New Super Mario Bros. DS vs. Wii: Which Platform Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old debate: Is New Super Mario Bros. DS better than New Super Mario Bros. Wii? The short answer is, it depends on what you’re looking for in a Mario platformer. Neither game is definitively “better,” but rather, they offer distinct experiences that cater to different preferences. The DS version boasts a tighter, more traditional single-player experience, while the Wii version shines with its chaotic multiplayer and motion control elements. Let’s dive into the nuances to help you decide which game might be a better fit for you.
A Tale of Two Platforms
New Super Mario Bros. DS: The Portable Powerhouse
New Super Mario Bros. DS, released in 2006, brought classic 2D Mario gameplay to the Nintendo DS. It features tight controls, a satisfying level of challenge, and impressive graphics for the handheld console. The core gameplay revolves around traditional platforming, with Mario navigating meticulously designed levels, stomping on Goombas, collecting Star Coins, and making use of iconic power-ups like the Super Mushroom, Fire Flower, and the brand new Mega Mushroom.
New Super Mario Bros. Wii: Multiplayer Mayhem
New Super Mario Bros. Wii, which launched in 2009, took the core gameplay of the DS title and added a unique twist: four-player simultaneous co-op. This feature allows up to four players to traverse the levels together, leading to both hilarious chaos and shared triumphs. The addition of motion controls also differentiated it from its handheld counterpart, with players shaking the Wii Remote to activate the propeller suit and other power-ups. While both games share visual similarities and some level themes, the multiplayer focus and motion controls of the Wii version dramatically alter the gameplay experience.
Gameplay and Difficulty
DS: A Focus on Single-Player Skill
The DS version provides a polished single-player experience. The level design is generally tighter and more focused on precise platforming challenges. The game has a relatively short length, which some might find a drawback, but it allows for a more concentrated gameplay experience. While it’s not overly punishing, New Super Mario Bros. DS offers a solid challenge, especially if you aim for 100% completion, which includes finding all 240 Star Coins and secret passages. The new power-ups, like the Mega Mushroom and Mini Mushroom, are more of a novelty than true game changers, as some players might feel they add little strategic depth to the core gameplay.
Wii: Chaotic Co-op and Dynamic Gameplay
The Wii version, by contrast, shifts the focus to co-operative multiplayer. This changes the entire dynamic. Levels that might be straightforward in single-player become hilarious challenges with multiple players bouncing off of each other, creating chaos and cooperation. The addition of motion controls to power-ups adds a tactile element, and levels are designed to encourage teamwork. While some might consider the game easier due to the ability to revive one another, the sheer amount of things happening on the screen simultaneously and the multiplayer interactions can ramp up the difficulty considerably. The level of strategy involved in coordinating jumps or item usage in a multiplayer setting also adds a unique layer of gameplay not present in the DS version. The Wii version definitely provides a different flavour of challenge compared to the DS.
Graphics and Presentation
Both games offer impressive visuals for their respective platforms. The DS version features arguably some of the best graphics on the system, with smooth animation, bright colors, and detailed environments. The Wii version boasts improved textures and resolution, taking advantage of the console’s processing power. However, both games share the same fundamental art style, with the main difference being the resolution and level of detail achievable on each system.
The Verdict: Which is Better for You?
Ultimately, the question of which is better depends on your preferences. If you value a tight, traditional single-player experience, with more refined level design, New Super Mario Bros. DS is the way to go. However, if you prefer the wild, unpredictable chaos of multiplayer and don’t mind the occasional frustration of motion controls, then New Super Mario Bros. Wii will be more appealing. Neither game is a disappointment, they are just different. If you can have both, having the distinct experiences of the DS game and Wii game is strongly recommended.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What are the major differences in gameplay between the DS and Wii versions?
The primary difference is the multiplayer focus of New Super Mario Bros. Wii, which allows up to four players to play simultaneously. The DS version is purely a single-player experience. The Wii version also incorporates motion controls, particularly for power-ups.
2. Is the Wii version harder than the DS version?
Many players find the Wii version to be easier due to its co-operative nature. However, the multiplayer chaos and screen clutter can make it more challenging. The DS version is considered to have more precise and challenging single-player platforming, particularly if aiming for 100% completion.
3. Which game has more content?
Both games have a similar number of levels, but the Wii version might offer slightly more replayability due to the multiplayer aspect. Both games require you to beat all 80 levels to “complete” the main story.
4. Does the Wii version support online multiplayer?
Unfortunately, New Super Mario Bros. Wii does not support online multiplayer. It is a local co-op experience only.
5. Are there new power-ups in the Wii version?
While both games share many power-ups, the Wii version also introduces the Penguin Suit, which allows Mario to slide on his belly and move easily on ice.
6. How do motion controls work in the Wii version?
Motion controls are used to activate the Propeller Suit, which allows Mario to do a boost into the air, and various other actions. The Wii remote must be shaken to activate these.
7. Which version is easier to 100% complete?
The DS version is generally considered easier to 100% complete, primarily because its challenges are more straightforward. In the DS version, this involves beating all 80 levels, finding all 17 secret passages and collecting all 240 Star Coins. The multiplayer element in the Wii version makes achieving 100% harder to track.
8. Are there any significant graphical differences?
While both games share the same art style, the Wii version has higher resolution and more detailed textures. The DS version, however, is impressive for the handheld hardware of the time.
9. Which game is more suitable for solo players?
New Super Mario Bros. DS is the better choice for solo players, as it is designed entirely as a single-player experience. The Wii version is designed around co-op.
10. Can you ride Yoshi in either version?
Yes, Yoshi appears as a rideable character in the Wii version, as well as in its direct sequel, New Super Mario Bros. U. The DS version does not include Yoshi.
11. Which game is considered to have a better soundtrack?
Both games share many of the same musical themes, but opinions vary on which soundtrack is better. Neither soundtrack is considered to be a significant improvement over the other.
12. Does the DS version use the touch screen for any gameplay purposes?
The touch screen is primarily used for menu navigation and a map display. The core gameplay is not directly affected by touch controls.
13. Are there any significant hidden secrets in the DS version?
Yes, the DS version contains 17 secret passages and 240 Star Coins spread through all levels, which are needed to achieve 100% completion.
14. Is it possible to play the Wii version solo?
Yes, it is possible to play the Wii version solo, but the gameplay is more fun and dynamic with multiple players. Some level design elements are harder or simply not possible to complete solo.
15. Which game is better for casual players?
Both games are suitable for casual players, however, the Wii version might be slightly more approachable due to its slightly easier level designs and ability to revive other players in the event of a death. The more focused single-player experience of the DS version might be more challenging for casual players seeking the path of least resistance.
Ultimately, the choice between New Super Mario Bros. DS and New Super Mario Bros. Wii depends entirely on what you seek in a Mario platformer. Both are excellent games, and both deserve a place in any Mario fan’s collection.