Is Secret Lair Legal? A Comprehensive Guide to Magic: The Gathering’s Unique Product
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, the vast majority of Secret Lair cards are tournament legal, though with some important caveats. The legality of these cards varies depending on the specific format of the Magic: The Gathering tournament you’re participating in. This article will break down the nuances of Secret Lair legality, offering a clear and comprehensive guide for players.
Understanding Secret Lair and its Legality
Secret Lair is a unique product line from Wizards of the Coast that offers players a curated selection of Magic: The Gathering cards with alternative art, special treatments, and sometimes even brand-new designs. It was initially launched with a focus on reprints of existing cards, often featuring unique artistic styles. However, the line has expanded to include new cards, especially with the introduction of the Universes Beyond series.
The general rule is that Secret Lair cards, like most other Magic cards, are legal in formats where the original card is legal. This means if a card is legal in, say, Commander, a Secret Lair printing of that card is also legal in Commander. However, the crucial difference lies in the way Wizards of the Coast has approached new cards introduced through Secret Lairs.
Reprint Cards vs. New Cards
Originally, Secret Lairs only contained reprints of cards already present in Magic. This meant that the Secret Lair versions inherited the legality of the original cards they were based on. So, if a card was legal in Modern, its Secret Lair version was too. However, the arrival of Universes Beyond and other themed Secret Lairs introduced a game-changer.
Some Secret Lair drops feature entirely new cards that are not reprints. This began with the Walking Dead drop and continued with other IPs like Stranger Things and Warhammer 40,000. These new cards have their own specific legality rules:
- Eternal Formats Only: New cards exclusive to Secret Lairs are generally legal only in Eternal formats such as Legacy, Vintage, Commander, and Oathbreaker. They are not legal in Standard, Pioneer, or Modern. This ensures that these unique cards do not disrupt the formats with rotating card pools.
- Why the Restriction? The restriction is primarily to maintain the competitive balance of non-eternal formats. New cards introduced through Secret Lairs are not included in standard booster packs, and therefore could create a pay-to-win scenario in rotating formats if they were legal.
Secret Lair Legality and Formats
Here’s a more specific breakdown of the legality of Secret Lair cards within various Magic: The Gathering formats:
- Standard: Secret Lair cards are not legal in Standard unless they are reprints of cards already legal in the Standard format from other sets. Any new cards exclusive to Secret Lair are not Standard legal.
- Pioneer: Similar to Standard, Secret Lair cards are not legal in Pioneer unless they are reprints of cards already legal in the Pioneer format from other sets. Exclusive new Secret Lair cards aren’t Pioneer legal.
- Modern: Again, Secret Lair cards are not legal in Modern unless they are reprints of cards already legal in the Modern format from other sets. New cards introduced via Secret Lairs are not Modern legal.
- Legacy: All Secret Lair cards, whether reprints or new cards, are legal in Legacy, as it is an eternal format.
- Vintage: Just like Legacy, all Secret Lair cards, including new ones, are legal in Vintage, an eternal format with very few card restrictions.
- Commander: All Secret Lair cards are legal in Commander. Commander is one of the most popular formats, and is an eternal format that allows use of all cards unless specifically banned.
- Oathbreaker: All Secret Lair cards are legal in Oathbreaker, another eternal format.
- Limited (Sealed and Draft): Secret Lair cards are not legal in any Limited format unless they are part of the regular set being used. For example, if a Secret Lair features a specific card that was part of the most recent set, this would be legal if opening the card in a limited event.
The Importance of the Holo-Foil
One way to verify a Magic card’s authenticity, which relates to its legality, is the presence of the holo-foil stamp. Most Magic cards, especially rares and mythics, have this small stamp at the bottom. While not directly tied to Secret Lair legality, this is a good way to ensure you’re playing with genuine Magic cards.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the legality and other aspects of Secret Lair cards:
1. Are all Secret Lair cards tournament legal?
No, not all Secret Lair cards are tournament legal in every format. While most reprints are legal in any format the original card is legal, new cards introduced exclusively through Secret Lairs are typically limited to eternal formats (Legacy, Vintage, Commander, and Oathbreaker).
2. What are Eternal Formats and why do they matter?
Eternal formats are Magic: The Gathering formats that include most Magic sets from the game’s history, without the rotating card pool like Standard and Pioneer. This is crucial to allow for the use of the new cards printed through Secret Lairs.
3. Are Universes Beyond cards legal?
Yes, but their legality follows the same rules as other Secret Lair cards. If they are new cards specific to Universes Beyond and were introduced as part of a Secret Lair, they are legal only in eternal formats.
4. Are Stranger Things MTG cards legal?
The Stranger Things cards, introduced through a Secret Lair drop, are legal only in eternal formats. These cards are not legal in Standard, Pioneer, or Modern.
5. Can I use my Secret Lair card in a local FNM?
It depends on the format of the FNM (Friday Night Magic). If the FNM is Standard, Pioneer, or Modern, you can only use Secret Lair cards if they are reprints already legal in the format. If the FNM is Commander, Legacy or Vintage, any Secret Lair card would be legal.
6. What about Secret Lair bonus cards? Are they legal?
Bonus cards included in Secret Lair drops follow the same legality rules as the rest of the cards in the drop. If it is a new card, it will only be legal in eternal formats.
7. How do I know if my Secret Lair card is legal for a specific format?
The easiest way to check is by reviewing the legality of the original card printed in a booster set. If it is a new Secret Lair card, it will most likely only be legal in the eternal formats. The Gatherer on the official Magic website is a great resource to research the legal status of cards.
8. Are Secret Lair cards worth investing in?
Secret Lairs are primarily for collectors and fans of specific aesthetics. They can sometimes appreciate in value, but it is not recommended to invest in them solely for financial gain.
9. How long does it take to receive my Secret Lair order?
It can take up to 3 weeks for your order to ship after the estimated release date listed in your order confirmation email.
10. Is it illegal to print your own Magic cards?
Yes, it’s illegal to print your own Magic cards for use in sanctioned events or for sale. This violates trademark and copyright laws.
11. What are fake MTG cards called?
Fake MTG cards are often referred to as proxies or counterfeits.
12. Why are some MTG cards banned?
Cards are banned due to offensive content, such as racial or cultural insensitivity, or to maintain game balance when a card creates undesirable combo or advantage.
13. Are Warhammer 40k MTG cards legal?
Yes, the Warhammer 40,000 Commander cards are legal in Commander, Vintage, and Legacy. They are not legal in Standard, Pioneer, or Modern.
14. Are Secret Lair cards more prone to curling?
Secret Lair foil cards, especially from earlier releases, can be prone to curling. However, there are no widespread reports of this being an issue with the newest releases.
15. Can I cancel a Secret Lair pre-order?
Yes, you can cancel your pre-order through the “Cancel pre-order” button on the “Manage Order” page on the official Secret Lair website.
Conclusion
Secret Lair cards, with their unique artwork and special treatments, offer an exciting way to collect and play Magic: The Gathering. While they are generally legal in many formats, it’s vital to understand the nuances, especially the differences between reprint cards and new cards introduced through the Secret Lair product line. By keeping these points in mind, you’ll be well-equipped to enjoy your Secret Lair collection in the format of your choice.