Is Time Warp Banned in MTG? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is: it depends on the format. The card Time Warp has a complex history within Magic: The Gathering (MTG), with its legality varying wildly across different formats. Let’s delve into the details to provide a clear picture of where this powerful extra-turn spell stands.
Time Warp’s Status in Different Formats
Time Warp’s ability to grant an extra turn makes it a highly sought-after and often problematic card. Here’s a breakdown of its legality:
- Historic (MTG Arena): Banned. As of June 10th, Time Warp is banned in the Historic format on MTG Arena. This ban was implemented due to the card’s contribution to an over-performing and consistent archetype that stifled format diversity. Players who had copies of Time Warp on their Arena accounts received wildcard compensations. The decision was driven by the high win rate and lack of unfavorable matchups for decks utilizing Time Warp. The same article also had discussions of Brainstorm, which was considered but ultimately not banned.
- Commander: Legal. Despite being a potent spell, Time Warp remains legal in the Commander format. This may seem surprising considering its power level, but the format’s casual, multiplayer nature often provides enough avenues for opponents to respond to extra-turn strategies. However, its strength still makes it a common inclusion in many Commander decks.
- Other Formats: Time Warp is also legal in other formats where it hasn’t been explicitly banned, such as Pioneer, Modern, and Legacy. However, it’s important to note that format legality can change. As of this article, the card remains legal in these formats, but it’s essential to always verify before playing.
Time Walk: The Grandfather of Extra Turns
While discussing Time Warp, it’s crucial to mention its predecessor, Time Walk. This card is part of the legendary “Power Nine” and is a 1 mana, blue sorcery that grants an extra turn. Its impact on the game is even more profound than Time Warp’s.
- Commander: Banned. Time Walk is banned in Commander due to its immense power. Its ability to disrupt the natural flow of the game and provide a significant tempo advantage makes it too problematic for the format’s casual, balanced design.
- Legacy: Banned. Similarly, Time Walk is also banned in Legacy due to its overwhelming power.
- Vintage: Restricted. In Vintage, the most powerful format where many older cards are legal, Time Walk is restricted. This means you can only include one copy of it in your deck, highlighting its powerful impact.
Why The Discrepancy in Bans?
The decision to ban or allow a card in a particular format hinges on various factors, including:
- Format Philosophy: Commander is designed to be a casual, social format where games are meant to be fun and unpredictable. While powerful cards exist, the focus is on interaction and multiple players. The ban list aims to remove cards that overly disrupt this balance. Formats like Historic prioritize balanced, interactive gameplay.
- Power Level: A card’s inherent power and the synergy it creates within a format play a big role. Time Warp can create a powerful combo with other cards, and its consistent performance lead to its ban in Historic. The immense power of Time Walk and its disruption of normal gameplay warranted a ban in most formats.
- Format Data: WotC and the Commander Rules Committee have access to comprehensive data on card performance and win rates, which guide ban decisions. The win rate of Time Warp decks in Historic directly influenced its banning.
Related Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is Time Warp a powerful card in MTG?
Yes, Time Warp is a very powerful card in MTG. Its ability to grant an extra turn provides a significant advantage, allowing players to make additional plays, attack more, and advance their strategies much faster than their opponents.
Was Time Warp really the problem in Historic?
Yes, according to the developers, Time Warp was the central problem in the Historic format. They determined that its consistent performance and its decks’ lack of unfavorable matchups contributed significantly to an unhealthy metagame.
What is the most toxic card in MTG?
This is subjective, but many consider cards that lead to non-interactive gameplay or lock opponents out of the game to be “toxic.” Some of the commonly named cards with this type of negative play pattern are: Venser, Corpse Puppet, Necrogen Rotpriest, Bloated Contaminator, Karumonix, the Rat King, and Skrelv, Defector Mite. However, this term depends on your play experience and style.
Is Mox Amber banned in Commander?
Yes, Mox Amber is banned in Commander. This ban was implemented because early Mox cards tend to create one-sided games, limiting strategic options and disrupting the natural flow of the format.
Is Edgar Markov banned as a commander?
Yes, Edgar Markov is banned as a commander. Other cards like Edric, Spymaster of Trest are also banned as commanders specifically, not from a deck.
Are 40K cards legal in MTG?
Yes, most Warhammer 40,000 Commander cards are legal in Commander, Vintage, and Legacy. However, they are not legal in Standard, Pioneer, or Modern.
Are MTG Unfinity cards legal?
Yes, Unfinity eternal cards are legal in Commander, Legacy, and Vintage.
Is Vial Smasher the Fierce banned in Commander?
Vial Smasher the Fierce is banned as a commander in Duel Commander format, but it may be part of your deck in the format. It’s important to note the specific format distinction here.
Is Jeweled Lotus banned in Commander?
Yes, Jeweled Lotus is banned in the Commander format. This card’s ability to give a significant early mana advantage to a commander quickly made it an unhealthy addition to the format.
Why is Chaos Orb banned in Commander?
Chaos Orb is banned because it requires physical dexterity to use, potentially making it unfair for those who are unable to perform the required actions or use the same dexterity.
Is Paradox Engine still banned in Commander?
Yes, Paradox Engine is still banned in Commander. It was banned in 2019 due to its propensity to run games into long, uninteractive loops.
Is Flash legal in Commander?
Yes, Flash is legal in Commander. It was previously banned, but the ban was lifted. Despite being a powerful card, the format has the ability to answer it and its combos.
Is Uro banned in Commander?
No, Uro is not banned in Commander. It was banned in several other formats but remains legal in Commander.
Was Time Warp made for Rocky Horror?
No, Time Warp as a card in MTG and “Time Warp” as a song and dance from the Rocky Horror Picture Show have no relation. They happen to share the same name.
Why is Erayo banned in Commander?
Erayo is banned in Commander because her effect is extremely powerful early game, severely limiting a player’s ability to play any spells without an answer. She was viewed as too restrictive.
Conclusion
Time Warp’s legality is a complex issue, and it’s essential to stay updated on format-specific ban lists. While banned in Historic, it remains a potent card in Commander and other formats. The card is a good example of the complex balance that the developers have to maintain to ensure a healthy and enjoyable experience for players across the different ways they chose to engage with MTG. Always double-check the official ban lists and rules before playing in any format.