Should You Give Rogier the Black Knifeprint in Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The answer, unequivocally, is yes. Giving Rogier the Black Knifeprint in Elden Ring is crucial for progressing his questline, unlocking valuable lore about the Night of the Black Knives, and ultimately obtaining his powerful Rogier’s Rapier +8. Withholding it provides absolutely no benefit.
Why Handing Over the Black Knifeprint is Essential
Rogier, the sorcerer found in Stormveil Castle’s chapel, is an intriguing character connected to some of the most significant events in the Lands Between’s history. His quest is tied to the assassination of Godwyn the Golden during the Night of the Black Knives. Giving him the Black Knifeprint, obtained from the Black Knife Catacombs in Liurnia of the Lakes, is the catalyst that propels his story forward.
Unlocking Rogier’s Lore and Triggering Dialogue
Presenting Rogier with the Knifeprint initiates a series of dialogues where he delves deeper into his research about the Night of the Black Knives. He begins to piece together the events leading up to Godwyn’s death, the involvement of the Black Knife Assassins, and the larger conspiracy surrounding the shattering of the Elden Ring. Without this vital piece of evidence, Rogier remains stagnant, unable to provide further insight into this crucial piece of Elden Ring’s lore. His knowledge is critical for understanding the motives of several key characters and the overall narrative.
Advancing Rogier’s Questline and Obtaining Rogier’s Rapier
The most tangible benefit of giving Rogier the Knifeprint is that it advances his questline. After some time (usually triggered by progressing through other areas of the game and resting at multiple Sites of Grace), Rogier will fall into a deep sleep. Examining him at this point allows you to obtain Rogier’s Bell Bearing (which unlocks his inventory for purchase at the Twin Maiden Husks) and Rogier’s Rapier +8.
Rogier’s Rapier is a fantastic weapon, especially for Intelligence-focused builds. It comes pre-equipped with the Glintstone Pebble weapon skill, allowing you to easily cast sorceries at range. Furthermore, it has an extremely high critical damage multiplier, making it deadly for staggering enemies. The fact that it’s a +8 weapon early in the game makes it incredibly powerful. It also has inherent magic scaling, making it a viable option throughout much of the game. The Rapier scales primarily with Dexterity and Intelligence, making it a great fit for many builds.
Understanding the Consequences of NOT Giving the Knifeprint
There are no benefits to withholding the Black Knifeprint from Rogier. He will remain in his initial dialogue state, offering no new information and remaining static. You will miss out on crucial lore reveals, the progression of his character arc, and the chance to acquire his powerful weapon and Bell Bearing. Holding onto the Knifeprint serves absolutely no purpose and actively prevents you from experiencing a significant part of Elden Ring’s narrative.
Rogier’s Connection to Ranni the Witch
Giving Rogier the Knifeprint ultimately sets you on the path to Ranni the Witch’s questline. Through his dialogue, Rogier reveals a potential connection between Ranni and the Night of the Black Knives. This revelation acts as a narrative bridge, encouraging the Tarnished to seek out Ranni at Ranni’s Rise in Liurnia of the Lakes. Completing Ranni’s questline is one of the primary endgame paths, and Rogier’s information is crucial to unlocking it. It also uncovers the story of the Fingerslayer Blade, a critical item in Ranni’s story.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Where can I find the Black Knifeprint?
The Black Knifeprint is located in the Black Knife Catacombs, found in the northeastern part of Liurnia of the Lakes. You’ll need to navigate the catacombs, defeat the Cemetery Shade boss, and open the door at the back of the boss room. The Black Knifeprint is inside.
2. When should I give Rogier the Black Knifeprint?
You can give it to him as soon as you obtain it. There is no reason to delay. Talk to him in the chapel of Stormveil Castle and select the dialogue option to show him the Black Knifeprint.
3. What happens if I kill Rogier before giving him the Black Knifeprint?
If you kill Rogier, you will miss out on his questline entirely. His Bell Bearing will drop, allowing you to purchase his sorceries from the Twin Maiden Husks, but you’ll lose the opportunity to obtain Rogier’s Rapier and uncover the unique lore associated with his quest.
4. Is Rogier’s Rapier a good weapon?
Yes, especially for Intelligence-focused builds. It has high critical damage, inherent magic scaling, and comes pre-equipped with the Glintstone Pebble weapon skill. Its starting +8 upgrade level makes it incredibly powerful early in the game.
5. Does Rogier’s Rapier scale with Intelligence?
Yes, Rogier’s Rapier scales primarily with Dexterity and Intelligence, making it ideal for characters who invest in these stats.
6. What triggers Rogier to fall asleep?
Rogier falls asleep after you have shown him the Black Knifeprint and progressed through other areas of the game. Resting at multiple Sites of Grace and progressing through areas such as Raya Lucaria Academy often triggers this event. Persistence is key; return to him periodically after major milestones.
7. What happens after Rogier falls asleep?
After Rogier falls asleep, examine him to receive Rogier’s Bell Bearing and Rogier’s Rapier +8. You can then give the Bell Bearing to the Twin Maiden Husks at the Roundtable Hold to unlock Rogier’s sorceries for purchase.
8. Can I still complete Ranni’s questline if I miss Rogier’s quest?
Yes, but you will miss some crucial lore and context regarding Ranni’s involvement in the Night of the Black Knives. While it’s not essential, it definitely enhances the narrative experience.
9. Is Rogier’s quest connected to Fia’s questline?
While they don’t directly intertwine, they both relate to the death of Godwyn the Golden. Rogier investigates the circumstances of his death, while Fia seeks to restore his life. They offer different perspectives on the same pivotal event.
10. What is the Night of the Black Knives?
The Night of the Black Knives was a significant event where a group of assassins, known as the Black Knife Assassins, murdered Godwyn the Golden, a demigod and son of Queen Marika. This event triggered the Shattering of the Elden Ring.
11. Who are the Black Knife Assassins?
The Black Knife Assassins were a group of assassins, all women, who used weapons imbued with the Rune of Death to assassinate Godwyn the Golden. They are believed to have been led by Ranni the Witch.
12. Where can I find more information about the Night of the Black Knives?
Information about the Night of the Black Knives can be gleaned from various sources, including Rogier’s dialogue, item descriptions (especially those related to Black Knife Assassins and weapons), and environmental storytelling throughout the game.
13. Is Rogier a friendly NPC?
Yes, Rogier is a friendly NPC who provides valuable information and assistance to the Tarnished. He poses no threat and is always willing to share his knowledge.
14. What are the benefits of using Rogier’s sorceries?
Rogier’s sorceries are generally focused on melee combat and offer unique offensive options. They can be effective for both PvE and PvP combat. While his stock might not be the most diverse, some spells like Glintblade Phalanx are excellent.
15. If I give Rogier the Black Knifeprint, will it disappear from my inventory?
Yes, giving Rogier the Black Knifeprint removes it from your inventory, similar to giving items to other NPCs in the game to advance their questlines. It’s a key item specifically for triggering his quest.
In conclusion, providing Rogier with the Black Knifeprint is a straightforward and essential decision in Elden Ring. It unlocks crucial lore, progresses his questline, and grants access to his powerful Rapier. There is absolutely no reason to withhold this information from him. Embrace the lore, claim the weapon, and delve deeper into the mysteries of the Lands Between.