Should I Finish The Witcher 1 Before Playing The Witcher 2? A Witcher Veteran’s Perspective
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer? Yes, absolutely, you should finish The Witcher 1 before diving into The Witcher 2. While The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings does a decent job of onboarding new players, skipping the original robs you of crucial context, character development, and a deeper appreciation for the world of The Witcher. Think of it like skipping the first book in a fantasy trilogy – you can do it, but you’ll miss out on nuances and emotional connections that enhance the overall experience. Let’s delve into why.
Why Experiencing The Witcher 1 First Matters
The Witcher 1 is more than just a precursor to its sequel; it’s the foundation upon which the entire saga is built. Here’s why you should prioritize it:
- Character Introduction and Development: The first game meticulously introduces you to Geralt of Rivia, his personality, his code, and the complex relationships he forges with characters like Triss Merigold, Yennefer of Vengerberg (albeit through memory restoration), and Dandelion. These relationships carry significant weight in The Witcher 2 and beyond. Jumping straight to the sequel means missing out on the organic evolution of these bonds.
- World-Building and Lore: The world of The Witcher is rich and detailed, steeped in Slavic mythology and folklore. The Witcher 1 lays the groundwork for understanding the political landscape, the power dynamics between humans, elves, dwarves, and other races, and the general atmosphere of moral ambiguity that defines the series. This foundational knowledge significantly enriches your experience in The Witcher 2.
- Choices and Consequences: While The Witcher 2 acknowledges some choices made in The Witcher 1 through a save game import feature (which isn’t always perfect), experiencing those choices firsthand in the original game adds a layer of personal investment. You’ll understand the why behind the consequences, not just the consequences themselves.
- Gameplay Familiarity: While the combat systems are vastly different between the two games (more on that later), The Witcher 1 introduces you to the core mechanics of potion brewing, monster hunting, and making difficult moral decisions – all crucial aspects of the Witcher experience.
- Emotional Resonance: The events of The Witcher 1, particularly the amnesia storyline and the re-emergence of the Wild Hunt, have a profound impact on Geralt’s psyche. Witnessing these events firsthand allows you to better understand his motivations and struggles in The Witcher 2.
Addressing Common Concerns
Many players are hesitant to play The Witcher 1 due to its age and somewhat clunky gameplay mechanics. Here are some counterarguments:
- Patience is Key: Yes, the combat system in The Witcher 1 is dated, and the animations can be stiff. However, with a little patience and willingness to adapt, you can overcome these limitations and appreciate the game’s strengths. Focus on strategic positioning, utilizing the correct combat styles, and mastering potion brewing.
- Mods Can Help: The modding community has created numerous enhancements for The Witcher 1, including improved textures, bug fixes, and even gameplay tweaks. Exploring these mods can significantly improve your overall experience.
- Story Over Graphics: Remember that you’re playing The Witcher 1 for its story, its characters, and its world-building. Don’t let the dated graphics deter you from experiencing a truly remarkable narrative. Focus on the dialogue, the atmosphere, and the weight of your decisions.
Is it EVER Okay to Skip The Witcher 1?
While I strongly recommend playing The Witcher 1 first, there are a few exceptional circumstances where skipping it might be acceptable:
- Extreme Time Constraints: If you’re facing an absolute time crunch and only have a limited window to play The Witcher 2 before something prevents you from continuing (e.g., a borrowed game or a temporary subscription), then skipping the first game might be a necessary evil. However, I still encourage you to at least read a detailed synopsis of The Witcher 1‘s story.
- Complete Aversion to Older Games: If you have a strong aversion to older games with dated graphics and gameplay mechanics, and you know you simply won’t be able to tolerate The Witcher 1, then skipping it might be preferable to forcing yourself to play through something you’ll ultimately hate. Again, a detailed synopsis is crucial in this case.
- Already Familiar with the Lore: If you’ve already read all the Witcher books or consumed a significant amount of lore through other media (e.g., the Netflix series, graphic novels), you might be able to get away with skipping the first game. However, keep in mind that the game’s narrative diverges from the books in certain areas, so you’ll still be missing out on some unique content.
