Table of Contents

Is it Bad to Have Low Honor in RDR2? A Deep Dive into the Morality of the Wild West

Quick answer

This page answers Is it bad to have low honor in RDR2? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Whether it’s “bad” to have low honor in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) depends entirely on your playstyle and desired experience. There’s no objectively “correct” way to play. A low honor playthrough offers a different set of benefits, challenges, and narrative experiences compared to a high honor one. It affects everything from store prices to the game’s ending and how Arthur interacts with the world. The choice is yours to decide what kind of outlaw Arthur Morgan will be.

The Dichotomy of Honor in RDR2

RDR2’s honor system is a nuanced mechanic that shapes Arthur’s journey. It isn’t simply a “good versus evil” meter. Instead, it’s a reflection of Arthur’s choices and how he interacts with the people and world around him. Understanding the implications of high and low honor is key to maximizing your enjoyment of the game.

Benefits of High Honor

Discounts at Shops: Higher honor directly translates to lower prices at stores. This can save you a significant amount of money throughout the game.
Exclusive Outfits: Reaching specific high honor levels unlocks unique and stylish outfits in stores, allowing for greater customization of Arthur’s appearance.
Better Loot from Enemies: While both high and low honor affect loot, high honor often leads to more valuable and practical items.
A “Good” Ending: A high honor playthrough culminates in a more heartwarming and arguably more satisfying ending for Arthur’s story.

Perks of Low Honor

Loot Geared Towards Mayhem: Low honor Arthur will find more deadeye tonics and other items suited for wreaking havoc when looting enemies.
Discount in One Settlement: While most shops penalize you for low honor, one settlement will offer you a discount if you’re known as a scoundrel.
Witnesses Less Likely to Snitch on Minor Crimes: If you commit a minor crime, a low honor Arthur will find that witnesses may be less willing to report it.
Cheaper Bribes: Bribing witnesses is cheaper, although you could just kill them.
A “Bad” Ending: A low honor playthrough, while tragic, offers a different perspective on Arthur’s character and the consequences of his actions.

Canon and Arthur’s Morality

The question of whether low honor Arthur is “canon” is subjective. There is no single “true” way to experience RDR2. Arthur’s character is complex, capable of both great cruelty and surprising compassion. A low honor playthrough isn’t a “wrong” way to play; it’s simply a different interpretation of the character within the game’s framework. His story is impacted by choices that you make as the player.

The Impact on Gameplay and Narrative

The honor system influences various aspects of RDR2, from gameplay mechanics to the overarching narrative.

Character Interactions: Arthur’s dialogue and interactions with NPCs change based on his honor level. A high honor Arthur is generally more polite and helpful, while a low honor Arthur is more cynical and aggressive.
World Reactions: The world reacts differently to Arthur depending on his reputation. People may be more wary of him in towns if he has low honor, and law enforcement will be more vigilant.
Dream Sequences: The animals Arthur dreams of can change based on your honor level.
Ending Variations: Arthur’s final moments and the subsequent epilogue are significantly impacted by his honor level, providing different emotional payoffs.

Delving Deeper: Honor Levels and Their Effects

To truly understand the implications of honor in RDR2, it’s essential to examine the specific benefits associated with different honor levels.

High Honor Tiers

Honor 5: 25% discount at all stores.
Honor 6: Unlocks the final set of outfits to buy in stores (the Deuville, the Drifter, the Dewberry Creek, the Farrier, the Faulkton, and the Gambler).

Low Honor Repercussions

While there are few explicit “benefits” to extremely low honor beyond the loot and witness behavior, the narrative implications are significant. The world feels harsher, Arthur’s relationships suffer, and his final fate takes a darker turn.

Making the Choice: Good or Bad?

Ultimately, the choice of whether to play with high or low honor comes down to personal preference. Do you want to experience Arthur as a tragic figure seeking redemption, or as a hardened outlaw embracing the violent nature of the Wild West? Both paths offer compelling and memorable experiences.

Remember to consider the role of games in education and societal development. As explored by the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org, games like RDR2 can provide immersive environments for exploring complex moral choices and understanding the consequences of our actions.

Conclusion

So, is it bad to have low honor in RDR2? Not necessarily. It’s a different experience, one that explores the darker side of Arthur Morgan and the world he inhabits. Whether you choose to be a saint or a sinner, RDR2 provides a rich and rewarding journey that will stay with you long after the credits roll.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Honor in RDR2

How quickly can Arthur go from Low Honor to High Honor in Red Dead Redemption 2? It depends on the methods used. Completing honor missions and making honorable choices (helping strangers, donating to the camp, etc.) significantly increases honor. Conversely, committing crimes quickly lowers it.
Does honor matter in RDR2? Absolutely. Honor influences Arthur’s personality, dialogue, interactions with the world, store prices, available outfits, enemy loot, and ultimately, the ending you receive.
Is Arthur Morgan high or low honor by default? Arthur starts with neutral honor, allowing you to shape his morality through your choices.
What happens if Arthur dies with low honor? In the “bad ending,” Micah will execute him. His grave will be weathered and without flowers, and a coyote will stand by it.
Does killing bounty hunters lower honor? No, killing bounty hunters does not lower honor. They are considered outlaws themselves.
What is Arthur’s canon death? Arthur’s canon death is succumbing to tuberculosis while watching the sunrise.
How do you rob without losing honor in RDR2? You can rob homesteads and loot without losing honor. This also applies when looting random camps.
Is it better to have high or low honor in RDR2? There is no “better” option. High honor offers discounts and unlocks content while giving a better ending, while low honor influences loot and character interactions.
Do bounties ever go away in RDR2? Yes, you can pay them off, serve jail time (by surrendering to the law), or sometimes they will expire over time.
Should you pay off bounties in RDR2? Paying off bounties is generally recommended to avoid constant encounters with lawmen and bounty hunters.
Can you cure Arthur’s tuberculosis? No, there is no cure for Arthur’s tuberculosis in RDR2. It’s a central plot point.
Does low honor Arthur see a wolf? Yes, if Arthur has low honor, he will see a wolf in his dreams, symbolizing his descent into savagery.
What are the benefits of low honor Arthur? Low honor provides access to loot geared toward mayhem, and in turn, offers discounts in one town.
How many endings does RDR2 have? RDR2 has four endings, influenced by both your honor level and the choices you make near the end of the game.
Does High honor Arthur go to heaven? If Arthur dies with high honor, you’ll see a scene of a buck heading towards the sunrise, symbolizing his ascension.