Is it better to be good or bad in RDR2?

The choice between being good or bad in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) ultimately depends on the player’s personal preference, as both paths offer unique experiences and rewards, with high honor leading to a more compassionate and selfless Arthur, while low honor results in a more selfish and heartless character. Playing with high honor provides benefits such as discounts at general stores, better loot, and a more positive reputation, whereas playing with low honor offers a more challenging experience with increased rewards for causing mayhem.

Understanding Honor in RDR2

How Honor Affects Gameplay

In RDR2, the honor system plays a significant role in shaping the player’s experience, influencing dialogue, storylines, and rewards. The player’s honor level is determined by their actions, such as helping others, killing innocent people, or committing crimes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the benefits of high honor in RDR2?: High honor leads to reduced prices in shops, more outfits to buy, and better loot from enemies, making it an attractive choice for players who want to explore the game’s story and characters without the burden of financial struggles.
2. Can you get discounts at general stores with high honor?: Yes, having high honor grants players discounts at general stores, allowing them to purchase items and supplies at a lower cost.
3. How does low honor affect the game?: Playing with low honor results in a more challenging experience, with increased rewards for causing mayhem, such as deadeye tonics and throwing weapons.
4. Is it worth being bad in RDR2?: While being bad in RDR2 can be rewarding, it ultimately depends on the player’s personal preference, as low honor can lead to a more difficult experience with worse rewards in some aspects.
5. What happens if Arthur dies with bad honor?: If Arthur dies with bad honor, his grave will be weathered and unkempt, guarded by a black coyote, and his epitaph will read “Blessed are those that mourn for they be comforted”.
6. Can you play as John Marston after Arthur dies?: Yes, after Arthur’s death, the player takes control of John Marston, allowing them to continue the story and experience the game from a different perspective.
7. Is RDR2 better as John or Arthur?: The choice between playing as John or Arthur depends on the player’s preference, as both characters offer unique experiences and storylines.
8. Who kills Arthur Morgan?: Arthur’s death is determined by the player’s choices, with Micah executing him if the player has low honor, or Arthur succumbing to his injuries and disease with high honor.
9. Should I be honorable in RDR2?: The decision to be honorable in RDR2 depends on the player’s desired experience, with high honor offering a more compassionate and selfless Arthur, while low honor results in a more selfish and heartless character.
10. Do RDR2 choices matter?: Yes, the player’s choices in RDR2 have a significant impact on the game, influencing dialogue, storylines, and rewards.
11. How many endings does RDR2 have?: There are four different endings in RDR2, depending on the player’s honor level and choices.
12. Is Arthur good or bad in Red Dead Redemption 2?: Arthur’s morality is determined by the player’s choices, with high honor resulting in a more compassionate and selfless character, while low honor leads to a more selfish and heartless Arthur.
13. Can Arthur fall in love in RDR2?: Yes, Arthur can fall in love with certain characters in the game, such as Eliza, a waitress he meets.
14. What is the saddest ending in RDR2?: The saddest ending in RDR2 is Arthur’s death, which is a poignant and emotional conclusion to the game.
15. Is RDR2 too sad to replay?: While RDR2 features many sad stories, the game’s replay value is still high, with many players enjoying the game multiple times despite the emotional challenges.