Should You Choose Natty or Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether to spend more time with Natsai Onai (Natty) or Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy is a common one among players. While the game doesn’t force you to choose one over the other for the majority of your playthrough, specific side quests and interactions can lean you towards forming a closer bond with one. The short answer is: it doesn’t significantly impact the main storyline or overall game outcome, but it does shape your personal experience and access to certain content. Neither choice is definitively “better,” it depends entirely on your playstyle, what you want from the narrative, and what spells you want to learn.
Exploring the Differences: Natty vs. Sebastian
Choosing to prioritize Natty or Sebastian mainly manifests in the side quests you undertake and the nature of the conversations you engage in. This choice doesn’t alter the main story’s trajectory or lead to drastically different endings. However, the experience of the game can feel quite different based on who you align yourself more closely with.
Natsai Onai (Natty): The Empathetic Explorer
- Focus: Natty’s questline is centered around uncovering the truth behind her mother’s past and fighting for justice. Her storyline typically involves more exploration, puzzle-solving, and helping vulnerable creatures.
- Moral Compass: Natty embodies a strong moral code. She is compassionate, brave, and always seeks to do what is right. If you value a character with integrity and a desire to help others, Natty might be a more appealing companion.
- Gameplay: Her quests often lead to new areas and challenges. Players who enjoy exploration and solving intricate puzzles will find her side missions engaging.
- No Dark Arts: Natty is firmly against the use of dark magic and will not teach you any unforgivable curses.
Sebastian Sallow: The Darkly Charismatic Slytherin
- Focus: Sebastian’s narrative is driven by his desire to save his twin sister, Anne, from a mysterious curse. His path leads him down a morally ambiguous road, with increasing reliance on darker magic.
- Moral Compass: Sebastian is a complex character, portrayed as both charming and troubled. He pushes the boundaries of what is considered acceptable, believing that the ends justify the means, sometimes involving morally questionable choices.
- Gameplay: His quests delve into the darker aspects of the magical world, featuring intense and dramatic scenarios. His side quests also allow you to learn dark curses.
- Access to Unforgivable Curses: The most significant draw towards Sebastian’s path is the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses: Crucio, Imperio, and Avada Kedavra. This is a crucial distinction for players who wish to experiment with these powerful spells. If you turn Sebastian in, you will lose the chance to learn these curses, except through DLC content or starting a new game.
Impact of Your Choices
- Hogsmeade Visit: Regardless of whether you choose to visit Hogsmeade with Natty or Sebastian, it does not have any significant effect on gameplay or story.
- The Unforgivable Curses: Choosing to follow Sebastian’s storyline allows you to learn and use the Unforgivable Curses, whereas aligning with Natty will not.
- Sebastian’s Fate: Your choice to turn Sebastian in after the climactic showdown with his uncle will dramatically alter your relationship with him, leading to his expulsion and unavailability for future quests. Turning him in is the only way to ensure he goes to Azkaban. If he isn’t turned in, he continues down his path into dark magic.
- Epilogue: If Sebastian is turned in, he will not be present in the epilogue of the story.
- No Romance: Regardless of who you prefer, there are no romantic options in the game.
Which Path Should You Choose?
Ultimately, the “right” choice depends on what you want from your Hogwarts Legacy experience.
- Choose Natty If: You prefer a more heroic, morally upright experience, enjoy exploration and puzzle-solving, and are not interested in using dark magic.
- Choose Sebastian If: You are drawn to morally ambiguous characters, want access to and experiment with the Unforgivable Curses, and are intrigued by a darker, more intense narrative.
There is no right or wrong choice. Enjoy playing the game how you see best. It is always fun to replay the game to see the different options and choices you could have made.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about choosing between Natty and Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy:
1. Does choosing Natty or Sebastian affect the main story ending?
No, choosing to spend more time with either Natty or Sebastian does not change the main storyline or the game’s ending. The overarching narrative remains the same, irrespective of your interactions with them.
2. Can I learn the Unforgivable Curses without Sebastian?
No, not in the base game. The only way to learn Crucio, Imperio, and Avada Kedavra is through Sebastian’s questline. After turning Sebastian in, the only way to learn them is by playing the Dark Arts Battle Arena via the Deluxe Edition or the Dark Arts Pack DLC or by restarting the game.
3. Is Sebastian evil in Hogwarts Legacy?
Sebastian is a morally complex character, not definitively evil. While he does make bad choices and commit terrible acts, his actions are driven by a desire to save his sister. He is portrayed as a tragic character who delves into dark magic due to his desperation.
4. Can I stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?
No, the confrontation and Sebastian’s killing of his uncle are fixed events in the story. The only choice you have is whether to turn him in to the authorities afterward.
5. Does turning in Sebastian affect the game?
Yes, turning in Sebastian results in his expulsion from Hogwarts. This means he will no longer be available for side quests, and you’ll miss out on certain interactions and content. If he has not taught you the unforgivable curses you will lose that opportunity. He will also be absent from the epilogue.
6. Can I have a romantic relationship with either Natty or Sebastian?
No, there are no romance options in Hogwarts Legacy. All relationships with other characters, including Natty and Sebastian, remain strictly platonic.
7. What is the “good” ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
The “good” ending is achieved by responding with “I intend to keep it contained here” when speaking to Professor Fig about the ancient magic. Your second response should be “I shall keep it secret forever”.
8. Does letting Sebastian take the relic have any impact?
No, your choice to let Sebastian take the relic during “In The Shadow Of Time” does not affect the story or outcome in any meaningful way.
9. Can I visit Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, but only briefly and as part of a specific quest, and it’s exclusive to players who choose a certain house.
10. How old is Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
Sebastian is 11 years old when he begins attending Hogwarts. The game takes place during his fifth year at school.
11. Can you ignore Sebastian entirely in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, you can choose to not complete his quests, but this would mean missing out on learning the Unforgivable Curses and experiencing his unique storyline.
12. Is it worth learning the Unforgivable Curses?
That depends on your playstyle. The Unforgivable Curses are powerful but come with a moral cost. Whether they are “worth it” is a subjective decision for each player.
13. Does my House choice affect my relationship with Natty or Sebastian?
Your house choice doesn’t significantly affect your relationship with Natty or Sebastian in the main story. They will be available regardless of which house you choose during character creation.
14. What are the consequences of choosing to not turn Sebastian in?
If you choose not to turn Sebastian in, he will continue down his path with dark magic, and you will continue his quest line which may include further questionable acts. It will also mean you will get to learn Avada Kedavra, something that is important to a lot of players.
15. Does the game have multiple endings depending on my choices?
While choices like turning in Sebastian or not and your response to Professor Fig do impact the game, they do not lead to multiple radically different endings to the main story. There are just different epilogues based on whether you choose to turn him in or not.