Should You Pull for Shenhe or Ganyu in Genshin Impact? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question for Genshin Impact players resurfaces every time these two Cryo powerhouses appear on a banner: Should I pull for Shenhe or Ganyu? The answer, as always, depends on your specific needs, team composition, and personal playstyle preferences.
In short:
- Pull for Shenhe if: You are a dedicated Ayaka or Ganyu main and want to maximize their damage potential, especially in Mono-Cryo teams. You value buffing and support capabilities over raw damage output. You enjoy building and optimizing characters with specific team roles.
- Pull for Ganyu if: You need a versatile Cryo DPS character who can function well in both Melt and Freeze teams. You prefer a more straightforward playstyle with powerful charged attacks. You are looking for a character who can deal significant damage without heavy reliance on specific supports (though supports certainly amplify her power). You lack a strong main DPS.
Essentially, Shenhe is a specialized support, an amplifier of Cryo damage. Ganyu is a powerhouse DPS who can carry teams. Let’s delve into the specifics and dissect why each character shines in their respective roles.
Understanding Shenhe: The Cryo Amplifier
Shenhe’s primary role is to boost the Cryo damage of your team. Her Elemental Skill, Spring Spirit Summoning, grants the Icy Quill effect, which adds bonus Cryo DMG to your characters’ attacks that deal Cryo damage. This effect is potent, especially for characters like Ayaka and Ganyu, whose kits revolve around dealing consistent Cryo damage. Shenhe’s Elemental Burst, Divine Maiden’s Deliverance, creates a field that reduces the Cryo and Physical RES of enemies within, further enhancing Cryo damage.
Shenhe’s Strengths:
- Massive Cryo DMG Boost: Icy Quills and her Burst provide significant damage buffs to Cryo DPS characters.
- Cryo Battery: Shenhe helps generate energy for other Cryo characters, ensuring smooth Burst rotations.
- Mono-Cryo Team Synergy: She excels in teams composed primarily of Cryo characters, amplifying their combined damage output.
- Versatile Artifact Builds: While specific sets are optimal, she can function well with various artifact combinations depending on your team’s needs.
Shenhe’s Weaknesses:
- Specialized Role: Her buffs primarily benefit Cryo damage, making her less useful in teams with diverse elemental compositions.
- Resource Intensive: Optimizing Shenhe requires good artifacts and understanding of her mechanics.
- Not a DPS: Shenhe herself doesn’t deal significant damage, relying on her teammates to capitalize on her buffs.
Understanding Ganyu: The Cryo Queen
Ganyu is a versatile Cryo DPS character capable of dealing massive damage through her charged attacks and Elemental Burst. Her charged attacks, specifically Frostflake Arrows, deal AoE Cryo damage and are the core of her DPS potential. Her Elemental Burst, Celestial Shower, rains down icicles that deal Cryo damage to enemies in a large area, providing consistent Cryo application and damage.
Ganyu’s Strengths:
- High DPS Potential: Her charged attacks and Burst deal substantial damage, making her a powerful DPS.
- Versatile Team Compositions: Ganyu can function well in both Melt and Freeze teams.
- Easy to Use: Her charged attack playstyle is relatively straightforward, making her accessible to players of all skill levels.
- AoE Damage: Her Frostflake Arrows and Burst deal significant damage to multiple enemies.
Ganyu’s Weaknesses:
- Charged Attack Playstyle: Some players find her charged attack playstyle repetitive or clunky, particularly on mobile.
- Aiming Required: Accurate aiming is crucial for maximizing her damage output.
- Vulnerable While Charging: She is vulnerable to interruption while charging her Frostflake Arrows, necessitating the use of shields or crowd control.
Team Composition Considerations
Your existing team composition significantly influences whether you should pull for Shenhe or Ganyu.
- If you already have Ayaka as your main DPS: Shenhe is an excellent addition to your team, boosting Ayaka’s damage significantly.
- If you lack a strong DPS character: Ganyu is a solid choice who can carry your team through challenging content.
- If you enjoy Freeze teams: Both Shenhe and Ganyu can contribute to Freeze teams, but Ganyu’s consistent Cryo application makes her a more natural fit as the primary DPS.
- If you enjoy Melt teams: Ganyu is a powerhouse in Melt teams, where her charged attacks trigger powerful Melt reactions.
