Should I Buy Witcher 1 or 2? A Deep Dive for Aspiring Witchers
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’re venturing into the world of The Witcher, a land of monsters, magic, and morally gray choices. You’re probably wondering where to begin. The age-old question arises: Should you buy The Witcher 1 or The Witcher 2?
The definitive answer is The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings. While The Witcher 1 holds historical significance, The Witcher 2 offers a more refined and accessible experience for modern gamers. It boasts improved gameplay mechanics, a compelling narrative, and graphics that still hold up reasonably well today. Skipping The Witcher 1 won’t significantly detract from your understanding of the series, especially if you familiarize yourself with a story summary. The Witcher 2 provides a better entry point and a more enjoyable overall experience.
Why The Witcher 2 is the Better Starting Point
The Witcher 2 represents a significant leap forward in terms of gameplay and presentation. Here’s a breakdown of why it’s the recommended starting point:
- Improved Gameplay: The combat system in The Witcher 1 is often described as clunky and reliant on rhythmic clicking. The Witcher 2 features a more action-oriented and responsive combat system, which many find more engaging and less frustrating.
- Enhanced Graphics: While neither game boasts cutting-edge graphics by today’s standards, The Witcher 2 is visually superior to its predecessor. The environments are more detailed, the character models are more refined, and the overall aesthetic is more polished.
- More Focused Narrative: While both games have strong stories, The Witcher 2 delivers a more concise and impactful narrative. The choices you make in The Witcher 2 have significant consequences that shape the storyline in meaningful ways.
- Accessibility: The Witcher 2 is more forgiving for newcomers to the series. It gradually introduces the world, characters, and lore without overwhelming the player.
- Direct Lead-in to The Witcher 3: The Witcher 2 directly sets the stage for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Playing The Witcher 2 will provide you with a much better understanding of the political landscape, key characters, and overarching conflicts that drive the narrative of The Witcher 3.
The Witcher 1: A Historical Perspective
The Witcher 1, while important in the series’ history, suffers from several issues that make it less appealing to modern gamers.
- Clunky Mechanics: The combat is often cited as the game’s biggest flaw. The reliance on rhythm-based clicking can feel repetitive and unresponsive.
- Dated Graphics: The visuals haven’t aged well, and the character models and environments lack the detail found in later entries in the series.
- Lengthy Playtime: The Witcher 1 is a longer game than The Witcher 2, which might be off-putting for players who are eager to jump into The Witcher 3.
- Less Impactful Story: While the story is compelling, its events have less direct bearing on the overall narrative of the series compared to The Witcher 2.
That said, The Witcher 1 has its merits:
- Compelling Story: The narrative is well-written and explores complex themes, and it successfully establishes the world and lore of The Witcher.
- Atmosphere: The game captures the grim and gritty atmosphere of the books exceptionally well.
Conclusion
If you are new to the series, start with The Witcher 2. You can always circle back to The Witcher 1 later if you find yourself captivated by the world and lore.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Do I need to play The Witcher 1 and 2 before The Witcher 3?
No, you don’t need to play the first two games to enjoy The Witcher 3. The game does a decent job of introducing new players to the world and characters. However, playing The Witcher 2 will significantly enhance your understanding of the story and your appreciation for the returning characters and events.
2. Can I skip The Witcher 1 and just read a summary?
Yes, reading a summary of The Witcher 1 is a perfectly acceptable approach, especially if you are concerned about the game’s dated mechanics and graphics. It’ll give you the basic story beats without requiring a large time investment.
3. Is The Witcher 1 getting a remake?
Yes! CD Projekt Red has announced a remake of The Witcher 1. This will update the game with modern graphics, gameplay mechanics, and potentially expand on the original story. Keep an eye out for the release date!
4. Is The Witcher 2 shorter than The Witcher 1?
Yes, The Witcher 2 is generally shorter than The Witcher 1. Most players report completing The Witcher 2 in around 30-40 hours, while The Witcher 1 can take 40-60 hours or more.
5. Is The Witcher 2 worth playing in 2023?
Absolutely! Despite its age, The Witcher 2 holds up well and offers a compelling RPG experience. The story, characters, and world are still engaging, and the graphics are decent enough for most players.
6. Does The Witcher 2 play like The Witcher 1?
No, the gameplay in The Witcher 2 is completely different from The Witcher 1. The Witcher 2 features a more action-oriented combat system with freeflow movement, spells, and traps.
7. Is The Witcher 1 easy?
The difficulty of The Witcher 1 depends on your experience with RPGs. Normal difficulty can be relatively easy for experienced players, while hard difficulty requires a more strategic approach.
8. What happens if I start with The Witcher 3?
If you start with The Witcher 3, you’ll still be able to enjoy the game. It introduces the basics, but you’ll likely miss some nuances of the lore and character relationships. You’ll also be given the option to simulate choices made in The Witcher 2, allowing you to customize your experience to some extent.
9. Does The Witcher 1 carry over to The Witcher 2?
Yes, you can import a save file from The Witcher 1 into The Witcher 2. This will transfer some of your decisions and relationships, impacting the story in subtle ways.
10. Does The Witcher series follow the books closely?
The games are inspired by the books, but they are not direct adaptations. The games take place after the events of the final book and tell original stories within the same universe. CD Projekt Red worked with author Andrzej Sapkowski, but they also took creative liberties with the lore. To learn more about video games, check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
11. Why do some critics rank The Witcher 3 over The Witcher 2?
The Witcher 3 is often ranked higher due to its vast open world, stunning graphics, extensive content, and highly polished gameplay.
12. Is The Witcher 1’s story essential to understanding The Witcher 3?
While The Witcher 1 establishes the world and introduces some key characters, its story is not essential to understanding The Witcher 3. The events of The Witcher 2 have a much more direct impact on The Witcher 3’s narrative.
13. Are Quick Time Events (QTEs) a major problem in The Witcher 2?
The Witcher 2 does feature QTEs, but they are not as prevalent or intrusive as in some other games. Some players find them annoying, while others don’t mind them.
14. If I love the lore of The Witcher, should I still play The Witcher 1?
If you are deeply interested in the lore of The Witcher, The Witcher 1 can still be worth playing, despite its flaws. It offers unique insights into the world and its characters.
15. Where can I find good summaries and lore explanations for The Witcher series?
There are numerous online resources, including wikis, YouTube videos, and forum discussions, that offer detailed summaries of The Witcher 1 and in-depth explanations of the series’ lore. Use these resources to supplement your gameplay and deepen your understanding of the world. The Games Learning Society might have some articles to help you!