Should You Give the Weathered Dagger to D in Elden Ring? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, absolutely, you should give the Weathered Dagger to D, Hunter of the Dead. This action is crucial for progressing Fia’s questline and unlocking significant content within Elden Ring. While it leads to a tragic event – D’s death – it’s a necessary step to experience the full narrative and obtain valuable rewards, including access to a hidden boss and an alternative ending. The consequences of this decision are impactful, shaping the story in significant ways, but ultimately, it’s a doorway to richer gameplay.
Understanding the Weathered Dagger and its Significance
The Weathered Dagger is an item you receive from Fia after progressing through a portion of her initial dialogue at the Roundtable Hold. She asks you to find the dagger’s rightful owner, hinting at a hidden purpose and a connection to the figures surrounding the Lands Between. This quest item is inextricably linked to Darian, the Hunter of the Dead, an NPC dedicated to eradicating Those Who Live in Death. The intertwined narrative of Fia and D is a microcosm of the broader themes of death, rebirth, and the conflicting factions vying for control.
The Consequences of Your Choice
Giving the dagger to D initiates a chain of events. Upon returning to the Roundtable Hold after resting or teleporting away, you’ll discover a new room has opened near the blacksmith, Master Hewg. Inside, you’ll find D murdered and Fia gone, signaling the next phase of her quest. This act violates the unspoken rule of the Roundtable Hold, where violence is forbidden, setting off a ripple effect that influences the fates of several characters. The significance of this choice isn’t just about progressing Fia’s questline it involves themes that GamesLearningSociety.org explores. The repercussions also lead you to D’s twin brother.
Navigating Fia’s Questline After D’s Demise
Following D’s murder, you’ll encounter his twin brother near the aqueduct leading to the Valiant Gargoyle boss fight in Nokron, Eternal City. Speaking to him, you’ll have the option to give him D’s Twinned Armor set. Doing so sets him on a path of revenge. This action isn’t strictly necessary to complete Fia’s questline, but it dramatically alters the ending. If you give D’s brother the armor, he will eventually kill Fia within her dream. This action impacts NPC dialogue but doesn’t prevent access to Fia’s ending. Even after D’s death, you must navigate Deeproot Depths, battle a boss, and ultimately interact with a sleeping Fia to continue.
The Rewards and Benefits
Despite the grim circumstances, pursuing Fia’s questline offers substantial rewards. Firstly, it leads to an alternate ending, the “Age of Duskborn” ending, which is thematically relevant to the lore surrounding death and rebirth in the Elden Ring. This ending provides a different perspective on the cycle of the Elden Ring and the Greater Will’s influence. Secondly, completing Fia’s quest grants access to unique weapons, armor, and incantations related to the concept of “Those Who Live in Death.” These items can significantly enhance certain character builds and offer a different approach to combat. Furthermore, engaging with the narrative offers a deeper understanding of the lore and motivations of various characters.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens if I don’t give the Weathered Dagger to D?
If you choose not to give the Weathered Dagger to D, Fia’s questline will stall, preventing you from accessing key areas, boss fights, and the “Age of Duskborn” ending. This limits your overall experience and locks you out of unique rewards.
2. Is there a way to save D?
Unfortunately, there is no known way to prevent D’s death. It is a scripted event that occurs after giving him the Weathered Dagger. His death is integral to progressing Fia’s questline.
3. Where do I find D after getting the Weathered Dagger?
D is typically found in the Roundtable Hold, usually near the table where you first meet him. He may move to different locations within the hold, but he generally remains accessible for dialogue.
4. How does Fia kill D without drawing a weapon in the Roundtable Hold?
It’s implied that Fia uses some form of unseen force or power related to Those Who Live in Death to kill D. It’s a violation of the sacred law of the hold, but her methods circumvent the explicit prohibition of drawing weapons.
5. What is the significance of the Twinned Armor set?
The Twinned Armor set belonged to D and his twin brother. Giving it to D’s brother allows him to seek revenge on Fia, impacting her questline later in the game, but not preventing the ending. It provides a narrative choice with consequences.
6. Does giving the Twinned Armor to D’s brother prevent me from getting Fia’s ending?
No, giving the Twinned Armor to D’s brother does not prevent you from obtaining Fia’s ending. While he kills her within her dream, it doesn’t negate the progress already made in her questline.
7. Where can I find D’s brother?
You can find D’s brother near the aqueduct leading to the Valiant Gargoyle boss fight in Nokron, Eternal City, after D’s death.
8. What are the benefits of letting Fia hold me?
Letting Fia hold you provides the Baldachin’s Blessing, an item that temporarily increases your poise, allowing you to withstand more hits without being staggered. However, it also temporarily reduces your maximum HP.
9. Is Fia evil?
Fia’s motivations are complex. She seeks to protect Those Who Live in Death and give Godwyn the Golden a second life as the Prince of Death. Her actions may be morally ambiguous, but she’s not necessarily inherently evil.
10. Who is Godwyn the Golden?
Godwyn the Golden was the first demigod to die in the Lands Between, his soul killed while his body remained alive. This event triggered the creation of Those Who Live in Death, beings that exist outside the natural cycle of life and death.
11. What is the Age of Duskborn ending?
The “Age of Duskborn” ending involves restoring the Elden Ring with the Mending Rune of the Death-Prince, ushering in an era where death is acknowledged as a natural part of the cycle, offering a place for Those Who Live in Death within the world.
12. Can I still fight Fortissax if I kill Fia?
No, you cannot fight Fortissax if you kill Fia. You encounter Fortissax within Fia’s dream after interacting with her sleeping body in Deeproot Depths. Killing her beforehand prevents access to this encounter.
13. Why does Fia want to resurrect Godwyn?
Fia believes that giving Godwyn a second life as the Prince of Death will provide a leader and protector for Those Who Live in Death, offering them a place in the world and challenging the control of the Greater Will.
14. What are Those Who Live in Death?
Those Who Live in Death are undead beings created as a result of Godwyn’s incomplete death. They are considered an abomination by the Golden Order and are hunted by individuals like D.
15. Does my choice in dialogue with Fia affect the ending?
While specific dialogue choices don’t drastically alter the outcome, they do provide context and insight into Fia’s motivations and the overall lore. Engaging with her dialogue is crucial for fully understanding the story.
In conclusion, giving the Weathered Dagger to D is a pivotal decision in Elden Ring, opening up Fia’s questline, leading to new areas, boss fights, and an alternative ending. While it results in a character’s death, it’s a necessary step to experience the full depth and complexity of the game’s narrative.