Is There an Evil Path in Hogwarts Legacy?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is: no, not really. While Hogwarts Legacy allows players to dabble in the dark arts, learn the Unforgivable Curses, and make morally questionable choices, there isn’t a true “evil path” that significantly alters the main narrative or results in a drastically different ending. You won’t become the next Voldemort no matter how many dark spells you sling around, nor will you face severe in-game consequences for your actions. The game’s design prioritizes player freedom and exploration over a strict morality system, offering a largely consistent core storyline regardless of your choices. However, you can still shape your character’s personal journey in ways that feel more “dark” or morally ambiguous, even if the game’s overall plot isn’t dramatically affected.
The Illusion of Choice: How Dark Can You Really Go?
Hogwarts Legacy does a great job of letting players feel like they are making impactful decisions that lean towards a more evil path. You can learn and use Avada Kedavra, Crucio, and Imperio, the infamous Unforgivable Curses, and you can choose dialogue options that reflect a more ruthless or power-hungry personality. However, the game doesn’t penalize you for these choices in any meaningful way. Using these curses won’t change how characters treat you, won’t affect which quests are available to you, and crucially, it won’t alter the overall trajectory of the main storyline.
Unforgivable Curses: Power, Not Punishment
The inclusion of the Unforgivable Curses is often a key element discussed when players wonder if they can be truly evil in Hogwarts Legacy. While learning these curses feels like a significant step towards a darker path, their effects in-game are purely mechanical. They simply provide more options in combat, making you a more powerful wizard. There’s no consequence for blasting enemies with Avada Kedavra; NPCs won’t react differently and you won’t gain any “evil” reputation within Hogwarts. This is a disappointment for players hoping for a game with a robust moral system where choices have substantial consequences.
Narrative Choices: Shaping Your Personal Story
Although the core plot remains constant, your dialogue choices and how you engage with the story’s secondary characters can create a sense of a “darker” playthrough. You might choose to be aggressive, selfish, or manipulative in your interactions with other students or NPCs. The most significant narrative choice that leads to a different outcome is related to the ending and the Repository of Ancient Magic. Specifically, when Professor Fig asks what your intentions are for the Repository, choosing the option “I intend to open it” unlocks the “bad ending.” This choice means your character will try to harness the raw power and absorb a portion of it into themselves instead of working with others to seal it away. However, even this “bad” ending doesn’t drastically alter the game’s core narrative.
Sebastian Sallow and the Dark Arts
The questline surrounding Sebastian Sallow provides some of the most morally ambiguous and emotionally charged moments in the game. Sebastian’s descent into dark magic and his eventual confrontation with his uncle creates a morally grey area for the player. While you cannot stop Sebastian from killing his uncle, you do have the choice of turning Sebastian in to the authorities for his crimes or letting him walk free. Turning him in results in his expulsion from Hogwarts and him disappearing from the game entirely. If you choose not to turn him in, he remains a part of your journey and potentially teaches you the Unforgivable Curses. However, even this decision, while affecting your game experience and your opportunities to interact with Sebastian, doesn’t drastically alter the central storyline.
The Lack of a Morality System
The primary reason there isn’t an “evil path” is the absence of a traditional in-game morality system. This means there are no meters that track your good or evil actions, no reputation systems with the various houses, and no repercussions for wielding the most heinous curses. Hogwarts Legacy emphasizes player freedom and experimentation over a strict good versus evil binary. This decision to forgo a robust moral system has been a point of contention amongst some players, who feel that the absence of consequences diminishes the impact of their actions.
Conclusion: An Individualized Experience
While Hogwarts Legacy allows players to explore darker elements through its magic and narrative, it lacks a true “evil path” that dramatically changes the game’s core elements. You can become a powerful and ruthless witch or wizard by learning the Unforgivable Curses, making morally questionable choices, and opting for the “bad” ending, but your overall experience and the game’s resolution will largely remain consistent. What you get instead is a highly individualized journey where your character’s narrative can feel more ethically compromised despite the game’s main story largely remaining unchanged. If you were hoping for a game with branching storylines and the opportunity to become the next dark lord, Hogwarts Legacy may not deliver that experience. But it offers a compelling adventure where you can choose your own role, good, bad, or somewhere in-between, even if the game’s wider narrative doesn’t change drastically.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does using the Unforgivable Curses impact the main story in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, using Unforgivable Curses like Avada Kedavra, Crucio, and Imperio has no impact on the main story of Hogwarts Legacy. The only thing it changes is the tools you have in combat.
2. Can you become a dark wizard and be recognized as such in Hogwarts Legacy?
No. There is no morality system in Hogwarts Legacy so no matter your choices, you won’t be seen as inherently evil or recognized as such by any in-game characters.
3. Can you get a bad ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
There is a “bad ending” that you can unlock by choosing the option “I intend to open it” when discussing the Repository with Professor Fig. However, it does not radically alter the overall narrative of the game.
4. Does the “bad ending” make you stronger in Hogwarts Legacy?
In the “bad” ending, your character absorbs some of the raw ancient magic, getting a burst of strength, but this is a narrative element and doesn’t really have any in-game mechanical effects.
5. Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, you cannot prevent Sebastian from killing his uncle. This event is set within the narrative and unavoidable.
6. Does learning Avada Kedavra make you evil in Hogwarts Legacy?
Learning and using Avada Kedavra has no in-game consequences beyond giving you an additional tool in combat. It does not make you “evil” within the context of the game’s systems.
7. Can you go to Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy?
Visiting Azkaban is an option in Hogwarts Legacy only for players who chose a particular House at the start of the game and even then, it’s a very brief and linear visit.
8. How many endings does Hogwarts Legacy have?
There are essentially three endings to Hogwarts Legacy, but all players have access to them, and your path in the game does not significantly change which ending you receive.
9. Is there a downside to learning the Unforgivable Curses in Hogwarts Legacy?
There are no downsides to learning and using the Unforgivable Curses in Hogwarts Legacy. They do not affect the story, and they only provide extra combat options.
10. Should you turn Sebastian in or not in Hogwarts Legacy?
Turning in Sebastian results in his expulsion and loss of access to him as a quest giver. Not turning him in keeps him in the game and lets you learn the Unforgivable Curses from him if you haven’t already.
11. Can you get expelled from Hogwarts in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, it is not possible to get expelled from Hogwarts in Hogwarts Legacy. This is not a mechanic within the game.
12. Can you use the Patronus charm in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, the Patronus charm is not available to use in Hogwarts Legacy.
13. Are there Dementors in Hogwarts Legacy?
Dementors are not present in the Hogwarts grounds, and they are only seen by the members of one of the houses.
14. Can you learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes. If you didn’t learn the curse from Sebastian or chose to turn him in, you can access Avada Kedavra in the Dark Arts Battle Arena which is part of the Deluxe Edition or the Dark Arts Pack DLC.
15. Will there be a Hogwarts Legacy 2?
Yes, there are indications that a sequel to Hogwarts Legacy is in development, though official announcements are yet to be made.