Is Grading Modern Pokémon Cards Worth the Hype? A Collector’s Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question on every modern Pokémon TCG collector’s mind: is it worth grading modern Pokémon cards? The short answer is, it depends. While the allure of a perfectly encased, officially graded card is strong, the reality is that not every card benefits from the process. Collectors might invest a fortune in grading, only to discover the card’s value hasn’t increased enough to justify the cost, or even worse, has dropped below the grading investment. Whether or not it is worth grading modern cards really boils down to careful selection, market awareness, and a healthy dose of realistic expectations.
Understanding the Grading Game
What is Card Grading and Why Does it Matter?
Card grading is the process by which a third-party company, such as PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator), Beckett Grading Services (BGS), or CGC (Certified Collectibles Group), assesses the condition of a trading card. This assessment results in a numerical grade, typically on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 representing a “Gem Mint” condition.
The grade assigned is based on several factors:
- Centering: How well the image is aligned on the card.
- Corners: Sharpness and lack of wear on the card’s corners.
- Edges: Smoothness and absence of damage along the edges.
- Surface: Lack of scratches, blemishes, and print defects on the card’s surface.
A higher grade typically translates to a higher market value because it signifies a card in exceptional condition, which is highly desirable among collectors. But this desirability also depends on the card itself. A common card in perfect condition will still be far less valuable than a rare card, even one in less than perfect condition.
The Cost Factor: Is the Investment Worth the Potential Return?
Grading isn’t free. Each grading service charges a fee per card, which can range from $15 to over $500, depending on the service level selected and the card’s declared value. Faster turnaround times and higher insurance coverage come with increased costs. This is where the cost-benefit analysis comes into play.
Before submitting a card for grading, research its raw (ungraded) value. Then, estimate the potential increase in value if it receives a high grade (PSA 10, BGS 9.5 or higher). If the projected profit margin is slim or non-existent after factoring in grading fees, it might not be worth the investment. Many modern sets produce a large number of near-mint cards, reducing the premium paid for those graded as a 10.
Modern vs. Vintage: A Different Landscape
The vintage Pokémon card market (Base Set, Jungle, Fossil, etc.) is generally more forgiving when it comes to grading. Older cards in high grades are rarer and command significant premiums due to their age and scarcity. In contrast, modern cards have been printed in much larger quantities, which lowers their rarity and the value of grading unless you are dealing with exceptional cards such as highly sought-after chase cards, valuable secret rares or error cards.
Which Modern Cards Are Worth Considering?
While many modern Pokémon cards may not be worth grading, there are exceptions. Focus on:
- Extremely rare cards: Hyper Rares, Secret Rares, Alternate Arts, and cards with low pull rates.
- Popular Pokémon: Charizard, Pikachu, and other iconic characters.
- Cards in pristine condition: Thoroughly examine the card for any imperfections before submitting it.
- Cards that are likely to increase in value over time: Keep up to date with the secondary market and new sets that affect the value of older cards.
Making the Informed Decision: Do Your Homework
Before sending any modern Pokémon card for grading, follow these steps:
- Assess the card’s condition: Use a magnifying glass to inspect for any flaws, even minor ones.
- Research current market prices: Check reputable online marketplaces (eBay, TCGplayer, etc.) for both raw and graded versions of the card.
- Compare grading service fees: Consider the costs and turnaround times of different grading companies.
- Calculate potential profit: Determine if the expected increase in value justifies the grading expenses.
- Consider your goals: Are you grading for personal enjoyment or for resale?
Navigating the Grading Services
Choosing the Right Grading Company
PSA, BGS, and CGC are the most reputable card grading services. Each has its own grading scale, reputation, and price structure. PSA is generally considered the most popular and widely accepted grading service within the Pokemon community.
Understanding Grading Scales
- PSA: Uses a numerical scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being “Gem Mint.”
- BGS: Utilizes a similar numerical scale but also provides subgrades for centering, corners, edges, and surface. A BGS 10 Black Label is the most coveted grade.
- CGC: Employs a numerical scale but has been steadily increasing in popularity within the card collecting community.
The Impact of Grading on Value
Grading can significantly increase the value of a Pokémon card, but the extent of the increase depends on several factors:
- The card’s rarity and popularity.
- The grade received.
- The grading company’s reputation.
The Future of Card Grading
The Pokémon card market has seen tremendous growth in recent years, leading to increased demand for grading services. While this growth is exciting, it’s essential to approach grading with caution and make informed decisions. Always remember that card grading is subjective and that the market is constantly evolving. Staying informed and understanding the nuances of the hobby will help you make sound investments and avoid potential pitfalls.
The Games Learning Society is a vibrant community that explores the intersection of gaming and education. Learn more at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the best Pokémon card grading company?
There is no definitive “best” company, as it depends on individual preference and the card being graded. PSA is generally considered the most popular, while BGS is known for its stringent grading standards and subgrades. CGC is increasingly popular and seen as a valuable grading service.
2. How much does it cost to get a Pokémon card graded?
Grading fees vary depending on the company, turnaround time, and declared value of the card. Expect to pay anywhere from $15 to $500+ per card.
3. What grade do Pokémon cards need to be worth grading?
Aim for a grade of PSA 9 or higher for modern cards to see a significant return on investment. The higher the grade, the more valuable the card will be.
4. Are modern Charizard cards worth grading?
Yes, but only if they are rare, sought-after variants like Hyper Rares, Secret Rares, or Alternate Arts, and if they are in near-mint to mint condition.
5. Will newer Pokémon cards go up in value?
Some newer cards will likely increase in value over time, especially those with low print runs, high demand, or significant playability in the TCG.
6. Is it better to buy graded or ungraded Pokémon cards?
It depends on your goals and budget. Graded cards offer authenticity and condition verification, while ungraded cards may offer more value for the price.
7. Can you trust card grading companies?
Reputable grading companies like PSA, BGS, and CGC are generally trustworthy, but it’s essential to understand that grading is subjective.
8. How can you tell if a modern Pokémon card is first edition?
Modern Pokémon cards generally do not have a “First Edition” symbol. This marking was largely phased out after the initial Base Set.
9. Why are people buying so many Pokémon cards?
Factors include nostalgia, investment potential, the thrill of collecting, and the enjoyment of playing the TCG.
10. What are the best Pokémon cards to invest in?
Focus on rare and popular cards from older sets, as well as sought-after modern cards like Charizard Hyper Rares and Alternate Art cards.
11. What is the hardest Pokémon card to grade?
Cards with holographic patterns or dark borders are notoriously difficult to grade due to potential scratching and edge wear. Special Delivery Pikachu has been cited as particularly difficult to grade.
12. What happens if PSA damages your card during grading?
PSA offers compensation based on the card’s declared value, but it’s essential to ensure your card is adequately insured.
13. What makes a PSA 10 Pokémon card?
A PSA 10 card is virtually perfect, with sharp corners, edges, and focus, as well as a flawless surface.
14. What cards will PSA not grade?
PSA will not grade cards that show evidence of alteration, trimming, restoration, or questionable authenticity.
15. What is the cheapest way to get Pokémon cards graded?
CGC often has the cheapest options, while lower service tiers from all companies offer reduced pricing, though they usually have a higher declared value requirement.