Greatsword vs. Greataxe: Which Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old debate rages on: Is the greatsword truly superior to the greataxe, or does each weapon carve its own niche in the annals of combat? The answer, like many things in the world of weaponry, isn’t a simple yes or no. It depends heavily on the context – the game, the character build, and even the player’s preferred style of engagement. The core difference lies in their approach to damage and overall utility.
Generally, neither is definitively “better” across the board. Greatswords offer more consistent damage and, in many games, better reach and move sets. This translates to a more reliable damage output, crucial for sustained fights. Greataxes, conversely, present a volatile but potentially devastating alternative. They often boast a higher maximum damage potential, sacrificing consistent results for the chance at brutal hits.
The choice ultimately hinges on a player’s preferences. Do you favor a steady, predictable style of play? Then the greatsword is likely your go-to. Are you a risk-taker who loves the thrill of a big hit and doesn’t mind the occasional swing that falls short? Then the greataxe might be more your cup of tea. This article will dive deep into the nuances of each weapon, exploring their strengths, weaknesses, and where they shine the most. We’ll look at how these weapons fare across different games and systems, providing a comprehensive look at this classic weaponry debate.
Understanding the Core Differences
Damage Output: Consistency vs. Volatility
The fundamental distinction between the greatsword and the greataxe boils down to how they deal damage. A typical representation of this, especially in tabletop role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), is shown with their damage dice. A greatsword usually uses 2d6, creating a bell curve of results centered around an average number, with both low and high extremes less likely. A greataxe, often wielding 1d12, has a far flatter damage distribution; you’re equally likely to roll any number from 1 to 12.
- Greatsword: Favors consistent, mid-range damage. The odds of rolling an average number are much higher. Think of it as a reliable workhorse that steadily chips away at the opponent. The predictable damage makes it easier to plan your tactics.
- Greataxe: Embraces high-risk, high-reward damage. While you might roll a 1, the possibility of rolling a 12 is just as plausible. It appeals to players who enjoy that volatile feel, aiming for those massive, impactful blows.
Gameplay Implications
The difference in damage also impacts how you should approach combat.
- Greatswords are excellent for battles where consistency is paramount. This can be during boss fights, or against enemies with high health pools where reliable DPS (damage per second) is vital. It is also better when fighting weaker enemies as the consistent damage will allow you to defeat them more efficiently.
- Greataxes are best suited for when you want to swing big and hit hard. These are best for players who enjoy the thrill of getting a high roll and don’t mind the risk of rolling low.
Other Factors: Range, Speed, and Move Sets
Beyond raw damage, the two weapons differ in other significant ways.
- Range: Greatswords generally have a longer reach than greataxes, giving a better ability to maintain distance.
- Speed: The greatsword’s move sets are typically more swift and flowing, whereas greataxes tend to have slower but more weighty attacks.
- Move sets: Greatswords often have a more versatile array of attacks, including both thrusting and sweeping motions. Greataxes, usually having a more straightforward, forceful move sets.
- Weight: Greatswords might be heavier, while axes are generally lighter, at least in theory. However, both are generally heavy weapons and might impact player mobility.
Game-Specific Examples
Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) 5e
In D&D 5e, the difference is particularly clear. The 2d6 of the greatsword provides a more predictable average damage, while the 1d12 of the greataxe has a wider damage range. The Great Weapon Fighting style, which lets you reroll 1s or 2s on damage dice, greatly favors the greatsword, increasing its average damage and making it the superior choice in many builds, especially when paired with builds focusing on hitting more often rather than maximizing damage with single, large blows. However, the greataxe gains more from Brutal Critical feature of the barbarian class, where more damage dice are added on a critical hit. The larger the die the greater this additional damage becomes.
New World
In New World, both weapons have distinct roles. Greatswords excel in high damage output and a fast, fluid combat style, while the greataxe often serves as an AoE (area of effect) crowd control tool, used to group enemies together and for its ability to cleave through multiple opponents at once.
Souls-Like Games (Elden Ring, Dark Souls)
Greatswords are often the most consistently powerful weapon choice, boasting a good balance of range, damage, and versatility. While Greataxes often have a similar role, often with increased power but usually at the cost of speed. Greatswords boast great range, damage, and are still fast enough to not get you punished too hard.
The Verdict
As you can see, the question of which is better depends entirely on what you need it for. If consistency and good move sets are your preference, then the greatsword is likely better for you. However, if you like the volatile, heavy impact of rolling a 12, then the greataxe is what you would want. Neither is definitively “better,” as each offers its own unique strengths and weaknesses.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is the Greatsword better with Great Weapon Fighting?
Yes, significantly. Great Weapon Fighting lets you reroll 1s and 2s on damage dice, boosting the greatsword’s average damage more than the greataxe’s.
2. Is the Greataxe better for Barbarians?
The Greataxe can be good for barbarians thanks to their brutal critical class feature, but not until they get this skill. Greatsword are better until that point.
3. What about Critical Hits with Greatsword vs. Greataxe?
On a critical hit, the damage dice of both weapons are doubled. The greataxe gets the advantage here as the d12 has a wider possible range than the two d6 of the greatsword.
4. Which weapon is better against low Armor Class (AC) targets?
Greatswords are generally better against low AC targets due to their consistent damage.
5. Which weapon is better against high AC targets?
Greataxes can be better against high AC targets if you are building for those big damage swings, but consistent damage from the greatsword can be just as effective if not more-so, if you are hitting more often.
6. Can a Paladin wield a Greatsword?
Yes, absolutely. Paladins are proficient with martial weapons, which include greatswords.
7. Is the Greatsword a slashing weapon?
Yes, a greatsword is typically considered a slashing weapon, though some moves may involve thrusting.
8. Is the Greatsword a two-handed weapon?
Yes, the greatsword is designed to be used with two hands, allowing for more power and control.
9. What is the best weapon for a Barbarian?
The best weapon for a barbarian is dependent on your build. In the context of the article, the greatsword is best for a consistent damage output, while greataxe can be better if you are building into heavy single hits. Some unique weapons, such as Balduran’s Giantslayer can also be very powerful for the Barbarian.
10. What Stats do Greatswords use?
This depends on the game, but often greatswords scale with strength and dexterity.
11. Are Greatswords effective in games?
Yes, greatswords are very effective in most games due to their balance of damage, range, and speed.
12. What pairs well with a Greatsword in New World?
Other strength-scaling weapons, like the War Hammer, Greataxe, or Hatchet, can pair well with a Greatsword in New World.
13. Is a Greatsword better than a Longsword?
Greatswords typically have higher damage output but slower swings compared to a longsword, which offers a faster attack.
14. Is a Claymore better than a Longsword?
A Claymore and a Longsword have different strengths. A Longsword is faster, while a Claymore generally has more power.
15. Can you tank with a Greatsword?
Yes, some games allow for tank builds using a Greatsword, especially when paired with other defensive abilities or items.