Pokémon Throwdown: Black & White vs. Black 2 & White 2 – Which Generation 5 Game Should You Choose?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’re thinking about diving back into the Unova region, huh? Excellent choice! Pokémon Black and White (BW) and their direct sequels, Black 2 and White 2 (BW2), represent some of the series’ most ambitious and beloved entries. But with four options on the table, deciding which game to pick can feel like navigating a tricky Elite Four battle. The short answer? Start with Black 2 or White 2. They offer a refined experience, a more diverse Pokémon roster, and compelling new content. However, the longer answer, as always, is more nuanced and depends on your individual preferences.
Why Black 2 and White 2 Usually Win the Day
Let’s break down why BW2 generally comes out on top.
-
Enhanced Gameplay and Content: BW2 are true sequels, taking place two years after the events of BW. This isn’t just a rehash with a few minor tweaks. The Unova region has changed, with new towns to explore in the western part of the map. You’ll also find new characters, a fresh storyline, and exciting features like the Pokémon World Tournament and Pokéstar Studios. These additions add significant replayability and depth.
-
Expanded Pokémon Roster: One of the biggest criticisms of BW was its initial focus on only introducing new Generation 5 Pokémon. This meant players had to wait until the post-game to encounter Pokémon from previous generations. BW2 address this by incorporating Pokémon from Kanto, Johto, Hoenn, and Sinnoh into the early game. This vastly improves team-building options and makes for a much more varied and engaging adventure from the get-go.
-
Improved Pacing and Difficulty: While BW were not particularly difficult, some players found their pacing to be a bit uneven. BW2 smooth out the experience, offering a more balanced and enjoyable progression. They also introduce a Challenge Mode (initially only accessible via keys), which provides a significant difficulty boost for veteran players seeking a greater challenge.
-
Nostalgic Charm with Modern Improvements: BW2 manage to retain the charm and strengths of their predecessors while incorporating quality-of-life improvements and expanded content. It’s the best of both worlds for long-time Pokémon fans and newcomers alike.
Should You Skip Black and White Entirely?
Not necessarily! There are a couple of reasons why you might still want to consider playing the original Black and White, even if you ultimately choose to start with BW2:
-
Story Considerations: While BW2 can be enjoyed as standalone games, they are sequels. Understanding the events and characters of BW will enhance your appreciation of the narrative in BW2. The Memory Link feature allows you to unlock flashbacks that provide context and backstory, further enriching the experience. To get the full picture, consider playing the first games.
-
A Purist Experience: Some players appreciate the original BW for their bold decision to focus solely on new Pokémon. If you want to experience Unova as it was initially intended, with a roster of entirely unfamiliar creatures, then BW might be worth exploring.
Choosing Between Black 2 and White 2
As with all dual-version Pokémon games, the primary differences between Black 2 and White 2 come down to version-exclusive Pokémon and minor map variations. Here’s a quick rundown:
-
Pokémon Exclusives: This is the biggest factor for most players. Black 2 features Pokémon like Latios, while White 2 features Latias. Research the version-exclusive Pokémon for both games to see which list appeals to you more. Remember, you can always trade with other players to obtain the Pokémon you want, but having them available naturally in your game is often more convenient.
-
Legendary Pokémon: In Black 2 you get Zekrom, and in White 2 you get Reshiram. If you missed either of the original games, this is a good way to still catch one of these.
-
Map Variations: There are minor differences in the layout of certain areas, such as Route 4 and Reversal Mountain. These variations are generally cosmetic and don’t significantly impact gameplay.
-
Location Exclusives: Black City is a location exclusive to Black 2, while White Forest is exclusive to White 2.
Recommendation
Given all factors, a safe choice would be to start with Black 2 or White 2 for a better experience and then after playing either of those games, you can then determine if you want to play the original games.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Are Black 2 and White 2 direct sequels to Black and White?
Yes, Black 2 and White 2 are direct sequels set two years after the events of Black and White. The storyline continues, and returning characters make appearances.
2. Do I need to play Black/White before Black 2/White 2?
While not strictly necessary, playing Black and White first will enhance your understanding and appreciation of the story in Black 2 and White 2. The Memory Link feature allows you to unlock flashbacks that provide context.
3. What are the main differences between Black 2 and White 2?
The main differences are version-exclusive Pokémon and minor map variations, such as the layout of Route 4 and Reversal Mountain. You get Zekrom in Black 2 and Reshiram in White 2.
4. Which version has the better Pokémon?
This is subjective and depends on your preferences. White 2 has been argued to have better Pokemon, excluding legendaries, though trades are possible.
5. What is the Pokémon World Tournament?
The Pokémon World Tournament is a new feature in Black 2 and White 2 that allows you to battle trainers from previous Pokémon games, including Gym Leaders and Champions.
6. What is Pokéstar Studios?
Pokéstar Studios is another new feature in Black 2 and White 2 where you can create and star in your own movies with Pokémon.
7. How do I access Challenge Mode in Black 2 and White 2?
Challenge Mode is initially unlocked by obtaining a Challenge Key, which can be transferred between games. You can obtain one if someone has already beat the game on challenge mode.
8. Can I trade Pokémon between Black/White and Black 2/White 2?
Yes, you can trade Pokémon between Black, White, Black 2, and White 2.
9. Why are Black 2 and White 2 so expensive?
Black 2 and White 2 are relatively rare and sought after by collectors, leading to higher prices on the secondary market. Additionally, unopened copies or special editions are highly valued.
10. Is it harder to play Black or White?
There is no definitive answer, but generally Black or White are not harder than one another.
11. Are the starter Pokémon different in Black 2 and White 2?
No, the starter Pokémon are the same in both Black 2 and White 2: Snivy (Grass), Tepig (Fire), and Oshawott (Water).
12. Which starter Pokémon is the best choice in Black 2?
Oshawott is considered a solid choice due to its balanced stats and the Water type’s defensive advantages. Tepig is also a good choice, being strong against the Bug gym.
13. What does Memory Link do?
Memory Link allows you to connect your save data from Black/White to Black 2/White 2, unlocking flashbacks and providing additional story context.
14. Is it possible to catch Zekrom in White 2 and Reshiram in Black 2?
Yes, in Black 2 you can catch Zekrom and in White 2 you can catch Reshiram.
15. What makes Pokémon Black and White 2 stand out as games?
Pokémon Black and White stand out as games because they are direct sequels, feature a changed Unova region, have new features such as the Pokémon World Tournament and Pokestar Studios, and have an improved Pokémon roster. If you are interested in exploring how games can be used to improve learning, visit the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.
Choosing between Pokémon Black/White and Black 2/White 2 ultimately depends on your personal preferences. However, for most players, Black 2 and White 2 offer a superior experience with their expanded content, improved pacing, and enhanced Pokémon roster. So, dust off your Nintendo DS or 3DS, pick your poison, and prepare to return to the Unova region for an unforgettable Pokémon adventure! Happy gaming!