Table of Contents

Greatsword vs. Greataxe: Which Reigns Supreme?

Quick answer

This page answers Is greatsword better than Greataxe? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The age-old debate rages on: Greatsword or Greataxe? For aspiring heroes, grizzled adventurers, and tabletop gaming enthusiasts alike, the choice between these two iconic weapons can feel monumental. The truth is, there’s no single “better” option. The optimal choice hinges on a variety of factors, including character class, combat style, and even specific rulesets. However, let’s provide a direct answer. In general, the greatsword is often considered slightly more consistent in damage output, while the greataxe offers the potential for higher burst damage, especially when combined with specific character features and lucky critical hits. The greatsword’s reliability often makes it a favored choice for many, but understanding the nuances of both weapons is crucial.

The Core Differences

Damage Dice and Averages

The fundamental difference lies in the damage dice each weapon employs. A greatsword typically uses two six-sided dice (2d6), averaging out to 7 damage. A greataxe, on the other hand, utilizes a single twelve-sided die (1d12), which averages 6.5 damage. On paper, the greatsword has a slight edge in average damage. However, this is just the beginning of the story.

Critical Hits and Damage Spikes

Where the greataxe truly shines is in its critical hits. When a natural 20 is rolled, both weapons double their damage dice. For the greatsword, this means rolling 4d6, while the greataxe rolls 2d12. Due to the higher maximum value of the d12, the greataxe has a higher potential for damage spikes. This makes the greataxe a more appealing choice for players who favor high-risk, high-reward gameplay.

The Impact of the Great Weapon Fighting Style

The Great Weapon Fighting style, available to classes like Fighters and Paladins, adds another layer of complexity. This style allows a player to reroll a damage die that lands on a 1 or 2. This increases the consistency of both weapons, but has a different impact on each. The greatsword benefits more from rerolling the lower dice numbers because of using 2 dice. The greataxe, using only 1 die, has fewer chances to reroll. It reduces the odds of a low damage roll, which slightly increases the average damage of each weapon, but still doesn’t make the greataxe have a higher average.

Other Class-Specific Features

Certain classes have unique features that can affect the viability of each weapon. Barbarians, for instance, often have features like Brutal Critical and Savage Attacks that further amplify critical hits. Given that greataxes have a higher potential critical hit damage, these class features often make greataxes more appealing for the class, especially at higher levels.

The “Better” Choice: Class and Situation

Barbarians: The Axe-Wielding Brutes?

Barbarians are often associated with axes, and for good reason. As mentioned above, their Brutal Critical ability synergizes exceptionally well with the high damage potential of a greataxe. While the article you provided suggests using a greatsword until level 9 (or 13 if not a Half-Orc), this is more nuanced. Half-orcs and builds aiming for crit fishing may benefit from great axe use earlier.

Fighters and Paladins: The Consistent Damage Dealers?

Fighters and Paladins, often relying on consistency, may find the greatsword a more comfortable fit. The Great Weapon Fighting style helps to mitigate the potential for low rolls on the 2d6 damage dice, providing a reliable damage output. The greatsword’s dependable damage makes it suitable for prolonged battles and consistent offense.

The Impact of Target Armor Class

The article also mentions how greatswords are better against low AC targets and greataxes are better against high AC targets. This is often because a single larger damage die benefits more from flat damage bonuses, and higher damage weapons have a higher chance of overcoming damage reduction. However, this rule of thumb is not always true, and it depends on the specific game system.

Beyond D&D 5e

The debate between greatsword and greataxe isn’t limited to D&D 5e. Many other tabletop role-playing games and video games feature similar weapon types. In these other settings, the specific rules, attributes, and bonus damage types can affect which weapon is “better”. For example, in some video games the greatsword may have a better move set, or a greataxe may have more armor penetration.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice between a greatsword and greataxe comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of your character and play style. Both are viable weapons with unique strengths. The greatsword offers consistent damage, while the greataxe holds the potential for massive damage spikes. Consider your class features, preferred play style, and the specific game mechanics before making your decision.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is it true that a greatsword is always better for beginners in D&D 5e? Not necessarily. While the greatsword’s consistent damage may feel more predictable, beginners may also enjoy the thrill of a greataxe’s potential for higher damage. It depends entirely on the player’s preference.
Does the type of dice actually make a significant difference? Yes. The difference between 2d6 and 1d12 is crucial, impacting average damage, the likelihood of critical hits, and how various feats and abilities interact with the weapon’s damage.
If I have advantage, does that make a great axe better? Not inherently. While advantage increases the probability of a critical hit, it benefits both the greatsword and great axe. The potential damage boost of the greataxe on a critical may be more noticeable.
Can a Barbarian effectively use a Greatsword? Absolutely! While greataxes synergize well with a Barbarian’s critical hit focus, the greatsword is still a powerful and viable option, especially early on.
Does the Great Weapon Master feat change the calculations? Yes, the Great Weapon Master feat allows for more damage, but at the cost of to-hit. When making these decisions, take into account the player’s to-hit modifier with and without this feat, which affects how likely attacks will hit, regardless of the weapon’s damage output.
In video games, is the same logic applicable? Not always. Video games often have unique mechanics, such as weapon attack speed, range, special abilities, and stat scaling, which may favor one weapon over the other differently.
What is the significance of a “critical hit” with these weapons? A critical hit doubles the number of damage dice rolled, significantly increasing damage. For the greatsword, this means 4d6, whereas for the greataxe, it’s 2d12.
Which weapon is better for dealing with enemies with high armor? Generally, the greataxe’s higher maximum damage can have an easier time overcoming damage reduction from armor. However, this depends on how that game system’s armor and damage reduction interacts with damage.
Are greatswords really that slow? In some games, greatswords may have slower attack animations than other weapons, which is generally true of most games. However, this isn’t always the case, especially in tabletop role-playing games.
Do racial abilities affect this choice? Yes! Some races, like Half-Orcs with Savage Attacks, synergize well with the high damage potential of a greataxe on a critical hit.
Is Great Weapon Fighting Style always the best fighting style? Not always, other fighting styles such as defense, dueling, or protection may be more suitable depending on the player’s class build and preferences.
What about other two-handed weapons like halberds? Halberds and glaives have their own unique characteristics, such as longer reach, which might make them preferable in certain situations or in some game systems.
Does the “flavor” of the weapon matter? Absolutely! The aesthetic and feel of a weapon can impact your enjoyment of a game. Some players simply prefer the look and feel of a greatsword over an axe and vice versa.
Can I switch between these two weapon types? Yes, absolutely! Many games, especially tabletop ones, allow you to switch weapons as needed. Adjusting to your opponents is vital.
Where can I find more resources on choosing the right weapon? Consult official game rules, forums, character builds websites, and guides relevant to the specific game you are playing.