The Bottom Line
Despite its age and some gameplay quirks, The Witcher 1 remains a vital part of the Witcher experience. Playing it before The Witcher 2 will significantly enhance your understanding of the world, the characters, and the overarching narrative. Don’t skip it if you can avoid it. You’ll be rewarded with a richer, more immersive, and ultimately more satisfying journey. Also consider, if you are involved in video game design, consider the work being done at the Games Learning Society to see if there is any relevant information or events which you can use for your learning, education, and development.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the nuances of playing The Witcher 1 and The Witcher 2:
1. Is the combat in The Witcher 1 really that bad?
It’s… different. It’s not action-oriented like The Witcher 2 or The Witcher 3. Instead, it’s a rhythmic, timing-based system where you click to attack at the right moment when Geralt is in the correct stance (fast, strong, or group). It takes some getting used to, but it can be surprisingly engaging once you understand it.
2. Will my choices in The Witcher 1 significantly impact The Witcher 2?
Yes, to a degree. The Witcher 2 allows you to import your save game from The Witcher 1, and certain choices, such as who you sided with in specific quests, will have consequences in the sequel. However, the impact isn’t game-changing.
3. How long does it take to beat The Witcher 1?
On average, it takes around 40-50 hours to complete The Witcher 1‘s main story and a decent amount of side quests. Completionists can easily spend 60+ hours in the game.
4. Is there a “best” ending to The Witcher 1?
There’s no objectively “best” ending. Each ending has its own implications and consequences, and the choice is ultimately up to you.
5. Should I play The Witcher 1 with a controller or keyboard and mouse?
The Witcher 1 was originally designed for keyboard and mouse, and that’s generally the recommended way to play it. However, some players have successfully used controllers with the help of mods.
6. Is there a difficulty setting I should choose for my first playthrough of The Witcher 1?
Normal difficulty is a good starting point for most players. You can always adjust the difficulty later if you find it too easy or too hard.
7. What are the best mods for The Witcher 1?
Some popular mods for The Witcher 1 include the Rise of the White Wolf mod (which overhauls the graphics and gameplay), the Scabbard Mod (which adds scabbards for Geralt’s swords), and various texture packs.
8. Does The Witcher 2 re-cap the story of The Witcher 1?
The Witcher 2 provides a brief overview of the events of The Witcher 1 during the prologue, but it’s not a comprehensive re-cap. It assumes that you already have some familiarity with the characters and the world.
9. Are there any important characters I should pay close attention to in The Witcher 1?
Yes, pay close attention to Triss Merigold, Yennefer of Vengerberg (even though she’s mostly absent), Siegfried, Yaevinn, and Azar Javed. Their actions and motivations have significant consequences in The Witcher 2.
10. Is it necessary to read the Witcher books before playing the games?
No, it’s not necessary, but it can definitely enhance your understanding and appreciation of the world and the characters. The games are technically a sequel to the books, but they tell their own self-contained story.
11. What are some things I should avoid doing in The Witcher 1?
Avoid rushing through the dialogue, skipping side quests, and neglecting potion brewing. These are all essential aspects of the Witcher experience.
12. How does Geralt lose his memory in The Witcher universe?
Geralt’s amnesia is a key plot point in The Witcher 1, caused by a traumatic event at the end of the Witcher book series. The games explore his struggle to regain his memories and piece together his past.
13. Is The Witcher 2 more difficult than The Witcher 1?
In some ways, yes. The Witcher 2 features a more demanding combat system and more complex quests. However, it’s also more forgiving in some areas, such as potion brewing.
14. Where can I find a good summary of The Witcher 1‘s story if I decide to skip it?
There are numerous websites and YouTube videos that provide detailed summaries of The Witcher 1‘s story. Just be sure to choose a reputable source and avoid spoilers for The Witcher 2 and The Witcher 3.
15. Is it better to play The Witcher 2 before watching the Netflix series?
It’s a matter of personal preference. Playing The Witcher 2 first can give you a deeper understanding of the characters and the world, which can enhance your enjoyment of the series. However, watching the series first might pique your interest in playing the games. Consider learning more from organizations such as GamesLearningSociety.org.