Is Pokémon Scarlet & Violet a Bad Pokémon Game?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether Pokémon Scarlet & Violet are “bad” is complex, eliciting passionate opinions from across the Pokémon community. A simple yes or no answer doesn’t suffice. In short, they are not inherently bad games, but they are deeply flawed and certainly not among the best in the franchise. They represent a fascinating, albeit bumpy, transition into a more ambitious open-world design, which ultimately suffers from technical shortcomings and uneven execution. While there are many positive aspects, the numerous problems can’t be ignored, making the overall experience a mixed bag that falls short of its potential.
A Mixed Bag of Innovation and Issues
The Good: A Glimpse of the Future
Scarlet and Violet attempt something genuinely new for the mainline Pokémon series – a fully open-world experience where players can explore at their own pace. This is a significant departure from the more linear structures of previous titles. This open world allows for more freedom in Pokémon capturing and exploration. The sheer joy of discovering new Pokémon hidden around the vast landscapes of Paldea is a genuine highlight. The introduction of the Terastal phenomenon, adding a new layer of strategy to battles, is another positive. Finally, the game’s story, while somewhat disjointed in its delivery, does offer a compelling narrative with heartfelt moments, particularly towards the end.
The Bad: Technical Deficiencies and Frustrations
The biggest issue with Pokémon Scarlet & Violet is its performance. Graphical glitches, frame rate drops, and clipping issues are rampant, seriously impacting the enjoyment of the game. Character models can be bizarrely distorted, and even the music during crucial battles has been known to suffer. These are not minor issues; they disrupt the flow of the gameplay and make the experience feel unfinished and unpolished. The lackluster Shiny hunting experience and the bugs in Tera Raid battles are additional points of frustration.
The Story and Structure
While the storyline itself is engaging, the narrative structure is a bit disjointed. The open-ended nature means the player might not experience the best parts until the very end, which some find anti-climactic. Legends: Arceus handled the story pacing more effectively, gradually increasing the stakes and immersing the player into the world. Furthermore, Scarlet & Violet’s lack of level scaling can lead to some areas becoming unexpectedly difficult if the player’s Pokémon are not adequately trained.
Comparing to Others: A Step Backwards?
Compared to the likes of Pokémon Legends: Arceus, some might find Scarlet & Violet to be a step backwards. While the open world provides freedom, the traversal mechanics, particularly with Koraidon and Miraidon’s gliding capabilities, feel limited compared to Arceus’s freer exploration. Also, user scores on platforms like Metacritic reflect a large amount of player dissatisfaction, giving the games the lowest score of the mainline series.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What are the main issues with Pokémon Scarlet and Violet?
The primary issues revolve around poor performance, including frame rate drops, graphical glitches, and buggy battle experiences. Additionally, the game’s disjointed narrative and occasional difficulty spikes due to a lack of level scaling are common complaints.
2. Which game should I get, Scarlet or Violet?
The main differences lie in the version-exclusive Professor, with Professor Sada in Scarlet and Professor Turo in Violet. There are also differences in default school uniforms, version-exclusive Pokémon, and a slightly different aesthetic theme, with Violet emphasizing a futuristic vibe compared to Scarlet’s more primal theme.
3. Is Pokémon Scarlet and Violet buggy?
Yes, Pokémon Scarlet and Violet are known for their numerous bugs. These range from bizarre visual glitches and character distortions to issues with music during battles and game-breaking glitches that have affected progress.
4. Is Legends: Arceus or Scarlet and Violet better?
This depends on individual preference. Legends: Arceus boasts a more focused story, better pacing, and a unique exploration style. Scarlet & Violet offer an open world, but it suffers from performance issues and a more disjointed narrative. Most players find Legends: Arceus’ traversal system much more efficient.
5. Why are people complaining about Pokémon Scarlet and Violet?
The primary complaints stem from the games’ poor performance, riddled with technical glitches and significant frame rate drops, making it difficult to enjoy the core gameplay.
6. Why is Pokémon Violet so hard?
Pokémon Violet (and Scarlet) can be challenging due to the lack of level scaling. This means any area can be tough if your Pokémon are not appropriately leveled or equipped. It requires careful team building and strategizing.
7. Has Pokémon Scarlet and Violet been fixed?
Game updates have addressed some of the game-breaking glitches and bugs, including ones impacting side quests and post-game content. However, many performance issues and visual glitches still remain.
8. Why did Scarlet and Violet get bad reviews?
Reviews cite widespread dissatisfaction due to the game’s poor performance, significant frame rate drops, and numerous glitches. These issues overshadowed the game’s positive aspects.
9. Why is Violet more popular than Scarlet?
Violet’s futuristic aesthetic and its exclusive Pokémon are generally more appealing to many players than Scarlet’s more primal focus. Even the legendary vehicle, Miraidon, has a more sci-fi design, making it a more popular choice.
10. Is Pokémon Violet DLC worth it?
The DLC provides a decent amount of content and a new story. However, if you struggle with the base game’s performance issues, the DLC’s performance is similar. It’s worth it for those who prioritize content and can tolerate the technical shortcomings.
11. Which Pokémon game is the hardest?
According to many players, Pokémon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon are often considered the most challenging mainline games. This is due to formidable Totem battles, trainers with optimized Pokémon, and difficult final battles like Ultra Necrozma.
12. What are the rarest Pokémon in Pokémon Violet?
Some of the rarest Pokémon in Violet include the paradox forms like Iron Valiant, Family of 3 Maushold/3 Segment Dudunsparce, Antique Sinistea/Polteageist, and the event Pokémon Walking Wake/Iron Leaves.
13. Which Pokémon are hard to find in Scarlet?
Pokémon like Trevenant, Ditto, Zorua, Paradox Forms, Tauros’ Blaze & Aqua Breeds, and Gholdengo can be particularly difficult to find in Scarlet.
14. Why do some people dislike Pokémon Violet?
The main reasons include the poor optimization, numerous glitches, and missing features. These problems are compounded by the perceived lack of innovation and interesting “dungeons” similar to the previous games, such as Sword and Shield.
15. Are Koraidon and Miraidon shiny locked?
Yes, the legendary Pokémon Koraidon and Miraidon are Shiny-locked in Scarlet and Violet. This means that it’s not possible to obtain a shiny version through normal gameplay.
Conclusion: Potential Held Back
Pokémon Scarlet and Violet are not a complete failure, but their potential is significantly hampered by their technical shortcomings. The open-world concept and the story hold promise, but the numerous bugs, poor performance, and disjointed narrative leave much to be desired. They represent a step in a new direction for the Pokémon franchise, but they clearly require further polish and optimization. While there are aspects to appreciate, players should be aware of the significant issues that may impact their experience. Whether they are deemed “bad” comes down to individual tolerance for these flaws, but one thing is clear: they are a long way from reaching their full potential.