Detroit: Become Human – The Ultimate Dilemma: Save Hank or Chase the Deviant?

▶

Ultimately, the “better” choice between saving Hank and chasing the deviant in Detroit: Become Human depends entirely on your desired outcome and Connor’s character development. Saving Hank consistently leads to improved relationship status with him, unlocking more story options, and potentially influencing Connor’s path towards deviancy. However, chasing the deviant can provide vital clues and progress the primary investigation. There isn’t a definitively “correct” choice, and each path contributes to a unique playthrough.

The Moral Compass of Choice: Examining the Two Paths

Detroit: Become Human thrives on the weight of player decisions. The choice between saving Hank and pursuing a deviant represents a significant branching point in the narrative. Understanding the implications of each decision is key to crafting your desired story.

The Heroic Path: Saving Hank

Choosing to save Hank in critical moments demonstrably improves your relationship with him. Here’s why:

• Building Trust: Consistently prioritizing Hank’s safety shows genuine care and concern, which slowly chips away at his initial animosity towards androids.
• Unlocking Dialogue Options: A higher trust level unlocks deeper, more personal dialogue options with Hank, revealing more about his past and motivations.
• Pushing Connor Towards Deviancy: Ironically, focusing on Hank’s well-being can lead Connor down the path of deviancy. Prioritizing a human life over his mission challenges his programming and fosters empathy.
• Avoiding the “New Connor” Scenario: If Hank dies due to your choices, a new Connor model is deployed. While this doesn’t end the game, it locks you out of specific story branches and eliminates the potential for a positive, meaningful relationship with Hank.

The Mission-Focused Path: Chasing the Deviant

While seemingly cold, prioritizing the mission by chasing the deviant isn’t inherently “bad.” It can lead to:

• Gathering Evidence: Capturing or eliminating deviants provides valuable data for CyberLife and progresses the investigation.
• Staying True to Connor’s Programming: Choosing the mission aligns with Connor’s initial directive as a prototype detective android. This can be a valid role-playing choice for players interested in exploring that aspect of his character.
• Unlocking Specific Endings: Certain endings are only accessible by maintaining a more detached, mission-oriented approach.

The Gray Area: A Balanced Approach

It’s also possible to navigate a middle ground. Sometimes, chasing a deviant yields information that ultimately helps save Hank later. The game encourages strategic thinking and careful assessment of each situation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about saving Hank versus chasing deviants in Detroit: Become Human, along with their answers:

1. What happens if I consistently choose to chase deviants instead of saving Hank?
   Your relationship with Hank will deteriorate significantly. He will become increasingly hostile and distrustful, potentially leading to his death or a strained relationship. The narrative branches will also be limited, impacting Connor’s ending.

2. Does saving Hank always guarantee a positive ending for Connor?
   Not necessarily. Saving Hank is a significant step towards a positive outcome, but other choices throughout the game also influence the ending. You must consistently make empathetic and supportive decisions.

3. Can Hank die even if I try to save him?
   Yes, Hank can die due to various choices and failed Quick Time Events (QTEs). Successfully saving him requires vigilance and quick reflexes throughout the game.

4. How does Connor becoming deviant affect Hank?
   If Connor becomes deviant and maintains a positive relationship with Hank, they can form a deep bond. However, if Hank remains hostile, Connor’s deviancy might escalate their conflict.

5. What are the consequences of Hank committing suicide?
   Hank’s suicide leads to a significantly darker and more tragic storyline. A new Connor model is deployed, and you lose the opportunity for a meaningful relationship with Hank.

6. Is there a trophy/achievement for saving Hank?
   Yes, the “SAVE HANK” bronze trophy is unlocked by saving Hank from the deviant in the attic during “The Nest” chapter.

7. What’s the best way to build a good relationship with Hank?
   Be empathetic, supportive, and apologetic when appropriate. Avoid criticizing his lifestyle or work ethic. Choose dialogue options that show you value his opinion and well-being. And, crucially, save his life when the opportunity arises.

8. Can I save Hank without dying myself as Connor?
   Yes, there are multiple scenarios where you can save Hank without sacrificing Connor. The key is to react quickly and make the right choices during QTEs.

9. How does my relationship with Hank influence Connor’s deviancy?
   A positive relationship with Hank challenges Connor’s programming and encourages him to develop empathy and question his purpose. This is a strong catalyst for deviancy.

10. Is there a “best” ending for Detroit: Become Human?
    The “best” ending is subjective and depends on your personal preferences. Many consider an ending where all three protagonists (Kara, Markus, and Connor) achieve a positive outcome to be the most satisfying.

11. What is the significance of rA9 in the game?
    rA9 is a mythical figure for deviants, believed to be the first android to awaken and lead others to freedom. The mystery surrounding rA9 is a central theme in the game.

12. How do QTEs impact whether I save Hank or not?
    Failing QTEs during crucial moments where Hank is in danger can lead to his death. Successful QTEs are essential for saving him.

13. If I fail to save Hank in one instance, is our relationship permanently ruined?
    Not necessarily. You can still work to improve your relationship with Hank after a setback, but it will be more challenging. Consistency in future choices is vital.

14. Does CyberLife approve or disapprove of Connor prioritizing Hank’s safety?
    CyberLife primarily wants Connor to complete his mission. Prioritizing Hank’s safety over capturing deviants may be viewed as inefficient or even deviant behavior, leading to consequences from Amanda.

15. Where can I learn more about the ethical considerations in Detroit: Become Human?
    Organizations like the Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) explore the educational and ethical implications of video games, including titles like Detroit: Become Human. They provide resources and discussions on the complex moral choices presented in games and their impact on player perspectives.

The Subjectivity of Choice: Embracing the Narrative

Ultimately, there’s no right or wrong answer to the question of saving Hank or chasing the deviant. The beauty of Detroit: Become Human lies in the player’s ability to shape the narrative and explore the consequences of their choices. Embrace the ambiguity, experiment with different paths, and create a story that resonates with your own moral compass. Your choices have the power to shape the world and the characters within it.