Should I Join the Stormcloaks as a High Elf in Skyrim?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether a High Elf (Altmer) should join the Stormcloaks in Skyrim is complex, steeped in lore, and ultimately depends on your roleplaying preferences. The short answer is: it’s complicated, but yes, it can be a valid and engaging choice, provided you’re willing to embrace the contradictions and explore the nuances of such a decision. It requires a deep understanding of the political landscape and a willingness to defy expectations.
Understanding the Political Landscape
Before making this weighty decision, it’s crucial to understand the swirling political currents of Skyrim.
-
The Empire: The once-mighty Empire is in decline, weakened by its defeat in the Great War against the Aldmeri Dominion. It is now forced to abide by the terms of the White-Gold Concordat, which includes a ban on the worship of Talos, a central figure in Nord religion.
-
The Stormcloaks: Led by Ulfric Stormcloak, the Stormcloaks are a rebellion fighting for Skyrim’s independence from the Empire. They oppose the Empire’s concessions to the Thalmor and champion the right to worship Talos freely. While presented as fighting for freedom, the Stormcloak cause often carries undertones of Nord supremacism.
-
The Thalmor: The ruling power of the Aldmeri Dominion, the Thalmor are High Elves who seek to maintain their dominance over Tamriel. They aim to dismantle the Empire and exploit the ensuing chaos to further their own agenda. As highlighted in various in-game documents, the Thalmor are arguably playing both sides, discreetly supporting the Stormcloaks’ rebellion to destabilize the Empire.
The Contradiction: High Elf and Stormcloak
On the surface, a High Elf joining the Stormcloaks seems paradoxical. Nords harbor deep-seated resentment toward the Altmer, stemming from historical conflicts and the Empire’s defeat at the hands of the Aldmeri Dominion. The Stormcloak cause, with its focus on Nord tradition and independence, seems inherently at odds with the goals of the Thalmor, or any High Elf.
However, this very contradiction makes for a compelling roleplaying experience. Here’s how it can work:
-
Defiance of the Thalmor: Not all High Elves agree with the Thalmor’s agenda. A High Elf character might believe the Thalmor’s methods are tyrannical and detrimental to the long-term stability of Tamriel. Joining the Stormcloaks can be an act of rebellion against their own society, a rejection of the Thalmor’s ideology.
-
A Pragmatic Approach: A High Elf may join the Stormcloaks out of pragmatism. They might believe that an independent Skyrim, even one initially hostile to elves, is preferable to an Empire controlled by the Thalmor. They could see the Stormcloaks as a necessary evil to break the Thalmor’s grip on power, with a long-term vision to shape Skyrim’s future.
-
Personal Redemption: A High Elf might be seeking redemption for past actions or for the perceived sins of their race. By fighting alongside the Stormcloaks, they can prove their loyalty to Skyrim and earn the respect of the Nords, even if it’s a difficult and uphill battle.
Roleplaying Opportunities
Embracing this contradiction opens up numerous roleplaying avenues:
-
The Infiltrator: A High Elf could be secretly working for the Thalmor, using the Stormcloaks to destabilize Skyrim before betraying them at a crucial moment.
-
The Reformer: The High Elf could aim to moderate the Stormcloaks’ more extreme views, promoting tolerance and cooperation between races in an independent Skyrim.
-
The Exile: Fleeing persecution or disagreeing with the Thalmor’s policies, a High Elf could see the Stormcloaks as the only available option for survival and a chance to build a new life.
Gameplay Considerations
Joining the Stormcloaks as a High Elf impacts your gameplay experience:
-
Dialogue and Interactions: Expect prejudice and suspicion from many Nords. You’ll need to work harder to earn their trust and prove your loyalty.
-
Quest Choices: Your allegiance to the Stormcloaks will influence your quest choices and the outcome of the Civil War.
-
Moral Dilemmas: You’ll face numerous moral dilemmas as you navigate the complex political landscape and grapple with the consequences of your actions.
