Table of Contents

Elden Ring Smithing Stones: Are They Truly Limited? A Comprehensive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers Is there a limited number of smithing stones? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The Lands Between offer a vast array of challenges and opportunities for Tarnished adventurers. Upgrading your weapons is paramount to surviving the dangers lurking in every corner of Elden Ring. But are the materials needed for this crucial task, the Smithing Stones, finite? The short answer is technically no, but with a crucial caveat. While certain rare and powerful stones are limited to a single playthrough, the game provides avenues for acquiring the majority of Smithing Stones indefinitely, allowing dedicated players to continuously enhance their arsenal.

Understanding Smithing Stones in Elden Ring

Elden Ring employs a tiered system for weapon upgrades, necessitating specific Smithing Stones based on the weapon type and desired level. There are two main categories of upgrade materials:

Smithing Stones: Used to upgrade regular weapons up to +25. They are divided into tiers (1-8), with higher tiers required for higher upgrade levels.
Somber Smithing Stones: Used to upgrade unique or “special” weapons, often those obtained from bosses or important NPCs, up to +10. These are also divided into tiers (1-9).

Both types culminate in an “Ancient Dragon” variant, which are very rare and needed to reach the maximum upgrade level for a weapon.

The Finite and Infinite Aspects

The key to understanding the availability of Smithing Stones lies in distinguishing between fixed, one-time finds and farmable sources.

Fixed Location Smithing Stones: Scattered throughout the world are numerous Smithing Stones that can be found as item pickups, often in mines, caves, and ruins. These stones are finite; once collected, they do not respawn unless you enter New Game Plus (NG+).
Enemy Drops: Many enemies, particularly those found in areas abundant with mineral deposits, have a chance to drop Smithing Stones upon defeat. These enemies do respawn, making it possible to farm specific stone types indefinitely.
Bell Bearings: This is the game-changer. By discovering and delivering Smithing-Stone Miner’s Bell Bearings and Somberstone Miner’s Bell Bearings to the Twin Maiden Husks at the Roundtable Hold, you unlock the ability to purchase an unlimited supply of Smithing Stones 1 through 8 (for regular weapons) and Somber Smithing Stones 1 through 9 (for special weapons). The availability depends on the specific Bell Bearing you find.
Limited Ancient Dragon Stones: It’s crucial to remember that the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones and Somber Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones, required to fully upgrade weapons, are strictly limited per playthrough. Only a handful exist within each game cycle, forcing players to be strategic about which weapons they choose to max out, or to embark on multiple NG+ runs.

How to Effectively Farm Smithing Stones

Farming Smithing Stones involves identifying enemies that consistently drop the desired stones and establishing efficient routes to eliminate them repeatedly. Here’s a general strategy:

Research: Determine which enemies in which locations drop the specific Smithing Stone you need. Online resources and player communities are invaluable for this.
Location Selection: Choose a location with a high density of the target enemy and a nearby Site of Grace for easy resetting.
Optimize Your Build: Equip items and spells that boost item discovery (e.g., Silver Scarab Talisman, Silver-Pickled Fowl Foot).
Farming Route: Develop a quick and efficient route to eliminate all target enemies.
Reset: Once the route is complete, rest at the Site of Grace to respawn the enemies and repeat the process.

FAQs: Your Smithing Stone Questions Answered

Here are some frequently asked questions regarding Smithing Stones in Elden Ring to provide further clarification:

Are Smithing Stones completely unlimited? No. All tiers of normal Smithing Stones are potentially unlimited (after you find the Bell Bearing). The exception is Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones and Somber Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones, which remain finite per playthrough.
Where can I find early-game Smithing Stones? Limgrave Tunnels and Morne Tunnel are excellent early-game locations for finding Smithing Stone [1]. Raya Lucaria Crystal Tunnel provides Smithing Stone [2].
Can I buy unlimited Somber Smithing Stones early in the game? Yes! In Liurnia of the Lakes, near the Road To The Manor Site of Grace, a friendly giant sells infinite Somber Smithing Stone [1] and [2].
What is the maximum weapon upgrade level in Elden Ring? Normal weapons can be upgraded to +25, while special (Somber) weapons can be upgraded to +10.
How many Smithing Stones do I need to fully upgrade a regular weapon? You need 12 of each Smithing Stone tier (1-8) to upgrade a regular weapon to +24, plus one Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone to reach +25.
How many Somber Smithing Stones do I need to fully upgrade a special weapon? You need one of each Somber Smithing Stone tier (1-9) to upgrade a special weapon to +9, plus one Somber Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone to reach +10.
Where can I find the Bell Bearings for unlimited Smithing Stones? Bell Bearings are found in various locations, often dropped by bosses in mines or hidden areas. Explore thoroughly and consult online guides for specific locations.
Can I farm Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones? No. Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones are limited to a set number per playthrough.
What is the best way to increase item discovery? Equip the Silver Scarab Talisman and consume Silver-Pickled Fowl Feet. Also, increasing your Arcane stat will inherently boost item discovery.
Do Smithing Stones respawn after I pick them up? No. Smithing Stones found as fixed item pickups do not respawn within the same playthrough.
What enemies are good for farming Smithing Stone [5]? Miners in Sellia Crystal Tunnel are a good source of Smithing Stone [5].
How many weapons can I fully upgrade in a single playthrough? You can fully upgrade approximately 13 normal weapons and 8 special weapons per playthrough, limited by the availability of Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones.
Is it worth going into NG+ just for more Smithing Stones? If you want to fully upgrade a wide variety of weapons, then yes, NG+ is essential. However, consider whether the effort outweighs simply sticking with a smaller selection of fully upgraded favorites.
Are Somber weapons generally better than regular weapons? Not necessarily. Somber weapons often have unique skills and attributes, but regular weapons can be customized with Ashes of War and infusions, offering more build flexibility.
How does Equip Load affect my ability to farm? Ensure your Equip Load remains below 70% to avoid “heavy load,” which significantly reduces your mobility and stamina regeneration. Optimize your armor and talismans to maintain medium or light load for efficient farming. Remember that Elden Ring’s Equip Load does not come into play while mounted; using the Spirit Steed will bypass any movement restrictions.

Mastering the Art of Weapon Enhancement

The ability to effectively acquire and utilize Smithing Stones is a core element of mastering Elden Ring. By understanding the finite and infinite aspects of these resources, and by employing efficient farming strategies, players can equip themselves with the powerful weaponry necessary to conquer the challenges that await them in the Lands Between. Remember to explore thoroughly, experiment with different builds, and never be afraid to delve into the online community for valuable tips and insights.

Consider exploring the research being done about gaming at sites such as GamesLearningSociety.org.