Evolving Your Pokémon: CP vs. Potential – The Ultimate Guide
So, you’re standing there in Pokémon GO, staring at a potential evolution. The burning question echoes in your mind: Is it better to evolve a Pokémon with a low CP or a high CP? The short answer is, it’s almost always better to evolve a Pokémon with high appraisal, typically signified by high stars, rather than solely focusing on its current Combat Power (CP). While CP is a quick indicator of strength, it’s not the whole story. Let’s dive into the nuanced world of Pokémon evolution to understand why.
Understanding CP, IVs, and Appraisal
Before we delve deeper, let’s establish a baseline understanding of key terms:
- CP (Combat Power): A numerical representation of a Pokémon’s battle strength. Higher CP generally means a Pokémon will perform better in battles.
- IVs (Individual Values): Hidden stats that determine a Pokémon’s potential. They range from 0 to 15 for Attack, Defense, and HP. These values are fixed and cannot be changed.
- Appraisal: The in-game assessment of a Pokémon’s IVs, usually represented by a star rating (0-4 stars) and comments from your team leader. This helps you gauge a Pokémon’s potential.
Why High Appraisal Trumps High CP (Initially)
While a high CP Pokémon might seem appealing for immediate gratification, it’s essential to consider the long-term potential. A Pokémon with high IVs (indicated by a good appraisal, usually 3 or 4 stars) has a higher ceiling for its CP. It will ultimately become stronger than a lower-IV Pokémon, even if the latter starts with a higher CP.
Think of it this way: a high CP Pokémon with low IVs is like a house built on a shaky foundation. It might look impressive now, but it won’t stand the test of time. A high-IV Pokémon, on the other hand, is a solid investment that will pay off handsomely as you power it up and evolve it.
The cost to Power Up a Pokemon (i.e, raise its CP) is a key consideration.
Evolving Strategies: Maximizing Your Pokémon’s Potential
Here’s a breakdown of the ideal evolution strategy:
- Prioritize Appraisal: Always check your Pokémon’s appraisal first. Aim for Pokémon with 3-star or 4-star ratings, as these indicate high IVs.
- Consider the Species: Some Pokémon species are inherently stronger than others. Focus on evolving species known for their powerful evolutions in the current meta (e.g., strong raid attackers, gym defenders, PvP contenders).
- CP as a Secondary Factor: Once you’ve identified Pokémon with good IVs, use CP as a tie-breaker. If you have two Pokémon of the same species with similar appraisal, evolve the one with the higher CP.
- Candy and Stardust: Remember that evolving and powering up Pokémon requires Candy and Stardust. Factor this into your decision-making process. It might be more efficient to invest in a high-IV Pokémon that will be a long-term asset.
Situations Where High CP Might Be Preferable (With Caveats)
There are a few limited scenarios where prioritizing CP over IVs might be justifiable, but these come with significant caveats:
- Early Game: When you’re just starting, and resources are scarce, evolving a high-CP Pokémon can provide an immediate boost to your battling capabilities. However, be prepared to replace it later with a higher-IV counterpart.
- Quick Gym Placement: If you need to quickly place a Pokémon in a gym to earn PokeCoins, a high-CP Pokémon might deter other players from challenging it, at least temporarily. This strategy is less effective as you level up and face stronger opponents.
Don’t Forget About Movesets!
Evolving a Pokemon is not as easy as only considering CP or IV. Once you have evolved a Pokémon, the moves it learns play a huge role in its effectiveness. Some moves are simply better than others, so consider waiting to evolve your Pokémon until a community day that includes special moves!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to help you refine your Pokémon evolution strategy:
1. Are Pokémon with higher CP always better?
No, not necessarily. Higher CP indicates a Pokémon’s current strength, but it doesn’t guarantee long-term potential. A Pokémon with lower CP but higher IVs will eventually surpass a high-CP, low-IV Pokémon when fully powered up.
2. Is it better to evolve higher CP or IV?
Higher IVs (as indicated by appraisal stars) are almost always preferable for long-term strength. CP can be increased through powering up, but IVs are fixed.
3. Should I evolve a 0-star Pokémon?
It’s generally not recommended to evolve a 0-star Pokémon unless you lack better alternatives. A 0-star Pokémon has very low IVs and will never reach its full potential. If you don’t have another Pokémon of the same species, it may be worth holding onto the 0-star until it can be replaced by one with a better Appraisal. A fully 0% IV Pokemon is extremely rare.
4. Should I evolve a 3-star Pokémon?
Yes! A 3-star Pokémon indicates high IVs and excellent potential. Evolving a 3-star Pokémon is usually a wise decision. If your Pokémon has three stars and a red stamp, it means that it has 100% perfect IVs.
5. Is CP or stars more important?
Stars (appraisal) are generally more important because they represent potential. CP is the current state. A 3-star Pokémon will always have a higher potential CP than a 0-star Pokémon of the same species.
6. How do I know if a Pokémon has perfect IVs?
In the appraisal system, a 3-star Pokémon with a red stamp indicates perfect 100% IVs. If it has three star with an orange stamp, it has around 80-99% perfect IVs.
7. Does CP level matter when evolving?
The CP circle stays as full as it did before. As a result, it really doesn’t matter in which order you boost a Pokemon.
8. Does Pokémon CP really matter?
Yes, CP is a good indicator of a Pokémon’s base strength. In general, a Pokemon with higher CP will perform better in battle than one with a lower stat.
9. Should I evolve a 4-star Pokémon?
Absolutely! A 4-star Pokémon has perfect IVs and the highest possible potential. Evolving a 4-star Pokémon is always a great idea.
10. Should I always evolve a shiny Pokémon?
Shiny Pokémon are purely cosmetic variants and are not inherently stronger. Evolve them if you like their appearance, but don’t expect any stat boosts.
11. When should I not evolve a Pokémon?
Consider not evolving a Pokémon if you’re waiting for a Community Day to get a special move or if you prefer its pre-evolution form aesthetically.
12. Should I evolve my 100% IV Pokémon immediately?
Ideally, yes. A 100% IV Pokémon is the best you can get. However, consider waiting for a Community Day or special event to ensure it learns the best moves. Never power up a Pokémon before evolving it!
13. Are level 0 Pokémon rare?
Level 0 Pokémon do not exist, but 0% IV Pokemon are even rarer than 100% pokemon, since the former can never come from raids, eggs, research tasks or trades.
14. Should I keep one of every Pokémon?
That’s a personal preference. Some players collect one of each for completion’s sake. It’s generally not necessary for gameplay purposes. Do you keep 1 of each kind in your Pokémon Go backpack?
15. Are two-star Pokémon worth keeping?
Some are rare, and your best stuff might be 2-stars. For instance, if you only did 2 Palkia raids, and both were 2-stars, you probably don’t want to delete them.
Conclusion: Evolve Smart, Evolve Strategically
In Pokémon GO, evolution is a critical component of building a strong team. While high CP might offer a temporary advantage, prioritizing high IVs (indicated by good appraisal stars) is crucial for long-term success. By understanding the nuances of CP, IVs, and movesets, you can make informed decisions and evolve your Pokémon strategically to maximize their potential. So, get out there, catch ’em all, and evolve them wisely!
Interested in learning more about the intersection of gaming and education? Visit the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.