Poisonous vs. Infect: Decoding the Venomous World of Magic: The Gathering
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
No, poisonous and infect are not the same, although both relate to giving an opponent poison counters in Magic: The Gathering (MTG). While they share the outcome of delivering poison counters, the mechanisms, timing, and interactions differ significantly, making them distinct abilities with different strategic implications.
Understanding Poisonous
Poisonous is an older ability that triggers upon a creature dealing combat damage to a player. Specifically, when a creature with poisonous N deals any amount of combat damage to an opponent, that opponent receives N poison counters, irrespective of the amount of damage actually dealt. For instance, a 1/1 creature with poisonous 2 that deals 1 combat damage to a player will still give that player two poison counters. The key is combat damage and the pre-determined number associated with the poisonous ability. This ability is less common in modern MTG sets but has appeared sporadically.
Key Characteristics of Poisonous:
- Combat Damage Trigger: It only functions when the creature deals combat damage to a player.
- Fixed Counter Amount: The number of poison counters given is predetermined by the “N” in poisonous N, not the amount of damage.
- Legacy Mechanic: It’s a relatively rare ability found mostly in older sets.
Delving into Infect
Infect, in contrast, is a more complex and strategically versatile ability. Rather than dealing damage as life loss to players, a creature with infect deals damage in the form of poison counters. To creatures, it deals damage in the form of -1/-1 counters. A 5/5 creature with infect dealing combat damage to a player gives that player 5 poison counters. It changes how damage is dealt, not simply adding an effect on top of it. Infect also alters how damage is dealt to creatures, which poisonous does not.
Key Characteristics of Infect:
- Damage Conversion: Transforms damage into poison counters for players and -1/-1 counters for creatures.
- Combat and Non-Combat: Infect applies to both combat and non-combat damage sources. If a spell deals damage from a source that has infect, it deals damage in the form of poison counters to players and -1/-1 counters to creatures.
- Modern Mechanic: More prevalent in newer MTG sets compared to poisonous.
Poisonous Vs. Infect Vs. Toxic
While all three abilities revolve around poison counters, they function differently. Poisonous triggers on combat damage with a fixed number of counters, infect converts all damage into poison counters (or -1/-1 counters), and toxic delivers a bonus of poison counters in addition to normal combat damage. Each ability has a unique strategic role in MTG.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Poison and MTG
1. Is Toxic 1 a Counter?
No, toxic 1 is not a counter itself. It’s an ability. Toxic 1 means that whenever a creature with the ability deals combat damage to a player, that player also gets one poison counter in addition to any life they lose from the combat damage.
2. What happens if you give a toxic creature infect?
This is where things get interesting! Toxic works when the creature deals combat damage to a player. It doesn’t care that it was “regular” (life-reducing) damage or infect damage. It still works with infect. So, if a 5/5 with Infect and Toxic 2 deals combat damage to an opponent, the opponent gets 5 poison counters from the infect, plus 2 additional poison counters from the toxic ability, totaling 7 poison counters.
3. Can a creature have Toxic 1 twice?
Yes, a creature can effectively have multiple instances of Toxic. Each instance of Toxic will add its respective number of poison counters. For instance, if a creature has Toxic 2 and gains Toxic 1 from another source, it will give a total of 3 poison counters upon dealing combat damage to a player.
4. How many poison counters does infect give?
There isn’t a concept of “infect counters.” Infect is an ability. It dictates how damage is dealt. So, a creature with infect deals damage to players in the form of poison counters, equal to the amount of damage it deals. It also affects how damage is dealt to creatures, by using -1/-1 counters. If a 2/2 creature with infect deals damage to another creature, that creature gets two -1/-1 counters.
5. Does infect cause loss of life?
No, infect doesn’t cause loss of life. When a creature with infect deals damage to a player, the player receives poison counters equal to the damage that would have been dealt, but the player’s life total remains unchanged.
6. Does Saskia work with infect?
Yes, Saskia the Unyielding can work effectively with infect strategies. Her ability allows you to choose an opponent and have all combat damage be dealt to that player, regardless of who’s attacking. This means you can essentially double the infect damage dealt to that chosen player, hastening their demise by poison.
7. Is infect better than toxic?
Neither infect nor toxic is inherently “better.” It depends on the overall strategy and the specific game situation. Infect provides a dedicated route to victory via poison counters alone, while toxic offers a more versatile approach by combining regular damage with a supplementary dose of poison.
8. Does Deathtouch cancel Deathtouch?
No, two instances of Deathtouch do not cancel each other out. If a creature with Deathtouch is dealt any amount of damage from a source with Deathtouch, it is still destroyed. There is no cancellation effect.
9. Can you get rid of infect counters?
Generally, poison counters (the result of infect damage) are difficult to remove in MTG. There are very few cards that allow a player to remove poison counters, making it a persistent threat. Leeches, from Homelands, is one such card.
10. Does toxic count as combat damage?
Yes, toxic involves dealing combat damage as usual. A creature with Toxic deals damage to other creatures and planeswalkers normally. If a toxic creature hits a player, they take normal damage and get additional poison counters as dictated by the toxic ability.
11. Which food is slow poison?
Certain foods can contain substances that are toxic in high doses, acting as a “slow poison.” Examples include elderberries, some varieties of mushrooms, and improperly prepared lima beans. Always be cautious about food preparation and potential toxins.
12. How do you neutralize poison?
Attempting to neutralize a poison yourself can be dangerous. Never try to neutralize a poison with substances like lemon juice or vinegar unless directed to do so by a medical professional or a poison control center. Contact professionals and follow their instructions.
13. What are the three types of poisonous?
In the context of poison, it can broadly be categorized into: agricultural and industrial chemicals, drugs and health care products, and biological poisons (derived from plants and animals).
14. Does poison affect animals?
Yes, animals can be affected by poison just like humans. They can be poisoned through ingestion, inhalation, or contact with a toxic substance. If you suspect your pet has been poisoned, contact a veterinarian immediately.
15. How do you counter infect?
Countering an infect strategy requires careful planning and the right cards. Removal spells can disrupt the infect player’s creature base. Another strategy is to overwhelm an infect opponent with removal spells. Many cards in MTG break the rules of Magic and can provide advantages such as deferring the cost of your spell to the next turn.
Conclusion: Mastering the Art of Venom
Understanding the nuances between poisonous and infect, and other relevant poison abilities like toxic, is crucial for any MTG player looking to master this powerful and often feared strategy. These abilities offer unique pathways to victory and add depth to the complex strategic landscape of Magic: The Gathering. Understanding how these mechanics play out adds to the excitement of the game. For more information on card strategies and MTG mechanics, visit the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.