Should I Report Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The decision of whether or not to report Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy is a complex moral dilemma presented to the player, impacting the game’s ending and your character’s relationship with certain individuals. There is no inherently “right” or “wrong” choice, as the consequences reflect the player’s own moral compass and desire for a specific narrative outcome.
Understanding the Context: Sebastian’s Story Arc
Sebastian Sallow’s narrative is a central and often controversial element of Hogwarts Legacy. He introduces the player to the Dark Arts, initially framed as a means to protect themselves and solve the mystery surrounding Anne Sallow’s curse. However, his increasing reliance on forbidden magic, disregard for established rules, and ultimately, his involvement in accidental fatal outcomes, creates a compelling and morally challenging situation. The player is forced to confront their own beliefs about justice, forgiveness, and the potential for redemption.
Sebastian’s motivations stem from a deep-seated love for his twin sister, Anne, and a desperate desire to lift the curse plaguing her. He believes that the Dark Arts hold the key to saving her, even if it means resorting to dangerous and ethically questionable practices. This creates a sense of empathy for his character, making the decision to report him all the more difficult.
The Consequences of Your Choice
Reporting Sebastian to Professor Weasley at the end of his quest line has significant ramifications:
- Sebastian’s Expulsion: This is the most immediate and obvious consequence. He is expelled from Hogwarts, effectively ending his academic career.
- Loss of Companion: You will no longer be able to interact with Sebastian as a companion. His presence will be absent from Hogwarts Castle, and you won’t be able to call on him for assistance during your adventures.
- Altered Ending: Reporting Sebastian will impact the final cutscenes and epilogue of the game, providing a significantly different conclusion to his personal story arc and his relationships with other characters.
- Impact on Relationship with Ominis Gaunt: Ominis is staunchly against the use of Dark Arts, and his friendship with Sebastian is strained by his actions. Reporting Sebastian is likely to improve your relationship with Ominis, while supporting Sebastian further isolates Ominis.
- Moral Alignment: The decision to report or not to report also reflects the player’s in-game moral alignment. Reporting him could be viewed as upholding justice and adhering to the rules, while choosing not to report him could be interpreted as prioritizing friendship and understanding.
Arguments for Reporting Sebastian
Several factors might influence your decision to report Sebastian:
- Severity of his actions: Sebastian’s use of unforgivable curses and his involvement in the accidental death of his uncle is a serious offense, warranting punishment.
- Maintaining order and safety: Reporting Sebastian sends a clear message that the Dark Arts are not to be taken lightly and that those who misuse them will be held accountable.
- Protecting others: By reporting Sebastian, you may prevent him from further endangering himself and others with his reckless pursuit of forbidden magic.
- Upholding the law: Reporting Sebastian is in accordance with Hogwarts rules and Ministry of Magic regulations, ensuring that justice is served.
- Preventing Future Harm: Reporting Sebastian removes him from a position where he can further experiment with dark magic, and potentially harm other students and staff.
Arguments Against Reporting Sebastian
Conversely, some arguments support choosing not to report Sebastian:
- His motivations: His actions, however misguided, stem from a deep love for his sister and a desperate attempt to save her life.
- Potential for redemption: Some believe that Sebastian could eventually learn from his mistakes and find a way to use his knowledge of the Dark Arts for good.
- Friendship and loyalty: Reporting a friend, even one who has made grave errors, can be a difficult decision, especially if you value your relationship with him.
- Belief in forgiveness: Some players might believe that Sebastian deserves a second chance and that expulsion is too harsh a punishment for his actions.
- Impact on Anne: Reporting Sebastian could further devastate Anne, who is already suffering from her curse.
- No one gets hurt: If you were to help Sebastian and no one else was to get hurt, the act of reporting him might not be required.
The Gray Area of Morality
Ultimately, the choice of whether to report Sebastian comes down to your personal interpretation of the situation and your character’s values. The game excels in presenting a morally ambiguous scenario where there is no easy answer. By weighing the consequences and considering the various perspectives, you can make a decision that aligns with your understanding of justice, friendship, and the complexities of the magical world.
