Is it Worth Selling Fish to C.J. in Animal Crossing: New Horizons?

Yes, absolutely! Selling fish to C.J. in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is almost always a more lucrative option than selling them at Nook’s Cranny. C.J., the cool beaver who visits your island randomly, will purchase your fish for 150% of their usual selling price. This significant increase makes him a prime source for earning extra bells, especially if you’ve been diligently fishing. While the game offers multiple ways to use your catches, if your primary goal is maximizing your financial gain, C.J. is your go-to guy. This article will delve into the specifics of why selling to C.J. is a smart move, highlight valuable fish to target, and answer some of the most frequently asked questions surrounding this topic.

Why Selling to C.J. is a Smart Move

The 150% Profit Boost

The most significant reason to sell your fish to C.J. is his generous offer. He buys any fish you catch for 1.5 times the price you’d get at Nook’s Cranny. For example, an Oarfish normally sells for 9,000 bells. Sell it to C.J., and you’ll earn 13,500 bells instead. This additional profit can quickly add up, particularly if you’ve hoarded valuable fish.

Random Island Visits

C.J.’s random visits can feel unpredictable, but they provide a great opportunity for a surge in income. Remember, C.J. will leave at 5 am the following day, so it’s essential to seize the opportunity while he’s around. This means making the most of his presence, especially if you’ve been saving your fish.

No Prep Work Required

Unlike cooking fish for resale, which requires recipes and resources, selling to C.J. is straightforward. You don’t need to invest time in crafting or preparing the fish, and you can sell them immediately. This simplicity makes him a convenient and efficient way to cash in on your fishing efforts.

Valuable Fish to Target for C.J.

While any fish sold to C.J. fetches a better price, some species are significantly more profitable than others. Here are a few high-value targets:

• Coelacanth: This fish, which appears in the ocean when it rains, sells for 15,000 bells normally, and 22,500 bells with C.J.
• Oarfish: As mentioned, these rare and large ocean fish sell for 9,000 bells at Nook’s, but 13,500 bells to C.J.
• Golden Trout: This river fish sells for 15,000 bells at Nook’s and a whopping 22,500 bells to C.J.
• Stringfish: Another very valuable river fish, it offers a great profit if sold to C.J.

C.J. vs. Other Selling Options

While Timmy and Tommy Nook offer a base price for your fish, selling to them is generally less lucrative when C.J. is an option. You can also cook fish, but this requires extra resources and the payoff is not as high as selling raw fish to C.J. Therefore, if your goal is to maximize profits, waiting for C.J. to appear on your island will often be the best strategy.

A Note on Donations to Blathers

Remember that while selling to C.J. is profitable, it’s important to donate the first of any new fish to Blathers at the Museum. Completing the Museum collection is an integral part of the Animal Crossing experience, so prioritize this before thinking about your profit.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Selling Fish to C.J.

Here are 15 commonly asked questions to give you even more insights into selling your fish to C.J.:

1. Does C.J. pay more for fish than Nook?

Yes, C.J. buys fish for 50% more than the usual price at Nook’s Cranny, which translates to 150% of their original value.

2. Does C.J. buy sea creatures?

No, C.J. only purchases fish. Sea creatures, such as sea stars and scallops, are not accepted by him.

3. What is the most valuable fish to sell to C.J.?

When you factor in C.J.’s markup, the Coelacanth and Golden Trout are among the most valuable fish to sell. These both sell for 22,500 bells each when sold to him.

4. Is it worth it to hold onto fish for C.J.?

Absolutely! If your primary goal is earning bells, saving fish to sell to C.J. when he visits is the most profitable strategy.

5. Does Isabelle announce when C.J. is visiting?

No, Isabelle doesn’t typically announce C.J.’s arrival. You will have to explore your island to find him.

6. How long does C.J. stay on your island?

C.J. stays on your island until 5 am the following day. Make sure you take advantage of his visit while he’s there.

7. Can C.J. create fish models?

Yes, if you give C.J. three of the same fish, he will send a fish model of that kind in the mail the next day.

8. Should I sell fish or give them to Blathers first?

You should always donate your first catch of any fish to Blathers to complete your museum collection. After that, feel free to sell subsequent catches.

9. What other fish should I focus on catching for good profits?

Besides the Coelacanth, Golden Trout, and Oarfish, target other high-value catches such as the Koi, Saddled Bichir, and Ocean Sunfish.

10. Is it better to sell fish or cook them in Animal Crossing?

Generally, selling raw fish to C.J. is more profitable than cooking and selling the resulting dishes. Cooking is primarily for filling out your recipe collection or for furniture, not for maximizing income.

11. Are C.J. and Flick dating?

While they are close friends, C.J. and Flick are not dating in the game. Nintendo has confirmed they are not romantically involved, but they do frequently appear in-game to sell their unique wares, making them very valuable characters to get to know.

12. How do I increase the chances of C.J. visiting?

There’s no way to manipulate the visits of C.J. or other special characters in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. Just keep playing and checking your island daily.

13. What should I do with extra fish if I am not selling to C.J.?

If C.J. is not visiting, or you have already gotten the models you want, you could sell them at Nook’s Cranny or gift them to villagers to raise your friendship level.

14. Is it always worth it to sell fish to C.J.?

If your goal is to make bells, it’s almost always worthwhile to sell your fish to C.J. due to the significant increase in value, especially for high value fish.

15. What are the benefits of selling to C.J. other than bells?

Besides bells, selling to C.J. can help you reduce your inventory of fish and unlock custom fish models. You can use the bells you have to buy more valuable items from the Nook’s Cranny.

Conclusion

Selling your fish to C.J. is a highly effective way to earn bells in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. His 150% markup, coupled with the potential to obtain custom models, makes him an invaluable character to interact with. While you should always prioritize donating to Blathers to complete your museum, when it comes to maximizing profit, C.J. is your go-to guy. Keep an eye out for his random visits, and be prepared with a well-stocked inventory of fish for a rewarding payday. Happy fishing!