Persona 5 vs. Persona 5 Royal: Is the Difference Worth Your Time?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, there is a big difference between Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal. Persona 5 Royal is not just a simple re-release or a minor upgrade. It’s a significantly enhanced and expanded version of the original, offering a wealth of new content, gameplay improvements, and story additions that make it the definitive way to experience the Phantom Thieves’ journey. From an entirely new semester to revamped mechanics, Royal elevates the core Persona 5 experience in almost every way.
Why Persona 5 Royal is the Definitive Experience
Persona 5 Royal is more than just an expansion; it’s a substantial reimagining that addresses many of the original game’s shortcomings while adding layers of depth to its strengths. Here’s a breakdown of what sets Royal apart:
-
The Third Semester: This is arguably the biggest addition. Persona 5 Royal features an entirely new story arc that takes place after the original game’s ending. This third semester introduces new characters, delves deeper into existing relationships, and presents a compelling narrative that explores themes of truth, reality, and personal fulfillment. This addition alone justifies playing Royal over the original.
-
New Characters and Confidants: Royal introduces two significant new characters: Kasumi Yoshizawa, a talented gymnast with a mysterious connection to the protagonist, and Takuto Maruki, a school counselor who offers unique psychological support to the students. Both characters become confidants, offering new abilities and story arcs to explore.
-
Revamped Combat and Gameplay Mechanics: Royal refines the combat system with new mechanics like Showtime attacks (powerful team-up moves) and changes to Baton Passes, making battles more dynamic and engaging. Dungeons have also been tweaked with new collectibles and challenges, adding replay value.
-
Enhanced Social Sim Elements: Royal expands upon the social simulation aspects of Persona 5, adding new activities, locations, and dialogue options. This allows players to deepen their relationships with confidants even further and experience more of the everyday life of a high school student in Tokyo.
-
Visual and Performance Improvements: While not a complete graphical overhaul, Royal features visual enhancements and performance optimizations that make the game look and run smoother than the original.
-
Quality of Life Improvements: Royal incorporates numerous quality-of-life improvements that streamline the gameplay experience. These include tweaks to Mementos (the procedurally generated dungeon), faster loading times, and more convenient ways to manage your time.
Should You Still Play Persona 5?
In short, unless you’re severely budget-constrained, there’s very little reason to play the original Persona 5 over Royal. Royal encompasses everything that made the original great and improves upon it in almost every way. The new content and enhancements provide a richer, more complete, and ultimately more satisfying experience. If you’re curious about the themes explored through games, consider the insights at Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
The only real argument for playing the original first would be to experience the story as it was initially intended. However, the additions in Royal don’t fundamentally change the core narrative; they enhance and expand upon it, providing a more nuanced and thought-provoking conclusion.
Persona 5 Vanilla vs. Royal: A Summary
| Feature | Persona 5 | Persona 5 Royal |
|---|---|---|
| —————- | —————————————————————————————————————————————– | —————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————— |
| Story | Compelling narrative about rebellion and societal reform. | Expanded story with a brand new third semester, delving deeper into themes of truth and reality. |
| Characters | Iconic cast of Phantom Thieves and supporting characters. | Adds Kasumi Yoshizawa and Takuto Maruki as new confidants, enriching the existing character dynamics. |
| Gameplay | Turn-based combat with Persona fusion and social simulation elements. | Revamped combat with Showtime attacks, improved Baton Passes, and refined dungeon designs. Enhanced social sim elements with new activities and locations. |
| Presentation | Stylish visuals and a memorable soundtrack. | Visual enhancements and performance optimizations. |
| Quality of Life | Some aspects of the game can feel slow or repetitive. | Numerous quality-of-life improvements, including faster loading times and tweaks to Mementos. |
| Overall Experience | A fantastic JRPG with a captivating story and engaging gameplay. | The definitive Persona 5 experience, offering a more complete, polished, and satisfying journey. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the differences between Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal:
1. Is Persona 5 Royal just a rehash of the original?
No, Persona 5 Royal is not just a simple rehash. While it builds upon the foundation of the original Persona 5, it adds a significant amount of new content, including a completely new story arc, characters, and gameplay mechanics.
2. Does Persona 5 Royal change the main story of Persona 5?
While the core narrative remains the same, Persona 5 Royal expands upon it with the addition of the third semester. This new content adds context and depth to the existing story, but it doesn’t fundamentally alter the events of the original game.
3. Is Kasumi Yoshizawa important to the story of Persona 5 Royal?
Yes, Kasumi Yoshizawa plays a significant role in the new third semester of Persona 5 Royal. Her story is intertwined with the themes of truth and reality that are explored in this new arc.
4. Are the gameplay changes in Persona 5 Royal significant?
Yes, the gameplay changes in Persona 5 Royal are quite significant. The addition of Showtime attacks, improvements to Baton Passes, and tweaks to dungeon designs make the combat more dynamic and engaging.
5. Is Persona 5 Royal longer than Persona 5?
Yes, Persona 5 Royal is longer than Persona 5, primarily due to the addition of the third semester. Expect to spend around 20-30 hours more on Royal compared to the original.
6. Does Persona 5 Royal have a different ending than Persona 5?
Yes, Persona 5 Royal features a new true ending that is tied to the events of the third semester. This ending provides a more nuanced and thought-provoking conclusion to the story.
7. Can I transfer my save data from Persona 5 to Persona 5 Royal?
No, you cannot transfer your save data from Persona 5 to Persona 5 Royal. You will need to start a new game from scratch.
8. Is Persona 5 Royal worth the price if I already own Persona 5?
For most players, the answer is a resounding yes. The new content, gameplay improvements, and story additions make Persona 5 Royal a worthwhile investment, even if you already own the original.
9. Does Persona 5 Royal fix the repetitive elements of Persona 5?
While some repetitive elements remain, Persona 5 Royal does address many of the original game’s pacing issues with quality-of-life improvements and new activities.
10. Is Persona 5 Royal more difficult than Persona 5?
Persona 5 Royal offers various difficulty options, allowing you to tailor the challenge to your preference. The base difficulty is generally similar to Persona 5, but the new content can present some unique challenges.
11. Is Persona 5 Royal the best Persona game?
That’s a matter of personal opinion, but many fans consider Persona 5 Royal to be the best entry in the series due to its refined gameplay, compelling story, and memorable characters.
12. Can I romance all the girls in Persona 5 Royal without consequences?
Dating multiple girls in Persona 5 Royal will lead to a humorous but ultimately unsatisfying scene on Valentine’s Day. Be prepared for the consequences of your actions!
13. What is the canon name for Joker in Persona 5?
While the player can choose Joker’s name, his canonical name is Ren Amamiya in most appearances. Akira Kurusu is used in the manga adaptation.
14. How many endings does Persona 5 Royal have?
Persona 5 Royal has multiple endings, including a true ending that is unlocked by completing the third semester and making specific choices.
15. When can we expect Persona 6?
While there’s no official release date, rumors suggest that Persona 6 may not arrive until 2025 or later.
In conclusion, Persona 5 Royal is a significant upgrade over the original Persona 5, offering a wealth of new content and improvements that make it the definitive way to experience this modern JRPG classic. If you’re a fan of the genre or curious about the Persona series, Persona 5 Royal is an absolute must-play.