Is It OK to Sell Remembrance of the Grafted? A Tarnished’s Dilemma
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the vast and unforgiving world of Elden Ring, every decision carries weight. Among the most significant choices players face are what to do with the Remembrances they acquire after defeating major bosses. These powerful items offer a tempting shortcut to wealth or a pathway to unique and powerful armaments. The Remembrance of the Grafted, obtained after felling Godrick the Grafted, is one such item that presents a pivotal decision: should you sell it for 20,000 Runes, or unlock its power at the Roundtable Hold?
The short answer: No, it’s generally not recommended to sell the Remembrance of the Grafted, especially early in the game. While the Runes offer immediate gratification, the weapons you can acquire in exchange for the remembrance offer are often more beneficial in the long run.
Unpacking the Remembrance of the Grafted
Let’s delve deeper into the options and their implications. The Remembrance of the Grafted presents two distinct paths:
- Consuming for Runes: This option grants you 20,000 Runes, a substantial sum, especially in the early game. Runes are the lifeblood of Elden Ring, used to level up your character, purchase equipment, and upgrade weapons.
- Exchanging at Roundtable Hold: By taking the Remembrance to Enia, the Finger Reader, at the Roundtable Hold, you can trade it for one of two unique items: the Axe of Godrick or the Grafted Dragon fist weapon.
Why Exchanging Is Usually the Better Choice
The allure of 20,000 Runes is undeniable, but the value of the Axe of Godrick or the Grafted Dragon often outweighs the immediate influx of currency, especially in the early stages of the game. Here’s why:
- Unique Weaponry: These weapons are exclusive to the Remembrance of the Grafted. You cannot acquire them through any other means.
- Powerful Stats and Skills: Both weapons possess unique stats and skills that can significantly enhance your combat prowess. The Axe of Godrick is a strength-focused greataxe with a powerful skill, while the Grafted Dragon allows you to spew fire from your fist.
- Early Game Advantage: Acquiring these weapons early on provides a tangible advantage against challenging bosses and enemies.
- Rune Farming Alternatives: While 20,000 Runes seems like a lot, more efficient rune farming methods become available as you progress through the game.
Considering Your Build and Playstyle
The optimal choice also hinges on your character build and preferred playstyle.
- Strength Builds: The Axe of Godrick is an excellent choice for strength-focused characters. Its high damage output and powerful weapon skill make it a formidable weapon in the early to mid-game.
- Strength/Faith Builds: The Grafted Dragon weapon is a suitable pick for builds that require strength and faith in their skills.
Ultimately, the decision is yours, but carefully consider the long-term benefits of obtaining unique and powerful weaponry versus the short-term gain of Runes.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Remembrances
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about Remembrances in Elden Ring:
1. Can I Get Both Weapons from a Single Remembrance?
No. Each Remembrance can only be exchanged for one item from Enia. If you want both items, you need to duplicate the Remembrance at a Walking Mausoleum.
2. What Is a Walking Mausoleum, and How Do I Use It?
Walking Mausoleums are giant, mobile structures scattered throughout the Lands Between. By clearing the skull-like formations on their legs, you can bring them down and access their interior, allowing you to duplicate a Remembrance.
3. Are All Remembrances Worth Duplicating?
Yes, duplicating Remembrances is generally considered a good idea. It allows you to acquire both weapon and spell options associated with each boss.
4. What Happens If I Accidentally Consume a Remembrance?
If you accidentally consume a Remembrance for Runes, you cannot recover it. You’ll need to defeat the corresponding boss again in a New Game Plus cycle to obtain another one.
5. Do Remembrances Carry Over to New Game Plus?
Yes, Remembrances carry over to New Game Plus, allowing you to acquire any items you missed in your previous playthrough.
6. Which Remembrance Is Considered the Best Overall?
While subjective, many players consider the Remembrance of the Blasphemous (obtained from Rykard, Lord of Blasphemy) to be one of the best, as it can be traded for the Blasphemous Blade, a powerful weapon with self-healing properties.
7. How Do I Decide Which Weapon to Choose from a Remembrance?
Consider your character build, playstyle, and the stats of the weapons. Read descriptions, watch gameplay videos, and experiment to determine which weapon best suits your needs.
8. Can I Use Remembrances to Level Up My Character Significantly?
While Remembrances provide a decent amount of Runes, they are not the most efficient way to level up. Focus on exploring the world, completing quests, and finding better rune farming spots.
9. Is the Grafted Dragon a Viable Weapon in the Late Game?
The Grafted Dragon can remain viable with proper upgrades and a suitable build. However, it may not be as powerful as some late-game weapons, particularly against enemies resistant to fire damage.
10. Is the Axe of Godrick a Good Choice for a Beginner?
Yes, the Axe of Godrick is an excellent choice for beginners, especially those focusing on strength builds. Its high damage output makes it effective against a wide range of enemies.
11. Do Remembrances Expire or Disappear?
No, Remembrances do not expire or disappear. You can hold onto them indefinitely until you decide what to do with them.
12. Can I Trade Remembrances with Other Players?
No, Remembrances cannot be traded with other players. They are bound to your character.
13. What’s the Difference Between a Remembrance and a Great Rune?
Remembrances are obtained from defeating major bosses and can be exchanged for unique items. Great Runes are also obtained from bosses but must be restored at a Divine Tower to unlock their full potential. They provide passive bonuses when equipped and activated with a Rune Arc.
14. Is Godrick the Weakest Demigod in Elden Ring?
Within the lore, Godrick is generally considered one of the weaker demigods due to his numerous defeats.
15. Where Can I Learn More About Elden Ring Builds and Strategies?
There are numerous online resources, including wikis, forums, and video guides, dedicated to Elden Ring. Experimentation and personal experience are also valuable learning tools. You can also find insights into gaming as a learning tool at the Games Learning Society by visiting GamesLearningSociety.org.
Conclusion
While the temptation to cash in the Remembrance of the Grafted for a quick 20,000 Runes is understandable, especially early in Elden Ring, the Axe of Godrick or the Grafted Dragon are typically the better choice. These unique weapons provide a tangible advantage in combat and are often more valuable than the temporary boost in Runes. Ultimately, the decision is yours, but consider your build, playstyle, and long-term goals before making your choice. May your journey in the Lands Between be filled with triumph and discovery!