Table of Contents

Mending vs. Infinity: The Ultimate Minecraft Bow Enchantment Showdown

Quick answer

This page answers Is mending better than infinity? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

So, you’re standing at your enchanting table, bow in hand, and the big question looms: Is mending better than infinity? The short, definitive answer is: it depends on your play style and resource availability. Mending is generally considered the superior enchantment in the long run, offering near-indestructibility for your bow. However, Infinity provides unparalleled convenience, especially early in the game. Let’s dive deep into the nuances of each enchantment, weighing their pros and cons to help you make the best choice for your Minecraft adventures.

The Case for Mending: Eternal Bow Bliss

Mending, with its singular Level I, is a game-changer. It harnesses the power of experience orbs (XP) to repair your equipment. Whenever you gain XP while holding or wearing an item enchanted with Mending, that XP is diverted to repairing the item’s durability. The rate is two durability points restored per point of experience.

Pros of Mending:

Near-infinite durability: With a steady supply of XP, your bow becomes virtually indestructible. No more crafting new bows or grinding for resources.
Synergy with XP farms: If you have a reliable XP farm (skeleton farm, enderman farm, etc.), Mending is an absolute must-have. Every kill repairs your bow, making it a self-sustaining weapon.
Versatility: Mending isn’t just for bows. You can apply it to armor, tools, and even your elytra, extending the lifespan of all your precious gear.
Repair Costs Be Damned: Mending bypasses the annoying mechanics of increasing repair costs in anvils. You can forget about ‘too expensive’ problems.

Cons of Mending:

Reliance on XP: If you’re not actively generating XP, Mending is useless. Your bow will slowly degrade with use, and you’ll need to find a source of XP to repair it.
Arrow Consumption: Unlike Infinity, you still need to craft and carry arrows. While not a major burden, it’s something to consider.
Initial Setup: Requires access to villagers or fishing to obtain the enchantment in the first place, this can be time consuming and dependent on luck

The Case for Infinity: Arrow Abundance

Infinity, also capped at Level I, grants you the ability to shoot an unlimited number of arrows from your bow, as long as you have at least one arrow in your inventory. This enchantment is a boon for players who dislike grinding for resources or those who are just starting out.

Pros of Infinity:

Unlimited Arrows: The most obvious advantage is never having to craft arrows again. This saves you a ton of time and resources, especially early in the game.
Convenience: No need to worry about carrying stacks of arrows in your inventory. One arrow is all you need.
Early Game Power: Infinity can be a lifesaver in the early game when resources are scarce and you’re trying to survive the night.

Cons of Infinity:

Bow Durability: Your bow still takes damage with each shot, and eventually, it will break.
Limited Repairability: Infinity bows can only be repaired a limited number of times on the anvil before becoming too expensive to repair, forcing you to make a new bow.
Incompatible with Special Arrows: Infinity only works with regular arrows. If you want to use tipped arrows or spectral arrows, you’ll need to carry them separately.
No Mending: The biggest drawback is that Infinity and Mending are mutually exclusive. You can’t have both on the same bow.

When to Choose Mending Over Infinity (and Vice Versa)

The decision between Mending and Infinity boils down to these factors:

Resource Availability: If you have a reliable source of XP, Mending is the clear winner. If arrows are difficult to obtain, Infinity is a better choice.
Play Style: If you prefer a hands-off approach and dislike resource gathering, Infinity is more convenient. If you’re willing to invest time in setting up XP farms and managing your resources, Mending is more rewarding in the long run.
Game Stage: Early in the game, Infinity can be invaluable. As you progress and gain access to better resources and XP farms, Mending becomes the superior option.

