Taking 20: Mastering the Art of Guaranteed Success in D&D
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Taking 20 in Dungeons & Dragons is a special rule that allows a character to automatically achieve the highest possible result (a 20) on a skill check, bypassing the usual d20 roll. However, this isn’t a free pass to instant mastery. It only applies under very specific conditions: the character must have ample time, face no threats or distractions, and the skill being attempted must not carry penalties for failure. Essentially, it represents the character taking their time to meticulously repeat the action until they inevitably succeed. The core idea is that with enough attempts, even a novice will eventually stumble upon the correct technique.
Understanding the Nuances of Taking 20
The “Take 20” rule isn’t universally applied across all editions of D&D, and even when present, its interpretation can vary from table to table. It’s crucial to understand the conditions required and the implications of using it. It’s less about raw power and more about resource management – specifically, time.
When Can You Take 20?
The key phrases to remember are:
- Plenty of time: This is the most significant constraint. Taking 20 implies attempting the task repeatedly. A simple lock might take minutes; a complex ritual could take hours, or even days. The DM determines how long taking 20 actually takes.
- No threats or distractions: If a dragon is breathing down your neck, or a goblin army is raiding the village, you cannot take 20. The environment must be safe and conducive to focused effort.
- No penalties for failure: This is often overlooked. Some skills, like picking a poison lock or disarming a trap, have consequences for failing. If failure triggers a trap, using ‘Take 20’ is simply not applicable. If there is a chance of a negative consequence, the ability is off limits.
The Difference Between Take 10 and Take 20
It’s crucial to distinguish “Taking 20” from “Taking 10”. Taking 10 means that when your character is not in immediate danger or distracted, instead of rolling 1d20 for the skill check, you calculate your result as if you had rolled a 10.
Here’s a comparison:
| Feature | Take 10 | Take 20 |
|---|---|---|
| :—————- | :————————————- | :—————————————————————————————————————— |
| Time | Normal time for the action | 20 times the normal time |
| Risk | Low; action completed quickly | High; long exposure increases risk of interruption |
| Conditions | No immediate danger or distractions | Plenty of time, no threats or distractions, no penalties for failure |
| Success Rate | 10 + Skill Modifier | Automatically achieves a result of 20 + Skill Modifier (effectively the highest possible outcome in the given situation) |
| Typical Uses | Routine tasks, checking for traps, etc. | Complex tasks with no time pressure, like decoding ancient texts, crafting complex items, or meticulously searching a room |
Think of it this way: Take 10 is about consistency; Take 20 is about guaranteed success at a significant cost.
Applying “Take 20” in Your Game
As a Dungeon Master, you have the final say on when and how “Take 20” can be used. Be clear with your players about the conditions required and the potential consequences of taking too long. It can add a layer of realism and resource management to your game, making choices more meaningful. Consider also the impact of using ‘Take 20’ to the world. For example, how available are skills to the average person if there are multiple ways to succeed?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Taking 20 in D&D
Here are some frequently asked questions about the nuanced details of “Take 20” in D&D:
- Can you always take 20 in D&D 5e? No. The rule for taking 20 is not directly stated in the core rule books for 5e, but the Dungeon Master’s Guide (DMG) references it as an option if the situation allows. It’s up to the DM to determine if the conditions are met.
- Is taking 20 the same as rolling a natural 20? Absolutely not. A natural 20 on an attack roll is an automatic hit (and often critical hit). Taking 20 is an alternative to rolling, effectively guaranteeing a result of 20 + relevant modifiers on a skill check, but only under specific conditions.
- What if a random event interrupts taking 20? The DM should adjudicate based on the situation. The character might have to start over, suffer a minor setback, or face a new challenge altogether. This highlights the risk associated with taking a long time on a task.
- Does taking 20 guarantee success on any skill check? No. Some skill checks are simply impossible, regardless of the result. The DM should set reasonable limits based on the character’s abilities and the inherent difficulty of the task.
- Can you take 20 on combat-related skills? Generally no. Combat is inherently chaotic and time-sensitive. The conditions required for taking 20 (plenty of time, no threats) are rarely met in a combat situation.
- How does taking 20 interact with Advantage and Disadvantage? Advantage and Disadvantage apply to dice rolls. Since taking 20 bypasses the dice roll, Advantage and Disadvantage are irrelevant.
- Can you take 20 to make a saving throw? Typically no. Saving throws are reactive actions taken in response to immediate threats. The conditions for taking 20 (plenty of time, no threats) are usually not met.
- What about skills with variable DCs (Difficulty Classes)? The DM determines the DC based on the complexity of the task. Taking 20 guarantees a result of 20 + modifiers, but that might still fall short of a very high DC.
- Is there a homebrew rule to modify the time required for taking 20? Many DMs create custom rules to adjust the time required for taking 20, perhaps based on the character’s proficiency or the complexity of the task. This is entirely within the DM’s discretion.
- How does ‘Take 20’ affect party dynamics? Taking 20 can create interesting party dynamics. While one character is meticulously working on a task, the others might need to keep watch, gather supplies, or pursue other objectives. This can lead to collaborative gameplay and shared responsibility.
- Could a player cheese the system by trying to Take 20 in every situation? A good DM will actively discourage this. Emphasize the time cost, the potential for interruptions, and the limitations of the rule. If a player is consistently abusing the system, have a conversation about reasonable gameplay.
- Does ‘Take 20’ apply to ability checks, or only skill checks? The principle can apply to both, but DMs should be particularly careful with ability checks. Taking 20 to bench press an impossible weight, for instance, is not reasonable.
- How does ‘Take 20’ interact with magical assistance? Spells or abilities that grant bonuses to skill checks can be factored into the final result when taking 20. This includes guidance, bardic inspiration, and similar effects.
- Are there skills where taking 20 is always appropriate? Certain crafting skills (e.g., blacksmithing, alchemy) are often ideal candidates for taking 20. These tasks typically involve repetitive actions and offer ample time for experimentation.
- How can I, as a DM, make ‘Take 20’ more engaging? Describe the process in detail. Instead of simply saying “You succeed,” narrate the character’s struggles, experiments, and eventual breakthrough. This can make the success feel more earned and meaningful. You can even use it as a chance to have the player show off their skill.
Conclusion
Mastering the “Take 20” rule requires understanding its limitations and implications. It’s a tool for creating realistic and engaging gameplay, but it should be used judiciously. By clearly communicating the conditions required and the potential consequences, DMs can empower players to make meaningful choices and enhance their D&D experience.
For more insights into the intersection of games and learning, be sure to check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.