The Ultimate Red Dead Redemption 2 Dilemma: Should Arthur Get the Money or Go With John?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The agonizing choice at the climax of Red Dead Redemption 2 – whether Arthur Morgan should return for the money or help John Marston escape – has sparked countless debates among players. The definitive answer, steeped in narrative depth and thematic resonance, is this: Arthur should go with John. While the allure of a final payday is tempting, choosing John’s path unlocks the game’s most profound and impactful ending, solidifying Arthur’s redemption arc and setting the stage for the events of the original Red Dead Redemption. Choosing the money, while offering a fleeting glimpse of treasure, ultimately diminishes Arthur’s sacrifice and leads to a less satisfying conclusion.
The Weight of Honor vs. the Lure of Greed
The decision hinges on the core themes woven throughout Red Dead Redemption 2: honor, loyalty, and the struggle against a changing world. Throughout the game, Arthur grapples with his role as an outlaw, questioning the morality of his actions under Dutch van der Linde’s increasingly delusional leadership. The tuberculosis diagnosis forces him to confront his mortality and re-evaluate his priorities.
Going back for the money is a deviation from Arthur’s hard-won redemption. It signifies a regression to the outlaw mentality he’s been trying to shed. It’s a selfish act in what should be selfless moments. He sees John, Abigail and Jack as the future and going for the money completely throws that away.
Helping John escape, however, embodies the culmination of Arthur’s transformation. He chooses family, legacy, and the promise of a better future for John and his family over personal gain. This act of selflessness elevates him from a morally ambiguous outlaw to a tragic hero, securing his place as one of gaming’s most beloved characters.
The Narrative Impact: Redemption Realized
The “Go with John” ending offers a significantly richer and more emotionally resonant narrative experience. Arthur’s final stand against the Pinkertons allows John to escape, ensuring his survival and providing him with the opportunity to start a new life.
This choice also leads to a more poignant final confrontation with Micah Bell. While the fight is brutal either way, the context is different. If Arthur goes with John, the fight is about protecting his family and making sure they survive. If he goes for the money, it is purely about greed and there is nothing honorable about it.
The “Canon” Choice: Confirmation from the Game Itself
Adding weight to this argument is the game’s design itself. As the prompt notes, if the player makes no decision or runs out of time, the game defaults to Arthur helping John. This suggests that Rockstar Games intended this path as the “canon” ending, the one that best aligns with the overarching narrative and themes of Red Dead Redemption 2.
Exploring the Consequences of Each Choice
Let’s delve deeper into what happens when Arthur makes each choice, highlighting the key differences in narrative and gameplay.
The “Go For the Money” Outcome
- The Ambush: Arthur reaches the camp and retrieves some of the money but is ambushed by Micah.
- The Knife Fight: A brutal knife fight ensues, with Micah gaining the upper hand and stabbing Arthur.
- Diminished Redemption: While still a powerful scene, Arthur’s death feels less heroic and more like a consequence of his greed.
- Missed Opportunity for Closure: He sacrifices his last moments for fleeting personal gain, diluting the impact of his redemption arc.
The “Go With John” Outcome
- Protecting the Future: Arthur’s primary focus is on ensuring John’s escape and the safety of his family.
- Sacrifice and Heroism: He bravely holds off the Pinkertons, buying John valuable time to escape.
- A More Meaningful Confrontation with Micah: The fight with Micah is driven by a desire to protect John and his family, adding weight to the conflict.
- Complete Redemption: Arthur’s final moments are filled with regret and a sense of peace knowing that he did everything he could to give John a chance at a better life.
Why Choose John?
- Upholds the Theme of Redemption: Arthur’s journey towards redemption culminates in this selfless act.
- Sets Up the Events of Red Dead Redemption: John’s escape is crucial for the events of the first game to unfold.
- Provides a More Emotional and Satisfying Conclusion: It creates a powerful emotional connection with Arthur, cementing his legacy.
- Reinforces the Importance of Family and Loyalty: It emphasizes the bonds of loyalty and the importance of protecting loved ones.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Arthur’s Choice
1. Does Arthur’s money go to John regardless of the choice?
Yes, John inherits Arthur’s satchel after Arthur’s death, regardless of whether Arthur went for the money or helped John escape. This includes any money Arthur had at the time.
2. Should I spend all of Arthur’s money before the end?
It’s recommended to spend Arthur’s money on items that John can inherit, such as clothes, weapons, and upgrades at the camp. This ensures that John starts the epilogue with valuable resources.
3. Is Arthur stronger than John in a fight?
The game suggests that Arthur is physically larger and a more skilled brawler than John, making him potentially superior in hand-to-hand combat.
4. Can John access Dutch’s hidden money?
Yes, John can find a chest left by Dutch containing a significant amount of money, implied to be part of the Blackwater heist money. He later shares this with Charles and Sadie.
5. Is there a secret ending where Arthur survives?
Unfortunately, there is no ending where Arthur survives. His death is a fixed point in the narrative.
6. Why does Dutch leave John the money?
Dutch leaves John the money as a sign of acknowledging his mistakes and Micah’s betrayal. It’s a form of atonement for his actions.
7. Who is more popular: Arthur or John?
While John was beloved in the first Red Dead Redemption, Arthur Morgan’s character has garnered immense popularity due to his complex personality and compelling story arc. Many now prefer Arthur over John.
8. Can John complete all the same activities as Arthur?
John can complete almost all of Arthur’s Stranger Missions, except for those specifically tied to Arthur’s past or relationships.
9. What determines the “best” ending for Arthur?
The “best” ending is generally considered to be the honorable ending where Arthur helps John escape, as it aligns with his redemption arc and provides a more emotionally satisfying conclusion.
10. Can John find Dutch’s chest if Arthur went for the money?
Yes, Dutch’s chest remains in Beaver Hollow regardless of Arthur’s choice, but John cannot interact with it.
11. Can I continue playing as Arthur after his death?
No, you cannot play as Arthur after his death without reverting to an earlier save. The game transitions to John Marston for the epilogue.
12. Can John reclaim the money stolen from Arthur at the pig farm?
Yes, John can return to the Aberdeen Pig Farm and reclaim the money stolen from Arthur, making it a useful strategy for players who want to ensure John starts with a significant sum.
13. Was Arthur a good or bad person?
Arthur is a complex character with both good and bad qualities. While he starts as a hardened outlaw, he gradually undergoes a transformation, showing remorse for his actions and ultimately striving for redemption.
14. Is it better to play with high or low honor in Red Dead Redemption 2?
The choice depends on player preference. High honor offers benefits such as discounts at stores, while low honor provides different interactions and opportunities. High Honor arguably provides the more satisfying ending and allows for a more full and complete realization of Arthur’s character.
15. Why did John never mention Arthur in the first Red Dead Redemption?
There are several theories: John may have been too grief-stricken to speak of Arthur, felt ashamed of Arthur’s sacrifice, or simply respected Arthur’s dying wish not to look back. All the reasons make sense, and no matter the combination of these things, it makes Arthur’s absence in the first game easier to understand.
In Conclusion
The choice between money and John isn’t just a gameplay decision; it’s a moral one that defines Arthur Morgan’s legacy. Choosing John not only delivers a more profound and emotionally resonant ending but also solidifies Arthur’s transformation from outlaw to hero. He will always be loved.
To understand more about the learning potential of games like Red Dead Redemption 2, explore the resources at the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.