Alternatives and Synergies

While you can’t have both Mending and Infinity on the same bow, you can mitigate the drawbacks of each enchantment by combining them with other enchantments and strategies. For example:

Unbreaking III: This enchantment significantly increases the durability of your bow, regardless of whether you choose Mending or Infinity.
Power V: This enchantment increases the damage dealt by your arrows, making you more efficient in combat.
Quick Charge III (Crossbow): Crossbows cannot have Mending or Infinity, but quick charge combined with the above buffs can make an effective damage dealing weapon.
Skeleton Farm: A well-designed skeleton farm provides a steady supply of both arrows and XP, making Mending an even more attractive option.
Librarian Villagers: Librarian villagers are a great source of Mending books. Keep an eye out for one that offers Mending as a first-tier trade.

The Final Verdict

In conclusion, while Infinity offers unparalleled convenience and arrow conservation, Mending is the more powerful enchantment in the long term. With a steady supply of XP, a Mending bow will last indefinitely, saving you countless hours of resource gathering and bow crafting. However, Infinity remains a viable option, especially for early-game players or those who prioritize convenience over long-term durability. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can Mending and Infinity go together?

No, Mending and Infinity are mutually exclusive. Mojang, the developers of Minecraft, made these two enchantments incompatible because combining infinite arrows with a self-repairing bow was deemed overpowered. You can only have one or the other on your bow.

2. Is Mending the best enchantment?

For most players, Mending is considered one of the best enchantments in Minecraft, if not the best. Its ability to repair your equipment using XP makes it incredibly valuable, especially when combined with a reliable XP farm. However, its usefulness depends on your access to XP.

3. What’s better, Infinity or Power?

This is a different question. Power V is always recommended! It increases the damage output of your bow by a massive 75% when fully drawn.

4. Can you put Mending on armor?

Yes, you can put Mending on armor. In fact, Mending is highly recommended for armor, as it greatly extends the lifespan of your expensive diamond or Netherite gear.

5. What’s the maximum level for Mending?

The maximum level for the Mending enchantment is Level 1 (Mending I). There are no higher levels of Mending.

6. Can you put Infinity on a crossbow?

No, you cannot put Infinity on a crossbow. Infinity is exclusive to bows. Crossbows have their own set of enchantments, such as Multishot, Quick Charge, and Piercing.

7. How many times can you repair an Infinity bow?

You can only repair your Infinity bow a limited number of times before the repair cost becomes too expensive. This number of times is usually only 2 times, depending on the other enchantments your bow has.

8. How rare is Mending 1?

The rarity of obtaining Mending depends on the method you’re using. When trading with villagers, there is around a 1 in 106 chance for a librarian villager to offer Mending as a trade. Fishing and dungeon loot tables also offer mending, with varying rarities.

9. Does Unbreaking and Mending last forever?

With both Unbreaking III and Mending, your equipment will essentially last forever as long as you continue to generate XP. Unbreaking increases the durability of the item, while Mending repairs it using XP.

10. Does Mending give more XP?

Mending does not give you more XP. It diverts XP that you would normally gain to repairing your equipment. Half of the XP that is earnt will repair the item, while the other half will go to the gamer’s level.

11. Does Mending work on axes?

Yes, Mending works on axes. It’s highly recommended to put Mending on your axe, as it allows you to repair it while mining and chopping down trees.

12. What happens if you put Infinity on a bow?

If you put Infinity on a bow, you will be able to shoot an unlimited number of arrows as long as you have at least one arrow in your inventory. The bow will still take durability damage with each shot, but you won’t consume any arrows.

13. Can you use Infinity on tipped arrows?

No, Infinity only works with regular arrows. If you want to use tipped arrows or spectral arrows, you’ll need to carry them separately, and they will be consumed when shot.

14. Does Mending work on tridents?

Yes, Mending works on tridents. It’s a great enchantment to have on your trident, especially if you use it frequently for combat or travel.

15. Where can I learn more about educational games and their impact?

You can explore the innovative work of the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. They are at the forefront of understanding how games can be used to enhance learning and engagement.

We hope this guide has helped you understand the nuances of Mending and Infinity and make the best choice for your Minecraft adventures!