Should I Sell or Dismantle Armor in The Witcher 3? A Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question for any budding Witcher: should you sell or dismantle armor in The Witcher 3? The short answer is that it’s usually more beneficial to dismantle armor, especially low-level or common pieces, to obtain crafting materials. Selling is generally better for high-value, unique armor pieces that you won’t be using. However, understanding the nuances can significantly impact your wealth and crafting capabilities throughout the game. This guide will help you make the best decisions for your Geralt.
Dismantling vs. Selling: Understanding the Core Mechanics
The Witcher 3’s economy and crafting system are deeply intertwined. Efficient resource management is key to upgrading your gear, brewing potions, and crafting bombs. Therefore, understanding the value of both dismantling and selling is crucial.
The Power of Dismantling
Dismantling armor breaks it down into its constituent components. These components are vital for crafting better armor, weapons, and other items. Common materials obtained from dismantling include:
- Leather Scraps and Hardened Leather: Used extensively in crafting various armors.
- Iron Ingots and Steel Ingots: Essential for crafting swords and armor.
- Cloth: Necessary for some armor pieces and other crafting recipes.
- Monster-specific Parts: Rarely found from armor, but sometimes present if the armor is made from monster components.
Why Dismantling is Often the Superior Choice:
- Crafting Materials are Valuable: Crafting materials become increasingly difficult and expensive to acquire as you progress through the game. Dismantling provides a steady, reliable source of these materials.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Buying crafting materials from vendors can quickly drain your coin. Dismantling is a free alternative.
- Future-Proofing: Even seemingly useless materials early on can become essential for crafting high-level Witcher gear or grandmaster sets.
The Allure of Selling
Selling armor provides an immediate influx of crowns, the game’s currency. This is particularly useful early in the game when you’re strapped for cash.
When Selling Makes Sense:
- High-Value, Unique Armor: Certain unique or rare armor pieces can fetch a significant price from vendors. If you’re confident you won’t need them for crafting or alternative builds, selling them is a viable option. Examples include relic items with high base values.
- Overflow of Materials: If you’ve been diligently dismantling and accumulating a surplus of crafting materials, selling common armor might be a good way to clear inventory space and earn some extra coin.
- Immediate Need for Crowns: There may be times when you desperately need crowns for a specific purchase, such as a Witcher gear diagram or a rune. Selling valuable armor can provide the necessary funds.
Maximizing Your Profits and Crafting Potential
To effectively manage your armor, consider these strategies:
- Prioritize Dismantling Low-Level Gear: Early in the game, dismantle almost all common armor you find. The materials you gain will be far more valuable than the paltry sum you’d receive from selling it.
- Identify Key Crafting Materials: Focus on acquiring materials that are consistently used in crafting, such as leather, iron, and steel.
- Track Your Needs: As you progress, pay attention to the materials you’re consistently short on. Adjust your dismantling habits accordingly.
- Use Vendors Strategically: Don’t sell everything to the first vendor you encounter. Different vendors offer varying prices. Armorers typically give the best prices for armor, while Blacksmiths offer better prices for weapons.
- Invest in Inventory Capacity: Early on, invest in saddlebags to increase Roach’s inventory capacity. This will allow you to carry more loot, including armor for dismantling, without becoming encumbered.
When to Break the Rules
While the general guideline favors dismantling, there are exceptions. Certain unique or aesthetically pleasing armor pieces might be worth keeping for fashion purposes, even if their stats aren’t optimal. Ultimately, the decision depends on your playstyle and priorities.
The Role of Merchants
Certain merchants offer better prices or unique services. Specifically, look for blacksmiths and armorers that can provide a larger payout.
- Armorers: Primarily give you the best price for armor.
- Blacksmiths: Will usually give a higher price for weapons.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is it ever worth selling common armor early in the game?
Not usually. The small amount of crowns you receive is outweighed by the value of the crafting materials you’d obtain from dismantling.
2. What are the best materials to look for when dismantling armor?
Leather scraps, hardened leather, iron ingots, and steel ingots are the most commonly used crafting materials.
3. How do I know which armor pieces are worth selling?
Check the sale price offered by vendors. If an armor piece is worth a significantly higher amount than others, it’s likely a good candidate for selling. Also, if it is unique and you won’t use it.
4. Should I dismantle Witcher gear?
Never! Witcher gear is specifically designed to be upgraded. Dismantling Witcher gear would waste valuable components. Keep it, upgrade it, or sell only after replacing it with a higher-tier version.
5. Where can I find the best vendors for selling armor?
Armorers, particularly in major cities like Novigrad and Oxenfurt, usually offer the best prices for armor.
6. Does difficulty level affect the value of dismantling vs. selling?
No, difficulty level doesn’t directly impact the value proposition. However, on higher difficulties, the need for crafting materials becomes more pronounced, making dismantling even more beneficial.
7. Can I get rare crafting materials from dismantling armor?
Rare materials are unlikely to be found from dismantling regular armor. They are usually obtained from dismantling monster parts, quest rewards, or rare loot.
8. What’s the best way to manage my inventory when carrying lots of armor?
Invest in saddlebags to increase Roach’s carrying capacity. Regularly visit vendors or crafting stations to sell or dismantle unwanted items.
9. Is there a specific skill that improves dismantling yields?
No, there isn’t a skill that directly improves dismantling yields. However, certain skills can make you wealthier, indirectly affecting your ability to buy materials if you choose not to dismantle.
10. How does crafting level influence my dismantling decisions?
At higher crafting levels, the demand for specific materials increases significantly. This makes dismantling even more crucial for acquiring the necessary components.
11. Should I keep duplicate armor pieces?
Generally, no. Unless you’re specifically collecting armor for aesthetic purposes, there’s no need to keep duplicate pieces. Dismantle or sell them.
12. What happens if I accidentally dismantle a valuable item?
Unfortunately, there’s no way to undo dismantling. Be cautious and double-check before dismantling any item.
13. Does repairing armor before selling it increase its value?
Yes, repairing armor before selling it will increase its value slightly. However, the cost of repairs may outweigh the increase in selling price, especially for lower-level armor.
14. Are there any armor pieces that are purely for cosmetic purposes?
Yes, some armor pieces, particularly those found in DLCs or as quest rewards, are primarily for cosmetic purposes and offer minimal stat bonuses. Whether to sell or dismantle them depends on your personal preference.
15. Does selling armor to a particular vendor improve my reputation with them?
No, selling armor or any items doesn’t directly affect your reputation with vendors. There is no vendor reputation system in The Witcher 3. Their prices stay the same.
By following these guidelines and considering your own playstyle, you can make informed decisions about whether to sell or dismantle armor in The Witcher 3, optimizing your wealth and crafting potential throughout your adventure. Happy hunting, Witcher!