Is Joining the Dark Brotherhood Evil? A Deep Dive into Skyrim’s Moral Quagmire
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether joining the Dark Brotherhood in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is evil is a complex one, devoid of a simple yes or no answer. Objectively, the Dark Brotherhood is an organization built on assassination for profit, and its members willingly engage in cold-blooded murder. Therefore, joining the Dark Brotherhood inherently involves embracing evil actions. However, morality in Skyrim, like in life, is rarely black and white. Player motivations, the specific contracts undertaken, and the overall narrative context all contribute to the moral weight of aligning with this shadowy guild. Ultimately, it’s up to each player to decide if the benefits and narrative opportunities outweigh the inherent ethical cost.
The Darkness Within: A Closer Look
The Dark Brotherhood operates under a strict code, albeit one steeped in darkness and devotion to Sithis, the Void. They are not mere mercenaries; they are fanatics who believe in the sacredness of their assassinations. This belief system, coupled with their ruthless efficiency, makes them a dangerous and morally questionable force.
-
The Initiation Ritual: The quest to join the Dark Brotherhood immediately throws the player into a moral dilemma. The assassination of Grelod the Kind, though arguably deserving of her fate due to her cruelty, sets the tone for the dark path ahead. This act is a deliberate test of the player’s willingness to cross a moral line.
-
Contracts of Convenience: While some contracts may target genuinely reprehensible individuals, others are morally ambiguous, or even target seemingly innocent people. The Brotherhood accepts any contract that fulfills the Black Sacrament, regardless of the target’s character. This willingness to kill anyone for the right price solidifies their position as an evil organization.
-
Embracing the Void: The Dark Brotherhood’s devotion to Sithis is another indicator of their inherent evil. Sithis represents chaos and destruction, principles that are fundamentally opposed to order and morality. Worshipping such a deity implies an acceptance of violence and a rejection of conventional ethics.
Shades of Gray: Context and Player Agency
Despite the overwhelming evidence pointing towards the Dark Brotherhood’s inherent evil, there are mitigating factors to consider:
-
The Justification of Targets: Sometimes, the targets assigned by the Dark Brotherhood are undeniably deserving of their fate. Corrupt officials, abusive spouses, and tyrannical leaders are all potential victims. In these cases, the player might rationalize their actions as a form of vigilante justice.
-
The Quest for Power: Some players may choose to join the Dark Brotherhood purely for the unique rewards, such as Shadowmere, the Blade of Woe, or the Summon Spectral Assassin ability. The pursuit of power and unique items can sometimes outweigh moral considerations in a game setting.
-
Roleplaying a Morally Gray Character: The beauty of Skyrim lies in its freedom of choice. Players can create characters with complex motivations and moral codes. A Dragonborn struggling with inner demons or driven by revenge might find a natural home within the Dark Brotherhood. This allows for compelling storytelling that explores the nuances of morality.
-
Destroying the Dark Brotherhood: The game provides an alternative path: destroying the Dark Brotherhood. This option allows players to actively combat evil and uphold a more righteous moral code within the game world. Choosing this path demonstrates a clear rejection of the Brotherhood’s values.
Conclusion: A Matter of Perspective
Ultimately, whether joining the Dark Brotherhood is considered evil depends on the player’s individual moral compass and their interpretation of the game’s narrative. While the organization is undeniably built on morally reprehensible actions, the player’s motivations, the specific contracts they undertake, and their overall roleplaying choices can all influence the moral weight of their decision. The Dark Brotherhood serves as a compelling exploration of the complexities of morality in a world where choices have real consequences. It offers a unique opportunity for players to confront their own values and decide what they are willing to sacrifice in the pursuit of power, justice, or revenge.
Consider this: Games have a powerful way of teaching us and helping us explore difficult topics. The Games Learning Society researches these intersections and offers new insights into how games change lives.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions related to joining the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim, providing further context and information:
1. What are the initial requirements for joining the Dark Brotherhood?
The initial requirement is to complete the quest “Innocence Lost” in Windhelm, which involves killing Grelod the Kind at the Honorhall Orphanage in Riften. Afterward, sleep in any bed, and you will be abducted and presented with a choice.
2. Is it possible to avoid killing Grelod the Kind and still join the Dark Brotherhood?
No, killing Grelod the Kind is a mandatory step to initiate the questline that leads to joining the Dark Brotherhood.
3. Can I destroy the Dark Brotherhood instead of joining them?
Yes. After being abducted by Astrid, you can choose to attack and kill her. This will initiate the quest “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!”
4. What are the main benefits of joining the Dark Brotherhood?
The main benefits include access to unique quests, rewards like Shadowmere and the Blade of Woe, the Summon Spectral Assassin ability, and interactions with memorable characters like Cicero.
5. What are the consequences of destroying the Dark Brotherhood?
Destroying the Dark Brotherhood prevents you from obtaining the unique rewards mentioned above, including Shadowmere, the Blade of Woe, and the Summon Spectral Assassin power. You also miss out on the unique storyline and character interactions.
6. Does joining the Dark Brotherhood affect my relationships with other factions?
Joining the Dark Brotherhood doesn’t directly affect your relationships with most other factions. However, your actions within the Brotherhood may conflict with the values of certain factions, like the Companions or the Vigilants of Stendarr.
7. Can I marry anyone in the Dark Brotherhood?
You cannot directly marry any member of the Dark Brotherhood unless they are already eligible for marriage. Certain quests may unlock marriage options with NPCs related to Dark Brotherhood contracts, such as Muiri in Markarth.
8. Does Astrid betray the Dragonborn?
Yes, Astrid ultimately betrays the Dragonborn in a bid to maintain control over the Dark Brotherhood. This occurs later in the Dark Brotherhood questline.
9. Why does Astrid betray the Dragonborn?
Astrid betrays the Dragonborn because she fears losing her position as the leader of the Dark Brotherhood. She believes the Dragonborn’s rising influence as the Listener threatens her authority.
10. What happens if a Dark Brotherhood initiate dies?
The Dark Brotherhood Initiates are essential characters and cannot die. They are valuable followers for stealthy characters due to their abilities and immortality.
11. Can the Dark Brotherhood be saved?
If you choose to destroy the Dark Brotherhood, you prevent its evil from spreading but sacrifice all the unique rewards. The Dark Brotherhood is a cult-like organization dedicated to murder, and there isn’t a way to make the organization good or neutral.
12. Is the Night Mother evil?
The Night Mother is a central figure in the Dark Brotherhood’s mythology. She is revered as the embodiment of death and the patron of assassins, making her a morally questionable figure.
13. Can you get unlimited radiant quests from the Dark Brotherhood?
Yes, after completing the main Dark Brotherhood questline, you can receive unlimited radiant quests from the Night Mother. These quests involve assassinating randomly generated targets.
14. Does the Dark Brotherhood ever go away?
No, the Dark Brotherhood will never disappear from the game if you complete the questline. Even after the main questline, you can continue to receive radiant assassination contracts indefinitely.
15. Are there any moral consequences for completing Dark Brotherhood contracts?
The game doesn’t directly impose in-game penalties for completing Dark Brotherhood contracts. However, your actions may conflict with your personal moral compass and impact your roleplaying experience. The moral consequences are left to the player to consider.
Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more about the intersection of games and education: Games Learning Society.