Is it Better to Sell or Donate in Animal Crossing? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question for any budding islander in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is: should you sell your hard-earned catches and finds, or should you donate them to the museum? The answer, like many things in this charming life sim, isn’t entirely straightforward. In short, it’s best to do both, but with a strategic approach. While selling provides immediate financial gain, donating contributes to your long-term collection goals and provides unique rewards. Let’s delve deeper into how to make the most of both options.
Understanding the Value of Selling
Nook’s Cranny and Market Prices
Nook’s Cranny is your go-to destination for selling almost anything you acquire. From fish and bugs to furniture and crafted items, the Nooklings will happily take them off your hands in exchange for Bells. The prices are fixed, but some items, like sharks or rare insects, fetch significantly more. Furthermore, certain items are designated as “Hot Items” daily. These sell for double the normal price, making them especially lucrative.
Crafting and Selling
While selling raw materials directly isn’t generally recommended, crafting can exponentially increase their value. For example, crafting using materials like wood and iron nuggets to make furniture and tools, and then selling those finished products, can significantly boost your earnings. The Trophy Case and Street Piano stand out as the most profitable items to craft, and they can generate a hefty profit.
The Stalk Market
For those willing to take a risk, the “stalk market” (buying and selling turnips) offers a chance for astronomical gains. However, it’s also a gamble, with turnip prices fluctuating wildly throughout the week. Successful participation in the stalk market can lead to a massive influx of Bells, enabling you to tackle many projects at once.
The Benefits of Donating to the Museum
Completing Your Collection
Donating to the Museum, overseen by the scholarly Blathers, is crucial for long-term progression and personal satisfaction. Each fish, bug, fossil, and piece of art you donate adds to your growing collection, allowing you to learn about the natural world and the art world. You will also be able to admire your discoveries in the beautifully detailed exhibits.
Museum Rewards
Besides the sense of accomplishment, donating leads to concrete rewards. When a section of the museum (such as the bug exhibit) is fully populated, Blathers will congratulate you. Ultimately, when you complete every exhibit, you’ll receive a special Museum Model as a token of your dedication. These rewards are unique and cannot be obtained through selling.
Keeping Track of Discoveries
Donating early and often makes it easier to keep track of what you’ve already acquired. Every time you catch a new creature, you get a notification about your encyclopedia entry, thus making it easy to avoid catching duplicate items.
No Space Limitations
Unlike your personal storage, the museum can hold countless items. If you have a particularly rare catch you might want to keep but lack the space, donating is a great way to put it on display.
Strategic Donating and Selling
The First of Everything
The most popular strategy is to donate the first of every type of catch you encounter to the museum. After that initial donation, you can then sell duplicates. This method ensures your collection is progressing while still giving you a flow of income.
High-Value Items
While it’s tempting to sell everything, certain items, like Gold Nuggets, are more valuable when used in crafting. It’s worth holding on to these. As for items that sell well, creatures like the Scorpion, Sturgeon, and Barreleye will earn you a considerable profit on the open market.
Balancing Act
The key is balance. Don’t neglect the museum for profit and vice versa. Prioritizing the donation of the initial copy of a find, and then selling duplicates, ensures that you can grow your museum and continue improving your island, all while keeping your pockets well lined.
FAQs: Your Burning Questions Answered
1. What happens if I donate everything to the museum?
Once every section of the museum is complete, Blathers will award you with a special Museum Model, a testament to your dedication as a collector.
2. Should I sell crafting materials like wood and iron?
It’s generally not advisable to sell these materials directly. They are more valuable when used to craft and sell furniture and other items.
3. Are sharks really worth selling?
Absolutely! Sharks consistently sell for high prices, making them lucrative catches for your island’s economy. Even less valuable sharks like the Hammerhead will bring in a good sum of Bells.
4. What’s the rarest fish to catch?
The Coelacanth is one of the rarest fish, known to be found in the ocean during rain. It is available all year round, at all times of day.
5. What’s the most valuable thing to sell?
Excluding items that use hybrid flowers or rare items to craft, the Trophy Case is the most valuable item you can sell in New Horizons.
6. What sells well besides rare fish and bugs?
Certain creatures like the Wasp, Mahi-mahi, Tuna, and Scorpion sell for adjusted, higher prices when you complete specific island features.
7. What’s the most profitable item to craft?
The Trophy Case and Street Piano are the most valuable items you can craft, requiring specific DIY recipes and resources.
8. Does the donation box actually do anything?
Yes. You can deposit or withdraw 1,000 Bells at a time. When sold at Nook’s Cranny, the player earns back the amount of Bells currently donated in addition to the item’s normal sell price.
9. What if I bury a fossil?
Burying six fossils will prevent any new ones from spawning on your island until you dig them up. This is great for keeping your island tidy.
10. What happens if I donate fake art to Blathers?
Blathers won’t accept fake art. It will be stuck in your inventory. Timmy and Tommy also won’t buy it.
11. Is it bad to only sell and never donate?
You would be missing out on important rewards, the completion of the museum, and tracking your discoveries. While selling generates fast wealth, donating is valuable for island progression.
12. Why should I save Bells?
You need Bells to purchase many items in the game. Also, you receive interest on your saved Bells.
13. Why can’t I give Tom Nook fish at the start of the game?
You have to unlock the ability to donate to Blathers first. Tom Nook will tell you that Blathers is a friend who will be happy to accept your specimens for the museum.
14. What are some of the most expensive items to buy?
The Cold Sleep Pod, Elaborate Kimono Stand, Castle Tower, Grand Piano, Yacht, Luxury Car, Throne, and Crown are some of the most expensive items to purchase.
15. What’s the fastest way to make money?
Time travel, planting money trees, selling fruit, using Nook Miles for Bell Vouchers, and playing the stalk market are all great ways to make a lot of bells quickly.
Conclusion: Your Island, Your Choice
Whether you prioritize the pursuit of Bells or the collection of the museum exhibits, Animal Crossing: New Horizons offers flexibility in how you play. The key is to be strategic, balance your need for profit with your long-term goals, and have fun exploring the diverse opportunities on your island. Remember, it’s your island, so create the adventure that best fits you!