Ultimately, choosing to join the Stormcloaks as a High Elf is a bold move. However, by embracing the contradictions and exploring the rich lore of Skyrim, you can create a unique and rewarding character arc. It’s a testament to the depth of the game that such a seemingly incongruous choice can be a source of compelling gameplay.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is it lore-accurate for a High Elf to join the Stormcloaks?
Yes, though counterintuitive, it can be lore-accurate. Thalmor documents suggest they favor the Stormcloaks’ rebellion to weaken the Empire. A High Elf could align with the Stormcloaks to defy the Thalmor, destabilize the region further for personal gain, or with the goal to manipulate and control the situation later on.
2. Do the Stormcloaks hate all Elves?
Generally, yes. The Stormcloaks, particularly the more nationalistic Nords, harbor prejudice against Elves, mainly stemming from historical conflicts and the recent Great War. However, they are more accepting of those who actively fight for their cause.
3. Will my High Elf character be treated differently if I join the Stormcloaks?
Absolutely. Expect suspicion, hostility, and prejudice from many Nords. You’ll need to work harder to prove your loyalty and earn their respect. Dialogue options and interactions will reflect this racial tension.
4. What are the benefits of joining the Stormcloaks as a High Elf?
The benefits are primarily roleplaying-based. It allows for a unique and challenging character arc, exploring themes of prejudice, loyalty, and redemption. Gameplay-wise, you’ll experience the Stormcloak questline and its impact on Skyrim’s political landscape.
5. Are there any specific quests or events that are different for a High Elf in the Stormcloaks?
There are no specific quests designed solely for a High Elf Stormcloak. However, your race will influence dialogue and interactions throughout the questline, affecting your ability to persuade characters and navigate certain situations.
6. How can I make my High Elf Stormcloak character more believable?
Focus on your character’s motivations. Are they defying the Thalmor? Seeking redemption? Exploiting the situation for personal gain? Develop a backstory that explains their decision to join the Stormcloaks and informs their actions.
7. What skills and attributes should I focus on for a High Elf Stormcloak?
This depends on your preferred playstyle. Skills like Speech can help you navigate prejudiced dialogue. Combat skills are essential for fighting alongside the Stormcloaks. Magic skills can be useful, especially if your character is a battlemage.
8. Is it possible to roleplay a Thalmor agent infiltrating the Stormcloaks?
Yes! This is a compelling roleplaying opportunity. You could secretly work to undermine the Stormcloaks and destabilize Skyrim further for the Thalmor’s benefit.
9. Will joining the Stormcloaks as a High Elf affect my relationship with other factions?
It will likely worsen your relationship with the Empire and may complicate interactions with other factions that support the Empire. Your relationship with the Thalmor will depend on your roleplaying choices.
10. Can I still worship Talos as a High Elf in the Stormcloaks?
Yes. The Stormcloaks fight for the right to worship Talos freely. However, doing so as a High Elf is a provocative act that highlights your defiance of the Thalmor and your commitment to the Stormcloak cause.
11. How does race affect gameplay in Skyrim?
Your race affects your starting skills, racial abilities, and dialogue options. High Elves start with a bonus to Magicka and the Highborn power, which grants increased Magicka regeneration. However, the impact of race diminishes as you level up and develop your character.
12. Can I change my race in Skyrim?
Not without using mods or console commands (on PC). Once you choose your race at the beginning of the game, it cannot be changed through in-game means.
13. Where can I learn more about the lore of The Elder Scrolls?
The Elder Scrolls Wiki is a comprehensive resource for lore. Also, playing the previous Elder Scrolls games provides valuable context. Furthermore, you could connect with other fans online. You could even consider studying similar learning themes in real-world scenarios as highlighted by experts at the Games Learning Society and explore the educational aspects of gaming at GamesLearningSociety.org.
14. Is Ulfric Stormcloak a bad guy?
Whether Ulfric is a “bad guy” is subjective and depends on your perspective. He is a complex character with valid grievances against the Empire, but his methods are often questionable, and his cause is tainted by Nord supremacism.
15. Which side should I choose in the Skyrim Civil War?
The choice is entirely up to you and your character’s motivations. There is no objectively “right” or “wrong” choice. Consider the consequences of each side winning and how it aligns with your roleplaying goals.