Is Zweihander Better Than Black Knight Greatsword? A Dark Souls Duel of Titans
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question: Is the Zweihander better than the Black Knight Greatsword in Dark Souls? The answer, like most things in FromSoftware’s masterpiece, is nuanced and depends heavily on your playstyle, build, and stage of the game. Generally, the Zweihander offers accessibility and utility throughout the entire game, while the Black Knight Greatsword shines with its raw power and relatively early-game potential. The Zweihander’s moveset and low stat requirements make it a reliable choice for various builds, while the Black Knight Greatsword demands specific stat investments to truly unleash its potential. It all boils down to what you value more: consistent performance and build flexibility (Zweihander) or focused power and potentially earlier dominance (Black Knight Greatsword).
Comparing the Colossi: Zweihander vs. Black Knight Greatsword
Let’s delve deeper into the core characteristics of each weapon to understand why they appeal to different players.
Zweihander: The Pancake King
The Zweihander is a colossal sword known for its devastating two-handed attacks and infamous “pancake” attack, where a heavy attack sends enemies sprawling. Its key strengths are:
- Low Stat Requirements: Requiring only 24 Strength and 8 Dexterity, the Zweihander is accessible early on, allowing players to wield it effectively even with a relatively low-level character.
- Versatile Moveset: Its moveset includes horizontal slashes for crowd control and a unique thrust attack (R2 when two-handed) that deals significant damage and can knock down opponents.
- Light Weight (for a Colossal Sword): Compared to other colossal swords, the Zweihander is relatively lightweight, allowing for more agile movement and stamina management.
- Scalability: The Zweihander scales with both Strength and Dexterity, making it a solid choice for quality builds (builds that invest in both stats).
- Early Availability: Found in the graveyard near Firelink Shrine, the Zweihander is obtainable very early in the game, giving players a powerful weapon right from the start.
Black Knight Greatsword: The Fiery Foe
The Black Knight Greatsword is a formidable weapon obtained from defeated Black Knights. Its notable characteristics are:
- High Base Damage: This weapon boasts exceptional base damage, making it a powerhouse early to mid-game.
- Poise Damage: The Black Knight Greatsword deals significant poise damage, staggering enemies more easily.
- Two-Handed Power: This weapon shines when wielded two-handed, increasing its attack speed and damage output.
- Fire Damage: While not explicitly displayed, Black Knight weapons deal a small amount of fire damage, adding a bit of extra punch.
- Black Knight Slayer Bonus: Black Knight weapons deal bonus damage against demon-type enemies, a common threat throughout Dark Souls.
- Limited Scaling: While it scales with Strength (C) and Dexterity (E), the scaling isn’t as significant as other weapons, making it less effective at very high levels.
Head-to-Head: Where Each Weapon Shines
- Early Game: The Black Knight Greatsword can dominate the early to mid-game due to its high base damage. If you get lucky and loot it early, it will carry you through many challenging encounters.
- Mid to Late Game: The Zweihander‘s versatility and scalability make it a reliable choice for the entire game, especially for quality builds.
- Boss Fights: Both weapons are viable for boss fights. The Black Knight Greatsword’s raw damage can quickly deplete a boss’s health bar, while the Zweihander’s knockdown attack can provide valuable openings.
- PvP: The Zweihander is often favored in PvP due to its unpredictable moveset and “pancake” attack, which can catch opponents off guard. The Black Knight Greatsword’s slower attack speed can make it vulnerable to more agile opponents.
- Builds: The Zweihander suits quality builds due to scaling with strength and dexterity, while the Black Knight Greatsword suits strength builds.
Making Your Decision
Ultimately, the “better” weapon depends on your personal preferences and build goals. If you prioritize early-game power and don’t mind a weapon that doesn’t scale as well later on, the Black Knight Greatsword is a fantastic choice. If you prefer a versatile weapon that remains effective throughout the entire game and are planning a quality build, the Zweihander is an excellent option. Test both, and see which suits your playstyle. There is no “correct” answer. Experimentation and adaptability are keys to success in Dark Souls. Learn more about weapon builds and game design at the Games Learning Society, a community exploring the intersection of games and education. Visit their website at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions about the Zweihander and Black Knight Greatsword:
Is the Zweihander considered a “noob” weapon?
While some players associate the Zweihander with beginners due to its ease of access and effectiveness, it’s a powerful weapon in the hands of experienced players as well. Its versatility and unique moveset make it a viable choice for all skill levels.
Where can I find the Zweihander early in Dark Souls?
The Zweihander is located in the graveyard near Firelink Shrine. Be cautious of the skeletons guarding it!
What stats do I need to wield the Zweihander effectively?
You need 24 Strength and 8 Dexterity to wield the Zweihander properly.
How do I get the Black Knight Greatsword?
The Black Knight Greatsword is dropped by Black Knights wielding it. These enemies can be found in several locations throughout the game, including the Undead Burg and Kiln of the First Flame.
What stats do I need to wield the Black Knight Greatsword effectively?
Ideally, you need high Strength and Dexterity. While you can wield it with lower stats, you won’t unlock its full potential until you invest significantly in these attributes.
Can I upgrade the Black Knight Greatsword?
Yes, but only with Twinkling Titanite. It cannot be upgraded with regular Titanite shards, large shards, chunks, or slabs.
Which weapon is better for a pure Strength build?
Both are excellent for a Strength build but the Black Knight Greatsword tends to shine because of its high base damage.
Which weapon is better for a quality build?
The Zweihander is better for a quality build because its scaling is Strength and Dexterity.
Does the Black Knight Greatsword have hidden fire damage?
Yes, Black Knight weapons deal a small amount of fire damage. This damage is not explicitly displayed in the weapon’s stats but contributes to its overall damage output.
Is the Black Knight Greatsword worth upgrading to +5?
Yes, absolutely. Upgrading the Black Knight Greatsword to +5 significantly increases its damage output, making it even more potent.
Which weapon is better for crowd control?
The Zweihander’s sweeping attacks make it better for crowd control.
How does poise damage work in Dark Souls?
Poise damage determines how easily you can stagger an enemy. The more poise damage a weapon deals, the quicker it can break an enemy’s poise, leaving them vulnerable to attack.
Can I enchant the Black Knight Greatsword?
No, Black Knight weapons cannot be enchanted with spells or resins.
What is the “pancake” attack with the Zweihander?
The “pancake” attack is a term used to describe the Zweihander’s two-handed heavy attack, which sends enemies flying and knocks them prone.
How does weapon scaling work in Dark Souls?
Weapon scaling refers to how much a weapon’s damage increases based on your character’s stats. Weapons with higher scaling in a particular stat will benefit more from investing in that stat.