Should I Escape with Madanach in Skyrim? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether or not to escape Cidhna Mine with Madanach, the King in Rags, in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is a pivotal one, impacting not only the immediate questline but also your character’s relationship with the Forsworn and the citizens of Markarth. The definitive answer? It depends on your roleplaying intentions and desired long-term consequences. Escaping with Madanach offers unique rewards and alliances, but also comes with moral implications. Analyze your character’s alignment and goals. If you are after loot and can justify the means, go ahead, if not, consider the other route.
Understanding the Stakes
The “No One Escapes Cidhna Mine” quest presents a moral dilemma: cooperate with a ruthless criminal to secure your freedom or take matters into your own hands, potentially sacrificing unique rewards. Understanding the consequences of each choice is crucial. Siding with Madanach essentially means aligning with the Forsworn, a group known for their brutal tactics and animosity towards the Nords of Skyrim.
Consequences of Escaping with Madanach
Escaping with Madanach has several immediate and long-term consequences:
- Friendly Forsworn: The Forsworn at Druadach Redoubt, where Madanach flees, will become friendly. This allows you to explore the camp without hostility.
- Armor of the Old Gods: You will receive the Armor of the Old Gods, a unique set of light armor with powerful enchantments, as a reward from Madanach after escaping.
- Markarth’s Hostility: While escaping with Madanach gets you a pardon for your crimes within Cidhna Mine, it doesn’t necessarily absolve you of all your crimes. Markarth guards may remain hostile if you had a previous bounty.
- Reputation with Nords: Siding with the Forsworn may negatively impact your standing with some Nord characters, especially those with strong nationalist views.
- Roleplaying Opportunities: Aligning with Madanach opens up unique roleplaying opportunities, allowing you to explore the motivations and culture of the Forsworn.
Consequences of Killing Madanach
Alternatively, choosing to kill Madanach also has significant outcomes:
- Loot the Armor of the Old Gods: You can loot the Armor of the Old Gods from his corpse.
- Pardon and Silver-Blood Ring: Upon escaping, Thonar Silver-Blood will pardon your crimes and reward you with the Silver-Blood Family Ring.
- Improved Reputation with Markarth: Eliminating Madanach can improve your standing with the citizens of Markarth.
- Moral High Ground: For characters with a strong moral compass, killing Madanach may be the preferred option, as it aligns with upholding law and order.
Making the Right Choice for Your Character
The “right” choice ultimately depends on your character’s alignment, goals, and playstyle.
- Evil Characters: For characters who embrace chaos and violence, siding with Madanach aligns perfectly.
- Neutral Characters: Neutral characters may weigh the pros and cons of each choice, considering the potential rewards and long-term consequences.
- Good Characters: Good characters may struggle with the decision, as both options involve morally questionable actions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Madanach good or bad?
Madanach is a morally complex character. He is considered a minor antagonist, however, his actions are driven by the desire to reclaim his people’s homeland from Nord oppression. While he employs violence, he sees it as a necessary means to an end. The Games Learning Society, like many academic organizations, appreciates that such difficult choices are found within gaming.
2. Can you become friendly with the Forsworn in general?
No. Siding with Madanach only makes the Forsworn at Druadach Redoubt friendly. Other Forsworn groups will remain hostile.
3. Can you get the Armor of the Old Gods if you kill Madanach?
Yes, you can loot the Armor of the Old Gods from Madanach’s corpse if you choose to kill him.
4. What happens if you give Markarth to the Stormcloaks?
In the broader context of the Civil War questline, giving Markarth to the Stormcloaks is usually a scripted event when a trade is made to favor the Stormcloaks. This has consequences for the overall balance of power in Skyrim.
5. Is the abandoned house in Markarth safe to store items?
Yes, the abandoned house in Markarth is safe for storage as the containers do not reset. However, be aware of the Daedric presence and its implications.
6. What happens if you kill Madanach?
If you kill Madanach, you will be pardoned for your crimes upon escaping Cidhna Mine and receive the Silver-Blood Family Ring from Thonar Silver-Blood.
7. Should I save Margret in Markarth?
Saving Margret can be helpful in later quests related to investigating the marketplace attack. It also provides a small reward and satisfaction for doing a good deed.
8. Should I save the woman in Markarth from Weylin?
Yes, saving her will result in her giving you a reward and potentially opening up further quest opportunities.
9. Can I save Eltrys?
It is possible to save Eltrys by various means, including completing the Cidhna Mine quest or skipping it entirely and dealing with the Silver-Bloods directly.
10. Where does Madanach go after you free him?
After being freed, Madanach goes to Druadach Redoubt, where he establishes a friendly Forsworn encampment if he survives the escape from the mine.
11. How do you beat Madanach if you choose to kill him?
The trick is to lure him away from the other prisoners and kill him quickly with a sneak attack, ideally using a dagger. Then loot his body and escape.
12. Why should I kill Madanach?
Killing Madanach aligns with upholding the law and order of the Nords. For characters who prioritize justice and moral purity, this is a justifiable choice. Furthermore, it allows you to gain the favor of the Silver-Blood family.
13. What is the best way to escape Cidhna Mine?
Whether you side with Madanach or kill him, focus on acquiring the necessary equipment (armor, weapons, potions) within the mine to ensure a successful escape. Sneak and combat skills are also crucial.
14. Am I supposed to go to jail in Markarth?
Yes, being imprisoned in Cidhna Mine is a mandatory part of the Forsworn Conspiracy questline.
15. What happens if I side with the Forsworn in Cidhna Mine?
Siding with the Forsworn in Cidhna Mine makes that particular group friendly and allows you to receive the Armor of the Old Gods. However, most Forsworn in Skyrim will remain hostile. GamesLearningSociety.org offers additional educational resources about game narratives and moral decision making.
Ultimately, the decision to escape with Madanach is a matter of personal preference, guided by your roleplaying style and desired gameplay experience. Understanding the consequences of each choice allows you to make a decision that aligns with your character’s values and goals.