Is Pokémon Scarlet & Violet Really That Bad? A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, is Pokémon Scarlet & Violet (SV) really that bad? The short answer is: it’s complicated. No, they aren’t objectively terrible games. However, they are significantly flawed and represent a stumble for a franchise that typically sets a high bar. They’re a mixed bag of brilliant ideas hampered by technical issues and design choices that left many players disappointed. They are not the worst Pokémon games ever, but they’re also far from the best, creating a unique and often frustrating experience.
A Tale of Two Versions (and Many Glitches)
Let’s be clear: Scarlet & Violet are ambitious. Game Freak attempted to deliver a truly open-world Pokémon experience, a goal many fans have dreamt of for years. Paldea, the Iberian Peninsula-inspired region, is vast and sprawling, filled with Pokémon to discover. The concept of three interwoven storylines – the classic Gym Challenge (Victory Road), battling gigantic Titan Pokémon (Path of Legends), and taking down the rebellious Team Star (Starfall Street) – is innovative.
The version differences, while largely cosmetic (uniform colors, a handful of exclusive Pokémon), do add a bit of flavor. Scarlet embodies the past, with ancient Paradox Pokémon, while Violet embraces the future, showcasing futuristic Paradox forms. I personally gravitated towards Scarlet for its unique and imposing Paradox Pokémon. However, this choice doesn’t drastically alter the gameplay experience.
The core issue, and the one that repeatedly surfaces in player reviews, is performance. The games are riddled with frame rate drops, graphical glitches, and outright crashes. Pop-in is rampant, and character models often move with a jerky, unnatural motion. These problems are not merely cosmetic; they actively detract from the enjoyment of exploring Paldea. Some argue that the Nintendo Switch’s hardware is simply not powerful enough to handle the game’s ambition. Others insist that poor optimization is to blame. Regardless of the root cause, the impact on the player experience is undeniable.
Beyond the performance issues, some design choices feel questionable. The open-world structure, while conceptually appealing, lacks clear direction at times. The absence of level scaling can lead to frustration, as players stumble upon areas with significantly higher-level Pokémon. The lack of compelling narrative until the very end leaves the mid-game feeling somewhat aimless.
However, it’s not all doom and gloom. Scarlet & Violet introduce 110 new Pokémon, many of which are creative and well-designed. The Terastal Phenomenon, which allows Pokémon to transform into crystalline forms with altered typings, adds a new layer of strategic depth to battles. The online co-op features, while also buggy, offer a unique way to experience the game with friends. And the endgame story is genuinely compelling, offering a narrative that resonates with many players.
Ultimately, Scarlet & Violet are a flawed but fascinating experiment. They represent a bold step forward for the Pokémon franchise, but a step that was not executed flawlessly. They possess moments of brilliance alongside moments of sheer frustration. Whether or not they are “that bad” is subjective and depends on your tolerance for technical issues and your expectations for a modern Pokémon game. They do have learning potential as a game, and studying how their systems work can teach students how to better design future titles. The GamesLearningSociety.org is a good place to start your journey.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Pokémon Scarlet & Violet better than Sword & Shield?
This is debatable. Scarlet & Violet offer a more ambitious open-world experience and introduce new gameplay mechanics that Sword & Shield lack. However, Sword & Shield are generally considered more polished and have fewer technical issues. If performance is your priority, Sword & Shield might be a better choice. If you’re looking for a more innovative experience, despite the flaws, Scarlet & Violet might appeal more. While Scarlet & Violet has many improvements over its mainline series predecessor, Pokemon Sword & Shield, it did not become the instant favorite that many were expecting.
2. Why are Pokémon Scarlet & Violet so different from previous games?
Scarlet & Violet break from the traditional Pokémon formula by offering a true open-world experience. Previous games were more linear, guiding players along a set path. In Scarlet & Violet, you’re free to explore Paldea at your own pace, tackling the three storylines in any order you choose. This freedom, coupled with new gameplay mechanics like the Terastal Phenomenon, makes Scarlet & Violet a significant departure from previous entries.
3. What’s the deal with the performance issues in Pokémon Scarlet & Violet?
The performance issues are primarily attributed to the game’s ambitious open-world design and potentially inadequate optimization. The Nintendo Switch’s hardware may struggle to handle the game’s scale and complexity, resulting in frame rate drops, graphical glitches, and crashes. This is a significant point of criticism for both games.
4. Is the DLC for Pokémon Scarlet & Violet worth it?
The DLC adds new areas to explore, new Pokémon to catch, and expands on the game’s story. However, the performance issues persist in the DLC, and the story is relatively short. If you enjoy collecting Pokémon and are willing to overlook the technical flaws, the DLC might be worth it. If performance is a major concern, you may be disappointed.
5. Which version is more popular: Scarlet or Violet?
Violet has generally been slightly more popular than Scarlet. Download figures are not available for Nintendo games. The Violet version accounted for 52% of sales, while Scarlet accounted for 42%, and the double pack featuring both games made up the remaining 6%. However, both versions have sold incredibly well.
6. Was Pokémon Scarlet & Violet rushed?
The release of Scarlet & Violet was plagued by technical issues, leading many to believe that the game was rushed. While Game Freak has released updates to address some of these problems, the performance remains a significant concern. It is suspected by many that the game had a looming deadline and needed to be launched by a certain date.
7. Does Pokémon Violet run better now after the updates?
Updates have improved performance somewhat, but the games still suffer from frame rate drops and graphical glitches. Some players have reported smoother gameplay, while others continue to experience significant issues. It is better than it was at launch, but still not perfect.
8. Why is Pokémon Scarlet & Violet so hard?
Scarlet & Violet’s difficulty can be uneven due to the lack of level scaling. Some areas may be significantly more challenging than others, especially if your Pokémon are under-leveled. The trainer can try to level up their own Pokemon, but that is not an easy fix.
9. Will Pokémon disobey you in Scarlet & Violet?
Yes, Pokémon can disobey you if they are a higher level than your current gym badge progression allows. You need to earn more gym badges to command higher-level Pokémon effectively. Keep battling gyms and working towards the mastery of the game.
10. Is Pokémon Scarlet going to be harder than Violet?
There is no inherent difficulty difference between Scarlet and Violet. The gameplay challenges are the same in both versions. The main differences are the version-exclusive Pokémon and some aesthetic elements.
11. Which Gen 9 starter is the best?
This is subjective and depends on your playstyle. However, Fuecoco, the Fire-type starter, is often considered the best overall due to its strong final evolution, Skeledirge. However, you should choose the starter that appeals to you the most.
12. Can you do all three stories in Scarlet & Violet?
Yes, you can complete all three storylines (Victory Road, Path of Legends, and Starfall Street) in any order you choose. This freedom is a core element of the game’s open-world design.
13. What Pokémon are not in Scarlet & Violet?
Many older Pokémon are not available in Scarlet & Violet. Some notable omissions include Bulbasaur, Ivysaur, Venusaur, Squirtle, Wartortle and many more. These Pokémon can potentially be transferred in from other games via Pokémon HOME in the future.
14. Is Tyranitar in Scarlet or Violet?
Tyranitar and its Paradox form, Iron Thorns, are available in both Scarlet & Violet. However, Tyranitar does not perform as well as it used to, according to some players.
15. Is Pokémon losing fans due to Scarlet & Violet?
While Scarlet & Violet’s flaws have disappointed some fans, Pokémon is not necessarily losing overall popularity. The franchise remains incredibly popular, and future games have the potential to win back any disgruntled players.