Is the Third Semester in Persona 5 Royal Canon? Unraveling the Mysteries
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of the third semester’s canonicity in Persona 5 Royal is a surprisingly complex one. While the third semester of Persona 5 Royal adds significant content and character development, it is explicitly stated not to be canon to Persona 5 Strikers. Persona 5 Strikers serves as a direct sequel to the events of the original Persona 5, completely ignoring the story beats, character arcs, and overarching themes introduced in the third semester of Royal. This means that the events of the third semester, the character of Kasumi Yoshizawa (Sumire) as a full member of the Phantom Thieves, and the expanded role of Goro Akechi are not considered part of the main timeline that continues into Strikers. Therefore, depending on how you look at the franchise, the third semester is or is not canon.
The Curious Case of Canonicity
The issue stems from a few factors. Firstly, Persona 5 Strikers was developed concurrently with Persona 5 Royal. This meant that the writers of Strikers couldn’t fully integrate the third semester’s narrative into their game without potentially delaying development or significantly altering their own storyline. Secondly, the thematic content of the third semester deals with complex and somewhat controversial topics like alternate realities and forced happiness, which might have clashed with the more lighthearted, road trip adventure Strikers aimed to deliver.
Ultimately, Atlus made a creative decision to prioritize the narrative flow from Persona 5 to Strikers, effectively relegating the third semester to a branching alternate timeline. This doesn’t diminish the value or impact of the third semester within Persona 5 Royal itself. It simply means that, in the grand scheme of the Persona 5 universe, it exists as a significant but non-essential side story. Consider it a captivating “What If?” scenario.
Understanding the Implications
So, what does this mean for fans? It means that the ending of Persona 5 leading directly into Persona 5 Strikers is the one where the Phantom Thieves defeat Yaldabaoth, the god of control, and Joker returns home to his parents (or chosen guardian). The third semester, with its exploration of Takuto Maruki’s reality and the re-emergence of Akechi, exists outside this established continuity.
This can be a little disappointing for players who grew attached to Sumire or enjoyed Akechi’s expanded role in the third semester. However, it also allows for a certain level of creative freedom in future spinoffs. While Sumire and the events of the third semester aren’t canon to Strikers, there’s always the possibility that they could be revisited in future titles or explored in different contexts.
For those interested in the academic side of gaming and how stories evolve, organizations like the Games Learning Society (https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/) provide a wealth of resources and research on the impact and intricacies of narrative choices in games. The decision regarding the third semester’s canonicity is a fascinating case study in how developers balance creative vision with established lore and player expectations.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Persona 5 Royal Canon
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the canonicity and related aspects of Persona 5 Royal:
1. Which ending of Persona 5 Royal is considered canon for Strikers?
The ending where the Phantom Thieves defeat Yaldabaoth and Joker returns home is the canon ending that Persona 5 Strikers follows directly.
2. Is Sumire Yoshizawa (Kasumi) canon to Persona 5 Strikers?
No, Sumire Yoshizawa, as a fully integrated member of the Phantom Thieves from the third semester, is not canon to Persona 5 Strikers. She is not mentioned or present in the game.
3. What happens in the third semester of Persona 5 Royal?
The third semester introduces a new palace ruled by Takuto Maruki, a school counselor who seeks to create a reality where everyone’s desires are fulfilled. It also involves the return of Goro Akechi in a significant role.
4. Is Goro Akechi’s survival canon?
Akechi’s survival is dependent on player choices made during his confidant route. His presence in the third semester is not canon to Strikers. Whether or not he survived in the original timeline before the third semester events is still up for debate.
5. If the third semester isn’t canon, is Persona 5 Royal still worth playing?
Absolutely! Persona 5 Royal is still considered the definitive version of Persona 5 due to its improved gameplay, quality-of-life changes, and expanded content, even if that content isn’t fully canon.
6. What is Persona 5 Strikers about?
Persona 5 Strikers is a direct sequel to Persona 5 that takes place during the Phantom Thieves’ summer vacation. They embark on a road trip across Japan to investigate a series of mysterious incidents.
7. Does Persona 5 Strikers reference the events of Persona 5?
Yes, Persona 5 Strikers directly references the events of the original Persona 5, including the Phantom Thieves’ battles against corrupt adults and their eventual victory over Yaldabaoth.
8. Is there a canon love interest for Joker?
There is no officially confirmed canon love interest for Joker. Romance is entirely player-determined.
9. What is the “true ending” of Persona 5 Royal?
The true ending of Persona 5 Royal is achieved by fulfilling specific conditions, including maxing out certain confidants and making specific choices during the third semester. It provides additional closure to the game’s storyline.
10. Can you fuse Satanael in Persona 5 Royal‘s third semester?
No, Satanael can only be fused in New Game+ of Persona 5 Royal, even after completing the third semester.
11. What is the bad ending of Persona 5 Royal?
One bad ending occurs if you reject Igor’s offer early in the game. Another arises if you fail to complete Maruki’s Palace by the deadline in the third semester, leading to a bleak conclusion.
12. What makes Maruki a villain?
Maruki’s villainy stems from his imposition of his ideal reality on others without their consent, denying them their free will and agency.
13. Is Morgana actually human?
No, Morgana is not human. He is a being created in the Metaverse with the purpose of assisting Joker in his quest to save the world.
14. What is Joker’s canon name?
While players can choose Joker’s name, his canon name is generally considered to be Ren Amamiya.
15. Will there be a Persona 6?
Yes, Atlus is currently developing Persona 6. While the exact release date is uncertain, projections estimate it could launch around 2025 or 2026.
Conclusion: Embrace the Multifaceted Narrative
Ultimately, the question of the third semester’s canonicity comes down to perspective. While it is explicitly not part of the mainline continuity leading into Persona 5 Strikers, it remains a valuable and enriching addition to the Persona 5 experience. It expands upon the themes of choice, freedom, and the pursuit of happiness, offering a compelling alternative narrative that many players have come to cherish. Whether you consider it canon or not, the third semester of Persona 5 Royal is undoubtedly a memorable and thought-provoking chapter in the Phantom Thieves’ story.