Final Thoughts
There is no perfect solution to the Sebastian Sallow dilemma. He made bad choices in the game, and it is up to you to make the decision whether to report him or not. You’ll be the only one to live with the consequences. It is important to consider your own moral compass when deciding how to deal with this situation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens if I don’t report Sebastian?
If you choose not to report Sebastian, he is not expelled from Hogwarts immediately after the quests. You will retain the ability to speak with him at his location at Hogwarts. However, his future remains uncertain, and he will still bear the consequences of his actions, leading to a more ambiguous and possibly bittersweet ending. The relationship with Ominis becomes more strained.
2. Can I change my decision after I’ve made it?
No, the decision of whether or not to report Sebastian is final. Once you’ve made your choice, it cannot be reversed, so consider your options carefully before making a decision.
3. Does reporting Sebastian affect my ability to learn Dark Arts spells?
No, reporting or not reporting Sebastian does not directly affect your ability to learn Dark Arts spells. You can still learn them from him regardless of your final decision.
4. Does reporting Sebastian affect the overall ending of the game beyond his personal story?
While the main storyline of the game remains largely unchanged, reporting Sebastian does have an impact on the epilogue and final scenes, offering a different perspective on the consequences of your choices and the fates of other characters involved.
5. Is there a “good” or “bad” ending associated with reporting or not reporting Sebastian?
There is no definitive “good” or “bad” ending. The outcome is subjective and depends on your moral perspective and what you consider to be the most fitting resolution to Sebastian’s story arc.
6. Does reporting Sebastian make me a “good” or “bad” character?
Reporting Sebastian does not automatically define your character as “good” or “bad.” It simply reflects your decision based on the available information and your personal values. The game allows for moral ambiguity, and the player’s motivations are what truly matter.
7. Can I still be friends with Ominis if I don’t report Sebastian?
Maintaining a strong friendship with Ominis becomes more challenging if you choose not to report Sebastian, as Ominis is vehemently opposed to the Dark Arts. However, it’s still possible to maintain a cordial relationship, although their bond might be strained.
8. Will Anne ever be cured, regardless of my choice?
The game offers no definitive cure for Anne’s curse. While Sebastian continues to search for a solution, her condition remains unchanged throughout the game.
9. Can I use Unforgivable Curses even if I report Sebastian?
Yes, you can still use Unforgivable Curses even if you report Sebastian. Your decision regarding him doesn’t restrict your combat abilities or spell choices.
10. Does my House (Gryffindor, Slytherin, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw) affect my decision on whether to report Sebastian?
Your House selection does not directly influence the decision to report Sebastian. The choice is based on your personal moral compass and how you perceive the events unfolding in the game.
11. Can I replay Sebastian’s quests to see both outcomes?
To experience both outcomes, you would need to replay the game from a save point before the final decision regarding Sebastian.
12. Does reporting Sebastian affect my relationship with other Hogwarts professors or students?
Your decision might subtly influence your standing with certain characters who have strong opinions about the Dark Arts. However, it generally doesn’t have a major impact on your overall relationships with most professors and students.
13. What happens to the knowledge Sebastian shared about the Dark Arts after he’s reported?
The knowledge you acquired from Sebastian about the Dark Arts remains with you, regardless of whether you report him.
14. Is there any hidden content or secret quests unlocked by reporting or not reporting Sebastian?
There are no known hidden quests or secret content exclusively unlocked by either reporting or not reporting Sebastian. The primary impact is on his personal narrative and the game’s ending.
15. Does Sebastian ever express regret for his actions?
Depending on your choices and dialogue options, Sebastian may express varying degrees of regret for his actions. However, his remorse is often tempered by his unwavering determination to save Anne. His true feelings towards the situation are often up to the player’s interpretation.