Final Verdict
Ultimately, the decision to pull for Shenhe or Ganyu depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you prioritize maximizing the damage of your existing Cryo DPS characters and enjoy optimizing support builds, Shenhe is the better choice. If you need a versatile and powerful Cryo DPS character who can function well in various team compositions, Ganyu is the better choice. Consider your current team composition, playstyle preferences, and available resources before making your decision. Remember that character showcases and trial runs are excellent ways to experience a character’s gameplay firsthand before committing your Primogems.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Shenhe pair well with Ganyu?
Yes, Shenhe and Ganyu synergize incredibly well. Shenhe’s Icy Quill effect significantly boosts Ganyu’s Cryo damage output, making them a formidable duo in Mono-Cryo teams.
2. Is it worth pulling for Ganyu in 2024?
Yes, Ganyu remains a powerful and versatile DPS character in 2024. Her charged attack playstyle is still effective, and her Elemental Burst provides consistent Cryo application and damage.
3. Is Ayaka stronger than Ganyu?
The debate between Ayaka and Ganyu is ongoing. Ayaka excels in Freeze teams with her consistent Cryo application and powerful Burst damage. Ganyu is more versatile, functioning well in both Melt and Freeze teams with her charged attacks. The “stronger” character depends on the specific team composition and encounter.
4. Should I pull Ayaka or Shenhe?
If you already have a strong DPS character (not necessarily Ayaka), pull for Shenhe to amplify their damage. If you lack a strong DPS character, pull for Ayaka. They work exceptionally well together.
5. Who should I use Shenhe with?
Shenhe’s best teammates are Cryo DPS characters like Ayaka and Ganyu. Other suitable teammates include characters who can consistently apply Cryo, such as Rosaria and Kaeya.
6. Is Shenhe or Kazuha better?
Shenhe and Kazuha fulfill different roles. Shenhe is a Cryo damage amplifier, while Kazuha is a general damage buffer and crowd controller. The “better” character depends on your team’s needs.
7. Who is the best Cryo DPS?
Ganyu and Ayaka are generally considered the top Cryo DPS characters. The best choice depends on your preferred playstyle and team composition.
8. Do I need Ganyu if I have Ayaka?
It depends. If you are satisfied with Ayaka as your sole Cryo DPS, you don’t need Ganyu. However, Ganyu offers a different playstyle and team composition options, making her a valuable addition to your roster.
9. Should I pull Ganyu or Baizhu?
If you need a strong DPS, pull for Ganyu. If you need a strong Dendro support and healer, especially for Hyperbloom teams, pull for Baizhu.
10. Why is Ganyu so hard to use?
Ganyu’s difficulty stems primarily from her charged attack playstyle, which requires accurate aiming and positioning. Players who struggle with aiming or prefer a more mobile playstyle may find her challenging.
11. Should I pull for Zhongli or Ganyu?
If you struggle with survivability or prefer a more comfortable gameplay experience, pull for Zhongli. His shield provides significant protection and reduces enemy RES. If you need a strong DPS, pull for Ganyu.
12. Who works good with Ganyu?
Ganyu’s best teammates include:
- Shenhe: Cryo damage amplifier
- Xiangling: Pyro applicator for Melt teams
- Bennett: Attack buffer and healer for Melt teams
- Mona/Kokomi: Hydro applicators for Freeze teams
- Kazuha/Venti: Crowd control and damage amplification
13. What is the best F2P team for Ganyu?
A viable F2P team for Ganyu could include:
- Ganyu (DPS)
- Xiangling (Pyro Sub-DPS/Enabler)
- Bennett (Healer/Buffer)
- Diona (Shielder/Healer/Cryo Resonance)
14. Is Ayaka weaker than Ganyu?
This is subjective and depends on the situation. As mentioned previously, Ayaka excels in Freeze teams due to the consistency in applying Cryo.
15. Can I play Ganyu without Zhongli?
Yes, Ganyu can be played effectively without Zhongli. However, his shield provides valuable protection against interruptions, making her charged attack playstyle more comfortable. Alternatives to Zhongli include other shielders like Diona, Layla, and Thoma.
The world of Genshin Impact is always evolving, and the characters are constantly being analyzed, so it’s important to do your research, understand your account, and have fun! Consider looking into resources like the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org for community insights into gaming and learning.