exploit the nature of “Storm” decks, which are constructed to cast multiple spells in a single turn, often through mana acceleration and efficient cantrips, to build up a significant Storm count and then unleash a lethal Grapeshot.
Why the Pauper Ban?
In Pauper, a format restricted to only common rarity cards, Grapeshot became too powerful. The format, by nature, limits the availability of powerful counterspells and disruptive cards, making it easy for a Storm deck to assemble a winning engine and unleash a huge Grapeshot. This overwhelming power level led to a stale and dominating metagame.
Pauper players, and Wizards of the Coast, aim for diversity and strategic interaction. Grapeshot, coupled with other efficient Storm enablers, proved too efficient, limiting the viability of other decks and strategies. Therefore, to restore balance and make the format more dynamic, Grapeshot was banned. This decision also extended to other problematic cards in Pauper Storm decks, like Empty the Warrens and Invigorate, which allowed for consistent and early wins.
Grapeshot in Other Formats
While banned in Pauper, Grapeshot remains legal in other prominent MTG formats.
Modern and Legacy
In Modern and Legacy, Grapeshot is used in certain Storm archetype decks. The presence of more powerful removal, counterspells, and interaction in these formats keeps its power in check. Unlike Pauper, these formats can handle Grapeshot’s potential more effectively, as decks often employ cards specifically to disrupt combo strategies. Grapeshot in these formats is strong, but it’s not format-warping. Instead, it is a tool in a deck that is manageable by the varied toolboxes other decks employ in those metas.
Commander (EDH)
Grapeshot is legal in Commander, also known as Elder Dragon Highlander. While combo decks using the Storm mechanic exist in Commander, this format’s multiplayer focus and 100-card singleton deck building limit its consistency. In other words, because of the increased number of players and the deck constraints of Commander, Grapeshot is more of a threat than a definitive win condition. There are simply more things that can go wrong, leading to its legality in that format. In many cases, other cards that synergize within a particular Commander deck will make for better options than Grapeshot.
Why Not Banned in These Formats?
The key reason Grapeshot is not banned in other formats lies in their power level and diversity. Modern and Legacy decks often have access to efficient counterspells, hand disruption, and creature removal. They can stop a Storm combo before it becomes too dangerous, or at least disrupt it enough to present counter play. Similarly, while Grapeshot can be a lethal threat in Commander, the singleton nature of deckbuilding and multiplayer politics make it less overwhelming. Unlike Pauper, these formats boast a larger range of cards that provide ways to slow, stop, or interact with combo-oriented strategies.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Grapeshot legal in Standard?
No. Grapeshot is not legal in Standard, as it hasn’t been printed in a Standard-legal set for many years. It is legal in the eternal formats like Modern, Legacy and Commander.
2. What is the Storm mechanic?
The Storm mechanic is a keyword ability that copies the spell for each other spell that was cast earlier in the turn. For example, if three spells were cast before Grapeshot in the turn, you would deal 4 damage instead of 1 as Grapeshot would make 3 copies that resolved before the original spell.
3. Why was Empty the Warrens banned in Pauper?
Empty the Warrens, like Grapeshot, is a powerful common card in a Storm deck. It allows players to generate a large number of 1/1 Goblin creature tokens, creating an overwhelming board presence that is difficult for the Pauper format to manage. This synergistic power within Storm archetypes alongside Grapeshot resulted in its ban in Pauper.
4. What is Pauper?
Pauper is a Magic: The Gathering format where decks are restricted to only common rarity cards. This format often focuses on synergy and creativity within these constraints, but sometimes certain cards create an unbalanced environment.
5. Is Grapeshot a good card in Commander?
Grapeshot can be a useful finisher in Commander, particularly in decks that can generate a significant number of spells in one turn. However, it’s less consistent and less of a staple than in formats like Pauper (before its ban). Because of Commander’s format, more often than not, a card that is synergistic with the player’s Commander is more reliable than Grapeshot.
6. Where can I find Grapeshot?
Grapeshot is a Magic: the Gathering card that is found in booster packs from sets that it was printed in, or from the secondary market where it is resold. As a common card it is normally a low cost acquisition.
7. What other cards are banned in Pauper?
Other notable cards banned in Pauper include Cloud of Faeries, Cranial Plating, Gitaxian Probe, and Mystic Remora, along with Empty the Warrens and Invigorate. Each was banned to maintain the health of the format, as these cards were often found to be too oppressive in pauper.
8. Is Grapeshot part of the “Storm” archetype?
Yes, Grapeshot is a core card of most Storm decks. It serves as the main win condition for the archetype, where the player will cast many spells to increase the storm count, and deal enough damage to win the game.
9. What other red cards are used in Storm decks?
Other cards that support storm decks include Rite of Flame, Manamorphose, Desperate Ritual, Pyretic Ritual, and Ponder. These cards either accelerate mana production to help cast more spells, or cantrips that replace themselves to help draw more cards for casting.
10. Why is Ponder banned in Modern?
Ponder is banned in Modern to reduce the consistency of combo decks, including Storm. It was too powerful when used in combination with other cards that allow for easy graveyard interaction.
11. What is an “eternal” format in MTG?
An eternal format is a format where all or almost all cards from MTG history are legal to play. Formats like Legacy, Commander, and Vintage are considered eternal formats.
12. Can I play Grapeshot in my casual games?
Yes, Grapeshot is legal in most casual play groups, as long as those casual games follow formats where Grapeshot is legal. Generally this is any format except Pauper.
13. What’s the difference between a banned and a restricted card?
A banned card is not allowed to be included in a deck, while a restricted card (mostly in Vintage) is limited to only one copy per deck. There are no restricted cards in other formats.
14. When was Grapeshot first printed?
Grapeshot was first printed in the Magic: the Gathering set Time Spiral in 2006.
15. Are there any similar spells to Grapeshot?
There are a few spells that utilize the storm mechanic, such as Temporal Fissure or Brain Freeze, but Grapeshot is the most commonly used of the win conditions. While these have a similar mechanic, they have different uses within a game and should not be assumed to be direct replacements for one another.