GTA V: Is Killing Trevor or Michael Worth It? A Comprehensive Analysis
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the brutal world of Grand Theft Auto V, Franklin Clinton faces a morally challenging decision: eliminate either Trevor Philips or Michael De Santa. The “worth” of this choice extends beyond simple financial gain, impacting gameplay, character relationships, and the overall narrative experience. Ultimately, killing either Trevor or Michael is not worth it for the majority of players. Choosing the “Deathwish” (Ending C), where all three protagonists survive, unlocks the full potential of the game, preserves character interactions, and allows for 100% completion. Killing either character permanently removes them from the game world, severely limiting post-story content and preventing you from experiencing everything GTA V has to offer.
The Consequences of Your Choice
Choosing to kill either Trevor or Michael has significant repercussions.
Killing Trevor: The Bitter Pill
- Financial Reward: Franklin and Michael split Trevor’s share of the final heist.
- Gameplay Limitations: Trevor is permanently removed from the game, meaning you can no longer play as him, complete his unique missions, or access his properties.
- Relationship Fallout: Michael will distance himself from Franklin, limiting interactions.
- Completion Hurdles: Achieving 100% completion becomes impossible on that save file.
Killing Michael: A Loss for Everyone
- No Financial Gain: Michael’s share goes to his family, leaving Franklin empty-handed.
- Gameplay Limitations: Similar to killing Trevor, Michael is gone for good, along with his missions and properties.
- Devastating Implications: This is arguably the “bad” ending, lacking closure and feeling ultimately unsatisfying.
- Relationship Fallout: Trevor will likely cut ties with Franklin as well.
The “Deathwish” (Ending C): The Ultimate Redemption
The “Deathwish” ending sees Franklin, Michael, and Trevor uniting to take down their enemies, ensuring the survival of all three. This path offers:
- Full Character Roster: All three protagonists remain playable, allowing you to switch between them freely and enjoy their unique skills and storylines.
- Complete Gameplay Experience: Access to all missions, side activities, and character-specific content.
- Stronger Narrative Closure: A more satisfying conclusion to the story, solidifying the bond between the protagonists.
- 100% Completion: The only way to achieve 100% completion of GTA V.
Why the “Deathwish” Is the Superior Option
The “Deathwish” ending offers the best of both worlds: a thrilling final mission and the preservation of the game’s core elements. The financial reward is comparable, and the long-term benefits of keeping all three characters alive far outweigh any short-term gains. This aligns well with the educational goals of using games for learning as discussed at GamesLearningSociety.org. The experience to keep the three characters alive is educational in that the protagonists learn to deal with their issues.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the implications of each choice.
1. What exactly happens when you kill Trevor in GTA 5?
When you choose to kill Trevor, Franklin carries out the deed with Michael’s assistance. Trevor’s assets and missions become unavailable, and you gain a share of his heist money. However, you lose a significant portion of the game’s content.
2. Do you get more money by killing Trevor or choosing the “Deathwish”?
While killing Trevor provides an immediate financial reward, the long-term benefits and enjoyment derived from keeping all three characters alive in the “Deathwish” ending far outweigh any monetary difference.
3. Can you still hang out with Michael if you kill Trevor?
No, Michael will distance himself from Franklin after Trevor’s death, limiting your ability to interact with him.
4. Is killing Trevor the best option, according to Reddit users?
Opinions vary, but a significant portion of Reddit users argue that killing Trevor (or Michael) is the most realistic, but not necessarily the best, option. Many recognize the gameplay advantages of the “Deathwish” ending.
5. Can you go to Michael’s house as Trevor?
Normally, yes. However, if you’ve chosen an ending where Michael is dead, you will obviously not be able to enter his house as Trevor.
6. What is the best ending in GTA 5?
The “Deathwish” ending (Ending C) is widely considered the best ending in GTA 5. It allows all three protagonists to survive and offers the most complete and satisfying gameplay experience.
7. What are the perks of killing Trevor?
There are no significant perks to killing Trevor. The only real “benefit” is a slightly shorter final mission. The drawbacks far outweigh this minor advantage.
8. What to do after Trevor dies?
After Trevor dies, you can continue playing as Michael and Franklin, completing side missions and exploring the world. However, you will be unable to access any content associated with Trevor. You also cannot achieve 100% completion.
9. How do I get Trevor back after killing him?
Unfortunately, once Trevor is killed, he’s gone for good on that save file. The only way to play as Trevor again is to start a new game.
10. What is the best option for Trevor’s heist prep?
The “Freighter” option is generally considered the best for Trevor’s heist prep due to requiring only one side mission (“Minisub”) compared to the “Offshore” option’s two.
11. Does Michael treat Franklin like a son?
Michael develops a close, almost father-son-like relationship with Franklin throughout the game.
12. Can you get 100% completion if you kill Trevor?
No, you cannot achieve 100% completion on a save file where Trevor has been killed.
13. Which of the three protagonists has the most kills?
Franklin Clinton has the highest kill count, followed by Trevor Philips and then Michael De Santa.
14. Is Trevor the most powerful character in GTA?
Trevor is definitely powerful and unhinged.
15. Does Trevor have any secret missions?
Yes, Trevor has access to several unique missions, including the infamous cannibalistic cult mission triggered after completing “Nervous Ron.”
Conclusion: Choose Wisely
In conclusion, while the temptation of a quick payout might make killing Trevor or Michael seem appealing, the long-term consequences are detrimental to your overall GTA V experience. The “Deathwish” ending offers the most fulfilling narrative, complete gameplay, and the satisfaction of keeping all three protagonists alive. Choose wisely and unlock the full potential of Grand Theft Auto V.